that is utter nonsense! Are you listening to what you are saying? burning calories on a treadmill does not make a difference? All these things workit is simply a matter of intensity, length of exercise, fasted state. You can switch all those variables around but ultimately you are burning calories and that means losing weight if your diet is correct. different folks prefer different methods but that is what is is, a preference. As for the lifting weights method, i already lift weights and want to burn MORE calories, i hope nelson is not suggesting that i overtrain to accomplish this. If you want to control your weight with weight training and diet alone, no probem, that is your preference. Some of us chose to add additional exercise to speed up the process as well as to reap the additional benefits.
jb