I find this thread and debate very interesting. It reminds me that there is a rep calculator over at huskerpower.com, and I have for some time thought that the calculator was off, at least for me. It must be set up for someone with average fast and slow twitch ratios. For example last night for my max effort movement I repped out with 225, and did 17 reps. I knew this was pretty pitiful, but went to the rep calculator just to see what it thought.
According to huskerpower I have about a 330 bench. Well that is all well and good, except for the fact that I went well above that this past Saturday for warmups before my bench meet. So I know for an absolute fact that this rep calculator is grossly off, at least for me.
In order for the rep calculator to give me credit for a weight that I have done in training, raw, and not going to 100 percent, I would have to have done 225 like 25 or 26 times. I know for certain that I could not get close to that even if I trained for reps. Note that I have not done more than 3 reps with a barbell on the bench in over 7 months.
I don't think I could get more than 3 or 4 reps with 80 percent of my max. I may try that for a max effort exercise after my next meet and see for sure.
Good thread.
B