Update...
Went back for the follow up, they sent me to the surgeon who said he wanted to remove a little more just to be sure. I thought, okay no big deal...
He took skin off the size of a 50 cent piece, then lopped off some cartilege to make the shape right, pulled the skin together and put 15 stitches in it. I have a really high pain tolerance from training and I'm eating tylenol with codeine like M&M's, got zero sleep last night so he is going to call a percoset script in for me. He took a big chunk off of my shoulder as well but it doesn't hurt. If you just HAVE to tan, again, don't tan your face or your ears cause really girls this is NO fun.