This is no problem at all. I had 3 girlfriends show up at the same club to see me. This is what you do.
Speech #1 intended for GF#1 :
"Hey baby, I want to treat you right on Valentines day but it's impossible to get reservations at a nice restaurant and I really want to treat you nice and spend lots of time with you (blah blah blah) so why don't we celebrate on Febuary 13th ? "
Speech #2 intended for GF#2 :
"Hey baby, I want to treat you right on Valentines day but it's impossible to get reservations at a nice restaurant and I really want to treat you nice and spend lots of time with you (blah blah blah) so why don't we celebrate on Febuary 15th ? "
On valentines day tell them both some sob story about how a friend of yours got dumped by his GF and he really loved her so his guy friends are taking him out to get him all wasted....no girls allowed. You have to hold your ground on this one. You feel bad, but you really have to be there for this friend of yours, and who cares which day you celebrate Valentines day anyway? Febuary 14th was just chosen by the card companies!!!!
See. Even you believe it. I'm here all week.
Socules, Gymguryl...you're both really hot.
i'm out.