what the hell? what do yuo really expect to happen if you tell someone to eat fruit veg and water every day all day?
1. they will hate it within a few days and go find the latest fad diet that allows them to eat real food
2. they will spend all day craving real food
3. they will lack energy all day
no disrespect but I disagree
also why would you recomend a catabolic diet? catabolic = muscle wasting... the less muscle someone has the slower their metabolism. With a higher metabolism she could eat more making the diet less grueling...
I dont really get the idea behind your advice here, I would be interested to hear the reason behind it all...
i used this diet to drop 35 pounds myself. and i'm not saying eat just that... you can eat lean meats as i stated above. this is just a base of what most of her diet should be if she wants to lose weight.
this diet DOES speed up the metabolism, her metabolism and energy will be sky high. this is a similar diet that weight watchers puts people on, and that is a pretty damn good diet with the points system.
you need to be a little more open to things, she isn't a bodybuilder or a lifter.. her goals are to lose weight... and this diet will do it pure and simple..
she will not crave food necessarily, but she will crave fats. this is why i recommend drink a lot of water and I'm sure you understand that drinking water will shut off the brain from feeling hungry..
again I'm not saying just eat fruits, veggies, water... you need to re-read what i posted and not look at things in just black and white. I'm saying MOST of the things she would eat should be those things. i would say 75%. and then overtime she can gradually re-introduce other foods back in moderation.
i use this diet myself when i am cutting off cycle, and look at my avi. <<<<< i see a lot of muscle on that frame so not sure where you get the whole muscle wasting theory from. in fact this might come as a shock but as I've stated many times on this forum I am mostly a vegan. and I'm eating some rasberries as I write
it all boils down to a LIFESTYLE change. if you want to drink Arizona sweet tea then you are gonna have a tough time losing weight. most people DO NOT eat enough fruits and veggies this is a fact. which is why we have an obesity and diabetes epidemic
its no different advice than telling guys who are 6 feet and 150 pounds to not juice and to start working out. thats the advice people give all the time, I could use your arguement on that too. "HEY you are guys are nuts? seriously? this guy never works out and now you want him to workout 4X per week? i disagree! "
well unfortunately diet + working out are the #1 things.. if you aren't willing to change your diet and TRY then you won't reach your goals.