Mr Testosterone - Don't forget that most people on atkins do not want to be body builders. I agree, atkins is not the way to go if you want to look like Fabio.
I'm on Atkins for a few reasons.
1) I'm tired of being unhealthy
2) Genetically i'm high risk for heart disease, diabeties and cancer
3) My major is Criminal Justice and by job will require being physically sound.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with being on Atkins. There isn't a single documented case where an Atkins patient suffered kidney failure, heart disease, or any nutritional deficency while eating the Atkins way.
If being on Atkins for over a year was so bad, then there would be 10's of thousands of people dropping dead. Atkins isn't really a diet, its a change in life long habits. If your "on" Atkins, your never off.