I thought there was a concensus reached here fifteen times that everyone has individual biochemical and hormonal levels as well as a differing response to types of macronutrients. There is no definative science proving lo carb or lo fat, or the berardi style eating. For that matter if the lo carb type diet was the "Correct" solution then wouldn't all asian people, who eat mainly rice and vegetables with occasional meats, be obese?
I belive in eating whole foods as much as I can, just because 2 products have the same macro nutrient breakdown doesn't mean they are anywhere near the same as far as micronutrient content or digestability. In american grocery stores it is easy to be overfed and malnourished at the same time. Take for instance bread, even the whole wheat bread. By law it need only contain 1% whole wheat flour to be considered whole wheat. Also the ones that do use 100% whole wheat are sweeted with high fructose corn syrup and use hydrogenated oils.
Some people may say this is ridiculous but when I am paying attention to my diet, I buy my meat from a butcher shop that uses beef with no hormones, I buy my breads from a family baker who is certified organic and who uses no refined ingrediants. I get all the rest of my carbs from a health fod store that specializes in natural and organic foods. The do not sell products that have been processed or altered. It may seem irrational but I can eat like a human being is meant to eat ( consume a normal amount of all three macronutrients) and still lose weight and get stronger.