Could Peyton Manning become the best QB to ever play the game?

[gjohnson5]

I don't judge quarterbacks by rings , so he is much higher on my scale

Can't be considered for anywhere near The Best, however;


As naturally talented as ANY QB to put on the uniform.........yes, better than Vick............he just suffered from poor team drafting, poor teams, and injuries.

He was in a league all by himself.

 

[test boy ii]

Phil Simms said Elway was the most physically talented QB in the game.

I respect the brains of Simms.

 

[a creed]

I don't judge quarterbacks by rings , so he is much higher on my scale

Are you judging them by something other than Wins, Stats, Performance?

I hope you're not judging on "potential", cause then I'll take Rick Mirer...........

 

[gjohnson5]

LOL!!!!
I don't know where to begin with that....

1. Combines speak alot about ones ability
2. The QB needs to be in a system that works for him
3. Who are the skill players around him
4. Who's blocking!!!

The quarterback is only 1 man.

Are you judging them by something other than Wins, Stats, Performance?

I hope you're not judging on "potential", cause then I'll take Rick Mirer...........

 

[a creed]

LOL!!!!
I don't know where to begin with that....

1. Combines speak alot about ones ability
2. The QB needs to be in a system that works for him
3. Who are the skill players around him
4. Who's blocking!!!

Thje quarterback is only 1 man.

You know we're cool bro, but if you are trying to rationalize R.C. into even the top 20 QB's of all-time, you are going to have to let yourself drift into a whole other world filled with illusion and Doug Williams................

 

[gjohnson5]

LOL!!!!!

No I really like Rich Gannon

You know we're cool bro, but if you are trying to rationalize R.C. into even the top 20 QB's of all-time, you are going to have to let yourself drift into a whole other world filled with illusion and Doug Williams................

 

[gjohnson5]

BTW , you putting some racial overtones in this???

I like RC for his skills not his color. RC never won a SuperBowl but Doug Williams did. RC is a much better quarterback. I think RC is under rated , similar to Dominique Wilkins

You know we're cool bro, but if you are trying to rationalize R.C. into even the top 20 QB's of all-time, you are going to have to let yourself drift into a whole other world filled with illusion and Doug Williams................

 

[a creed]

LOL!!!!!

No I really like Rich Gannon

who doesn't LOL

 

[juiceddreadlocks]

I always liked Elway. I wasn't knocking him , I was knocking the folks who say the QB isn't good until he wins the big one.

WHo do you think is a better quarterback
Elway or Tom Brady

Tom Brady is a good quarterback , but he's no John Elway

I'd take Elway over brady. He made magic for a lot of shitty teams

 

[juiceddreadlocks]

LOL!!!!!

No I really like Rich Gannon

It was BFM (big fucking mistake) for the chiefs to let him go.