"......Well...I have recommended that the program is only to be used twice per year. Joint pain comes for the heavier weights which tax ligiments and tendon strength. You imply that I want people to continue on a program when inflamed joints arise. Please point out where I implied that. So - are you saying that you should avoid an exercise altogether because the joints get sore?? Why not cycle onto another program that incluse them but in a different rep range?? "
If a program is to only be used twice a year...it is not a good program. Louie Simmons says that any program that "works only for a limited time" is not a good one. You are usually growing because of simple change and/or overtraining.
Where do find that Joint pain comes from heavier weights? Joint pain, in this case, probably comes from the fact that you are doing squats, deads, and flat presses 3x per week. The joint never gets a rest. She never said that you should avoid that exercise totally...just NOT 3x per week...and heaven forbid a machine like the Smith Machine. A machine that restricts the joint's movement to a non-natural movement.
"Justification is that I swear I read that he used the term "more compact". To me that that doesn't mean fat loss. If that was inded the case then it was my fault for making the asumption. "
More compact? I am functionally stronger now than I was a year ago.
August, 2000: 275lbs.
December 26th 2000: 305lbs.
I was still doing bodybuilding then...no machines...same garage gym I train in now.
February 2001: 290lbs, getting in better cardio shape.
June 2001: 289, still better cardio shape
October 2001: 280, really focusing on speed strength and cardio
February 2002: 290, super cardio shape AND strength
Current: 285, great shape, getting leaner, strength phase beginning
You do not seem to understand that at 285...my waist is about 4-5" smaller and everything else is the same. Sure, the "pretty" muscles (chest, front delts, quads, etc..) don't look as "pretty", but strength does not lay in those muscles. Strength comes from those muscles that you see from the backsides of a person. I don't train my front delts, upper chest, biceps, quads hardly at all with strongman...I train total functional strength.
BUT...
I have not advocated doing strongman training on this thread at all. I have not suggested doing farmers, yoke walk, harness pulling, hussefeld stone lifting, etc...on this thread. I posted a bodybuilding routine. I posted a routine that took me from 152-305lbs.
"Explain why he is getting stronger yet not gain a lot of weight...most powerflifters get stronger without ever changing weight classes. He is not training for size. He is training for strength - two separate issues. I think that is where some of this miscommunication is coming from. I said this was a great program for size with the added benefit of strength."
I am constantly getting leaner and doing 4 hours of cardio on Sundays don't help too much either. Hard, intense cardio. I lift 2x a week and one day of events...the rest is REST time. Powerlifters don't change weight classes? The strongest powerlifters are USUALLY in the SHW class. A powerlifter, good one anyway, will tell you that if you want to push/pull more weight...get bigger and gain weight.
Your program is good for size and strength? A person can get stronger at concentration curls...but that is not what I consider strength. Smith Squats? Smith Bench? Push-ups on a bench? Gloves, straps, padding the bar while doing squats? One word...KAZ.
"So - you do a program that relies on Squats, deads and presses - same type exercises as what I recommend. It's good that you can alter the w/o every week. That point is really neither here nor there. If a program is working, even doing thwe smae exercises and rep scheme - you should make progress for several weeks in a row."
"I would imagine it's heavy on the basics like the old school program. Squats deads, etc. "
Monday:Squats, Bench, Deads 10 sets of 10
Tues-Sunday: Repeat every day
This program is based on squats, bench, and deadlift...just like mine and hers? What is your point? There is little to no correlation between our programs. Just because they both advocate squats...doesn't mean that they are equal...or even close.
"See - the thing is - he stated that he did indeed gain most of his size by doing a very similar program years ago."
YOU said that, not me. Our programs are similar to the point that we both trained in a gym, that is about where it ended.
"The mis-communication was, if event training made him smaller - why would he not be open to a change, as there is a very BIG difference between maintaining anf actuallt losing size. Again, we have talked about that and I see the reasoning behing it."
Event training did NOT make me smaller. The intense cardio, many other factors in my life, and getting constantly leaner has made me smaller. I still have a 30" thigh, 19+" arms, calves nearing 18", cross striations in my thighs, etc... I train for pure strength and functionality towards my events. Why waste 10 sets for upper chest or outer delts if they don't make a hill of beans difference on contest day?
BUT...
That was not my point...my point is that you are using my strongman training to compare to...my functionality training. I give advice to those wishing to get bigger and stronger...not how to be a strongman. Seems as if your point just doesn't make any sense.
Why will I not try your program? Because I do not wish to lose further strength, overtrain, have an injury, lose speed strength, lose strength speed...and Heaven Forbid if anyone ever sees me on a Smith Machine...unless I am using it to hold by sweaty t-shirts while changing clothes.
I am living proof that peole can gain large amounts of weight, drug free, with very limited equipment. When I gained to 305lbs...I had a bar, semi power rack, 700lbs of 45's, 2 cable pull downs, 2 dbells, and a make-shift chin up bar.
Maybe I am ignorant to the ways of modern day bodybuilding. If modern day bodybuilding revolves around straps, gloves, padding the bar, smith machines, overtraining, etc...I want little to do about it.
I don't give advice to those who just want to look "toned" or anyone who wants to be happy weighing 200lbs. I wanted to be a freak. I wanted freakish size and freakish strength. I've accomplished a lot more of that than the average person I guess...but I didn't get hooked on the cables and machines fad for very long. I have done about every program type in the world. I found which ones had good points and which ones had tons of bad ones.
In our society...we see so many things as "quick and easy, just follow these steps and you can too..." and this is not correct. Find those who are where you want to be and ask questions. Learn from them...and improve simply, basically, and with all that you have.
Ohh...I don't think that I am the ONLY one being closed minded here. Don't think I am being closed minded at all.
B True