b fold the truth said:
I agree....
AND...science isn't EVER going to figure out the BEST way to train because it is always changing. It changes for every person and even THAT changes quickly.
I would have to respectfully disagree here...
I think some things are person-specific. Some guys are more or less capable in the following areas:
1. Robustness of joints and susceptability to injury
2. Rate of muscle gain
3. CNS overtraining threshhold, ie. if someone did 10 sets to failure every single day, how fast he would start to be overtrained relative to another guy.
But in terms of muscle growth, I believe it is far more cut and dry. It's more of a physiology issue. In terms of muscle growth, HST and DFHT, and to a slightly lesser extent DC (since it's concentrates a little more on strength gains) have discovered the fastest way we know of to build muscle tissue. Now as we learn more, these program might evolve slightly, but since it's based on concepts of the human body I don't think they'll change significantly any time soon.
With regards to the best strength gain program, Westside seems to be pretty darn close. The reason this is up in the air more is, IMO, for the following reasons:
1. Although we know that total strength is a resultant of a couple factors (power/speed, pure strength etc.),
2. The best way to develop each of these factors is a little bit harder to figure out. It's easier to figure out in a lab how muscle grows, it's harder to figure out how strength develops.
This is where the person-specific factors come in. Some guy might be able to produce more strength on a certain protocol because of his genetics and structure than another guy. That guy might be better suited towards a different program that takes advantage of HIS attributes. Some guys can handle all the Metal Militia volume, some guys will get overtrained quickly, etc.
Last, some programs might generate more speed but less progressive overload, and vice versa. Since both these factors contribute to strength, it is hard to come up with an absolute "best way" to gaining strength.