Bran987 said:
why does everyone still say "yeah but real food is better"
There's a lot of good reasons why real food is better. 1st, real food has a much higher thermic effect. This means it requires more energy to digest and process real food than liquids, which in turn means more calories expended on real food (however insignificant it may be).
2nd, real food, and I'm talking clean foods, usually have better vitamins, minerals, and nutrients in them. No need to explain that.
3rd, at least personally, real food is MUCH more filling. I, however, throw in psyllium husk into all of my shakes to help with feelings of fullness.
Real food is sometimes cheaper. This is debatable, especially depending on choice in protein sources. Also, real food has more variety than just a protein shake. Sure, you can throw crap in your protein shake, but cooking something to your liking is a little different. I don't know if that came out right, but you know what I mean.
I'm sure there are more reasons why real food is better, but those are some of the biggest reasons why I prefer real food.