That's a false choice. There's a plan C -- let the private sector do its job and provide employment and benefits for more people.
Here's what Barry & Co wrestle with: In order to create those jobs, they're going to have to let a few people get wealthy (or even more wealthy). Providers of capital create jobs when they see an opportunity to make money. If Barry wants to keep kicking capital providers in the shins, they're going to deploy that capital elsewhere.
OBAMA DID NOT CREATE THE CURRENT MESS THE ECONOMY IS IN and it took the previous administration eight years to create it, so why does everyone expect the new guy to fix it in less time than that?
As far as the private sector fixing it, lemme guess, you're an advocate of the Milton Friedman school of economy. Frankly, I believe if left to its own devices, the private sector will just be an absolutely greedy pig. A perfect epitome of "Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely." It needs SOME neutral oversight. You need an impartial third party otherwise, I'm sorry, greed overcomes all. If money is your motivating factor, what motivation do you have for making sure other people have it? And really, if you are rich, you ARE motivated by money.
It's like asking a heroine addict to become a good pharmacist, let's be realistic here.
You know who are the worst tippers (i.e., you go to a restaurant, get a meal, tip the server)? Rich people, seriously. I never worked restaurant, but I've heard the same from numerous people who have. The best tippers are Joe Everyman. The rich are stingy bastards. Really, how the hell do you think they got that way? They only grease a wheel if it will eventually line their pocket. In other words, the motto of the rich is: "Fuck the other guy, I got mine, let him figure out how to get his." Trust me, that philosophy applies to EVERY aspect of their lives. They treat an employee worse than a rental car.
There are people in this world who
do believe that the greatest way to achieve greatness is by helping another achieve their own greatness, first.
Anyway, 80 years or so ago I would have been a New Dealer, and I think Milton Freidman should have kept his opinions to himself.