Firstly, Glad is very right in what he just said about goal specificity.
However, I want to address something you said, Josh:
I am not going to speak for EM, but as far as I'm concerned I want to lift for the rest of my life (knock on wood) providing i am capable of doing so. I don't want to force myself into any type of training I don't enjoy doing, because as i said i want lifting to be a longass marathon for me and i want to enjoy every step of the way. I purely just love the feeling i get after/while working out and the aesthetic/strength gains that come with it. I don't want to be a PLer/BBer or anything, but I am looking to learn more about something i love to do (why i am on EF).
I have a great deal of respect for guys like you strive to be the very best you can be, but that's not me- i don't want my schedule everyday to revolve around getting enough food in and shit like that so i see better gains. I'm leaner and stronger than most people i meet, and that's more than sufficient for me.
I am VERY similar to you. I also want to lift for my whole life. But that has nothing to do with not having specific goals. I am not a Powerlifter and I am not a Bodybuilder and I am not a Strongman. I train to get strong. Thats it.
I once met a World War 2 vet when I was training in Dallas. The guy must've been past 85. He was Deadlifting 365. I want to be THAT guy. He was literally a fountain of knowledge and almost EVERYTHING he said is stuff Eric has literally ingrained into my thick skull.
Yes, Josh, we do train because it is fun for us but it must have a purpose. And if there is no goal then you don't need to sweat about a lack of progress. Hell, you don't need a plan and you don't anything. All you need is to be able to go in, lift, feel happy, leave. Why do you need to do anything you do now - write it down, etc?
You've got one foot in the door and the other out.
What I do - the way I train is specifically for longevity. Remember a while ago I got into an argument with Glad in my journal (I think) when I mentioned I want gradual progress? This is why. If you have steady, gradual progress then you're fine. IF you try to rush things and do them quickly you always have a set back. Take yourself for example: you did some stuff, then you did 5/3/1 and now you're weaker. You can blame it on a number of reasons but hey...you're weaker than you were before.
I didn't do Deadlifts for 7 weeks. Infact, I trained minimally for 7 weeks. Did I lose an OUNCE of strength? Nope. I came back and I pulled 455 for doubles and triples. Why? Not because I am genetically gifted (hey...you guys know what I look like: am I really gifted genetically?).
So what I am trying to say (simply) is that you have one foot in the door and the other out. You want to record your training, you want some sort of a plan, you keep hopping between routines, you want to eat better, etc..BUT you don't want any goals because you want to lift for longer. See the problem? You CAN lift all your life, get stronger every year and be better off and not label yourself a powerlifter, strongman or bodybuilder.