jestro said:
Honestly, I think there's got to be better punishments than that. My daughter would have to rob a bank or something for me to not let her go trick or treating at 5 years old. There's a real limited number of years that they can enjoy kid stuff. My daughter is 12 and feels like shes too old to go trick or treating, and it is god damn sad for me.
Everyone give HH red.
As a parent you do what you know will work for your child. Each punishment for each child is different. And as a mother, it's my sole responsibility to identify with what will impact her even at 5 years old, to go in the direction she needs to be. If I tell her, if you do this, then this will happen....If I do NOT abide by that then trust, respect, security, love, and honor is NOT instilled in her. Regardless of what YOU do for your child as punishment, you're in no place to instruct or dictate how I should punish mine.
Clearly you don't understand the severity of instilling at a VERY EARLY age, respect and principals. If I allowed her to go trick or treating after 7 weeks of misbehaving at school in the worst way and specifically telling her if your behavior does NOT improve, you will not do this........I would have failed her as a mother.
Your close minded approach speaks volumes for you. Don't think for two seconds I didn't cry my eyes out that night. Even through her 2-3 hour tantrum, I held strong to my word. I could've easily caved. All that would instill in her is that "you know what honey, it's ok to continue acting that way...all you have to do is cry and pitch a fit and you'll get what you want". It's a shame there aren't more parents out there like me who are able to make a decision like that for their child. Trust that, at five years old, she is WELL aware of what is going on. It's her job to push the envelope and test the limits as much as possible. It's my job to teach her where that line of limit falls and to make sure she understands that regardless of her age and actions, she too is responsible.
Clearly that consequence made an impact. Her behavior has significantly improved since. Her teacher has since contacted me saying she was extremely impressed as well as other parties involved.
Too many parents take the easy road these days. It's a shame.