Ever get the feeling Eli Manning is trading on his last name and not much else?

[Lumberg]

If he had a different name, I'm thinking 2nd-4th rounder. I don't think he can live up to his name.

 

[Becoming]

he sux

 

[BileStew]

I am so pissed the Giants let Collins go. They signed that fat QB from kentucky and now considering Neil O'Donnell as a back up to groom Manning.

My prediction and it pains me to say this. 3-13.

 

[Lumberg]

I am so pissed the Giants let Collins go. They signed that fat QB from kentucky and now considering Neil O'Donnell as a back up to groom Manning.

My prediction and it pains me to say this. 3-13.

Jared Lorenszen?

 

[BileStew]

Jared Lorenszen?

Yep..

 

[canadianhitman]

Giants are gonna suck!

 

[big4life]

He's a top ten pick no matter what his name. The thing with quarterbacks is it's such a gamble. I would have a vet. start off the season instead of throwing him to the wolves. That goes for any rookie qb. It's just too big of a jump.

 

[gator_mclusky]

He'll be breaking records lefteand right.

Gator

 

[Lumberg]

He's a top ten pick no matter what his name. The thing with quarterbacks is it's such a gamble. I would have a vet. start off the season instead of throwing him to the wolves. That goes for any rookie qb. It's just too big of a jump.

I think he's a legitimate 1st rounder. But not the best QB in the draft.

Definitely not deserving of being the frst pick overall.