The only thing I ever ate from Smuckers is there Jams/Jellies.
For regular, PB - Is Skippy & Jiff ... Skippy is more sugary/sweet IMO & jiff more salty
I eat Presidents Choice ANPB (until SBT hooked me up, going to buy some more right now

)
Plain ANPB is good cold where it's not creamy. When it's warm it reminds me of, well, think an ill bad baby making a mess in a diaper. LOL
I prefer crunchy (ANPB!!!!!!!!)
Cinn Raisin Swirl is also good chilled, hunks of raisin and grainy. Tastes like cookie dough.
White Chocolate ANPB also tastes like a form of cookie Dough, and it's really good.
Pumpkin Pie ANPB tastes like a notassweet pumpkin pie, but it's still quite edible.
The PB's are going to be the death of me lol, but on my low carb days I can have 2 tbsp with 3-5 meals a day and it just works for my #'s

If I end up getting sick of it, that is NOT a bad thing. I always have almonds & walnuts to fall back on