Could Peyton Manning become the best QB to ever play the game?

[PICK3]

Drew Brees is da man!

 

[test boy ii]

Reread the beginning of the thread.
Tell that to the posters who say you're not a good quarterback until you win the "BIG" one IE the Superbowl

There have been so many really great QBs that we need a lightning rod to help thin the ranks.

I think winning two Super Bowls has its merits. That is what it is about.


I just think there is plenty of glory in Silver medals and getting to the championship as well. Such a fine line between first and second so many times.

 

[test boy ii]

Michael Jordan waited many years to get past Detroit...........

 

[gjohnson5]

BTW , Peyton Manning is from New Orleans...

 

[test boy ii]

I'd like to see a poll amongst NFL head coaches...past and present:

If you could draft any QB that ever existed...at 22 years of age....who would it be?

I don't think so many would pick Marino or Brady....though they are both great.

Unitas
Tarkenton
Bradshaw would get a few yea's
Elway
Montana
Young


I see these as the leaders. Sure I'm missing an obvious one or two.

 

[test boy ii]

Who would Jimmy Johnson pick?

 

[Raptorex]

Who would Jimmy Johnson pick?

Jeff Gordon

 

[a creed]

It would be "classic" to see the Colts beat the Pats this Sunday night, only to have the pats beat them in the Playoffs..............

THAT would be "classic"

 

[gjohnson5]

Randall Cunningham

I'd like to see a poll amongst NFL head coaches...past and present:

If you could draft any QB that ever existed...at 22 years of age....who would it be?

I don't think so many would pick Marino or Brady....though they are both great.

Unitas
Tarkenton
Bradshaw would get a few yea's
Elway
Montana
Young


I see these as the leaders. Sure I'm missing an obvious one or two.

 

[a creed]

Randall Cunningham

Can't be considered for anywhere near The Best, however;


As naturally talented as ANY QB to put on the uniform.........yes, better than Vick............he just suffered from poor team drafting, poor teams, and injuries.

He was in a league all by himself.