Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
RESEARCHSARMSUGFREAKeudomestic
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsRESEARCHSARMSUGFREAKeudomestic

Thinking about hiring a personal trainer

bignate73 said:
as for the guy whose done it. great for him. he can tell you this or that. my area of study is exercise SCIENCE, so that means...i want to know HOW. SPECIFICALLY.

So your study of exercise SCIENCE has gotten you where? You have posted a big bench press...right? You not using your lats has given you a huge bench press...right? It has given you a huge chest also...right?

I am sorry...but untill you have done it...it is all theory. I may be a dumb athlete...but I am a dumb atlhete who has went from nothing to something. I am also a dumb athlete who can put up decent numbers on the squat, bench, and deadlift...AND still look decent for a strength athlete.

Your area of study in exercise SCIENCE has given you that also...right?

B True
 
im gonna be open minded, tomorrow, im going to give it a shot.

i understand the form, but im going to figure out HOW. i can actually see a little of how scapular depression can cause the shoulder which is hyperextended at the bottom of the bench can cause for a small amount of shoulder and humerus movement. a strong enough contraction that way COULD start the motion off the chest, but from there thats a shitload of close grip tricep pressing and some serious front delts.

like i said, i'll give it a shot so i can understand it. who knows, i may implement it into my training. (not now though, im 2 weeks out from a show and the joints cant take too much in the way of big stress) no fat=no cushion.
 
bignate73 said:
as for the guy whose done it. great for him. he can tell you this or that. my area of study is exercise SCIENCE, so that means...i want to know HOW. SPECIFICALLY.

now i can understand contracting the lats...to arch the back and thereby shorten the distance to the chest, also essentially putting the body in a decline position despite being on a flat bench. i understand all of this...but as for a muscle reversing its action, thats like saying that a hydraulic piston suddenly loses all its pressure and goes into a vacuum. if you follow the sliding filament theory.

http://www.testosterone.net/articles/180press.html

Ok....if you know the whole "back release theory" as you call it...then you realize that by using it, it will produce a force driving into the bar. And it may only be a few inches...no arguing that. But when you are a top bencher...and your bench stroke is only 7" or 8"...then that "couple of inches" is a big thing. And after that...guess what...the triceps lock out the bar. I am not arguing that chest and shoulders aren't involved in benching...they are...but lats and especially triceps are involved to a greater extent.

You can use Science to prove almost anything on paper. But in the "trenches" things are different. Yes it is somewhat important to have a basic understanding of WHY something is the way it is. How else do you explain to your clients why they should do something...I can understand and respect that. But if I increase my lats strength, and dont change anything else about my training...and my bench goes up...there is a direct correlation that I dont have to look in a text book to find.

On a side note....Westside has been using the bands for active recovery work for years...and they still don't know exactly WHY or HOW they work...they just see the results. I don't know why they work either...and while I would like to know...as long as I see progress from using them...the end justifies the means.
 
Last edited:
bfold im not here to get into a pissing contest with your accomplishments. they are great and are duly noted. my interest is in the HOW, scientifically. im assuming someone can explain it to me.

as for my accomplishments, i dont brag. i know where im at now, i know what i'll win in 2 weeks, and i know what my knowledge of nutrition (sound nutrition that is) and solid training can do to my body.

you take it personally because its your sport, fine but you shouldnt. just because i question it and ask for it to be explained in real scientific terms shouldnt be taken as an attack. if it "just happens" then there is a reason how, thats all im asking. if you cant explain it, someone else can. but there is no way i'll be satisfied with..."so and so said its good, or it must be true because..." sorry, thats not how i work.

if you insist on questioning my experience, what i have accomplished etc. because of my scientific background (and i have seen your disdain for science/theory) i'll post pics of whatever will satisfy someone as to my bodybuilding and training integrity.
 
Why are we getting sidetracked by the lats? I specifically said tris, lats, and shoulders. You aren't the only one around here sporting an ACSM, so I don't need to remind you that there isn't enough physics on that exam.

Keep in mind that "scientific studies" like Barnet, 1995, regarding IGF recruitment are not going to be applicable in terms of lat/tri use as the subjects tested were not engaging those muscles...they were benching "like body builders."

Bfold has a point...I'm a 170 pounds female, and I'm benching about 200. Clean (natural) and raw (no lifting gear). I'm also recovering from shoulder injuries from benching at 90 degrees. My goal is 315 by December. I never train my chest.

Shoulder injuries are the NUMBER ONE reason to learn how to engage your lats and use your traps. For starters, the lats hold the bar in the "groove" to ensure proper bar placement. For me that's sternum, not chest. It may land too high or too low. If it is too low, the delts are involved too much. If the bar lands too high, the triceps are involved too much. Strong lats will ensure the bar is placed in the correct position, that is, with the forearms vertical. In this position, an equal amount of delt, pec, and triceps are used in pressing. If you don’t place the bar in the correct position, delt and pec injuries are more likely to occur. The path of the bar in the concentric phase should be a straight line. This requires the correct use of muscles. When the Clemson University coaching staff wanted to know which are the most important muscle groups for benching, George Halbert told them triceps are first, lats second, upper back third, and delts last. George holds the world record in the 220’s at 657, a world record of 688 in the 242s and a 683 at 227, the heaviest triple bodyweight bench of all time (457 pounds over bodyweight).

In case you want a non-Louie opinion...

ASSISTANCE MOVEMENTS FOR THE BENCH PRESS
By David Geistlinger, Nebraska USAPL Athlete Rep

There is no doubt about it. If you want to increase the amount of weight you can handle on the bench, you need to spend a substantial amount of time doing the bench press, or a variation of the bench movement. But if you want to reach your maximum potential and stay injury free, you must also do assistance exercises for the muscles utilized while bench pressing.

Often times, a lifter will have a dominantly strong prime mover. Your prime movers in the bench press are the lats, pecs, front delts, and the triceps. Many times the lifter will rely on their dominantly strong muscles to overcome for their weak points. This usually results in bad form. One example would be when the bar drifts back over the face in an arched pathway. People bench with an arched bar pathway because they have weak lats and triceps. They overcompensate by putting extra load on the front delts. They can do all the sets of the bench press exercise that they can, but their form will never improve. They will continue to let the bar drift back over the face. The more sets that they let this happen, the worse their muscle imbalance becomes, because more time is spent using the delts, and less time is used stressing the triceps and lats. This means that if we want to improve form, we need to do so by strengthening the muscles utilized in the bench press in the right proportions. As time goes by, the amount of assistance that we do for a particular muscle will change. Over time, muscles that were a weak point may become a strong point and vice versa. The amount of assistance for each muscle needs to be adjusted on a constant basis so that the weaker muscles are getting the majority of time spent doing extra exercises.

_______

Recruitment is just as important as strength, IMO. Very few lifters utilize the strength of the lats in their bench press and when they are able to incorporate lat contraction into their exercises, immediate increase is always achieved. Here is how you incorporate the lats into your bench press: Take an empty bar or even a wooden rod and assume the bench press position. Lower the bar to the chest and pause. Instead of driving the weight up with the arms, contract or “flare” the lats in an outward direction. If you have decent lat development, you should see the bar move several inches off the chest. This takes practice to utilize the lats in this manner, but be persistent and practice over and over with an empty bar, gradually adding weight as you get used to the movement. The eventual goal is to use the lats as sort of a cushion or coiled spring when lowering the bar and then contracting them strongly on the initial drive at the same time you are pressing with the arms. Athletes who have increased their maximum bench press anywhere from 20-50lbs within 2 weeks as a result of using this technique.

In addition to recruitment is conditioning. Muscles can be stronger in one plane than another. For this reason, lats should be trained in the same plane as the bench, ie bb rows.

Perhaps you'd like to take a stab at how power lifters are able to press more than 500 pounds with torn pecs?

I read your posts regularly, and I know you know your stuff. I've been on both sides of this. 16 weeks ago I was benching 95 pounds...I started benching with my lats/tris/shoulders, and have added over 100 pounds, and my shoudler is finally rehabbing successfully. Give it an honest try before you knock it. However, be warned that benching like this won't train your chest to failure, so you have to use other movements to do this, such as db flies (yes, I said it again), db presses and bb presses all at less than 30 degrees (to not engage anterior delts). If you have a "good" shoulder, then do all that dipping stuff if you want. I wouldn't recommend those movements for someone with weak, or otherwise compromised, shoulders. :)
 
Last edited:
So when you posted earlier in this thread that the lats were NOT part of the prime movers of the bench press...you stated that because you were searching for the right answer...or just because...hmm..how did you just put it..."so and so said its good, or it must be true because..."

Well...you are saying that "pec" benching is good and that you don't have to use your lats for a big bench. Where did you get this from? Or did you just hear it from so and so...?

If the guys from WSB or Coan, Frank, etc...tells me to use my lats, heels, triceps, tongue, pecker...whatever...I will listen because they have done it. There is only one way to prove it...that is to step up to the platform or stage and do it.

B True
 
spatterson said:
Why are we getting sidetracked by the lats? I specifically said tris, lats, and shoulder. You aren't the only one around here sportin and ACSM, so I don't need to remind you that there isn't enough physics on that exam.


that explained how (kindof) the lats are involved. more of a synergistic effect, which goes against pec benching. i can relate.

all i wanted was an explanation of lat involvement by those doing it. i hear anecdotal this and that, i just wanted some explanation.

i know people get up in arms when someone questions thier way of doing business. its not a "you guys are all fucked up thread", its a tell me how inquiry.

ps....look again. its NASM, i dont have ACSM (yet). :)
 
I don't understand everything about how it works...and I don't believe that everything about the Westside methods work for me either. I pick and choose from different programs through trial and error and I try to keep my errors down to as little as possible.

B True
 
My way vs your way is irrelevant, we have different goals.

However, my concern for the point of this thread is its originator and his shoulder problem. If he goes out and finds any old trainer, educated and certified or not, and that person is as firm in his benching form beliefs as you were/are he may damage his shoulder further. If you need to bench such that your pecs are more stimulated for purposes of hypertrophy and symmetry, then you are doing a movement that's ideal for your goals.

BUT...

If you are operating with a bum shoulder (or potentially bum shoulder), skip or modify your bench form and work on strengthening the upper back and shoulder. Go back to the wide bench later when the shoulder is strong enough to support it.

AND...

If your goal is strength and a big bench (powerlifting), you will need to bench with the tris/lats/shoulders and not out wide.

Thanks for the civilized debate. :)
 
b fold the truth said:
I don't understand everything about how it works...and I don't believe that everything about the Westside methods work for me either. I pick and choose from different programs through trial and error and I try to keep my errors down to as little as possible.

B True

so be it. thats my point of asking why. to minimize wasted time in the gym, to make progress.

since i am looked upon as an instructor (and since trainers seem to have such a bad reputation) then i had damn well be able to explain the how and why of an exercise. otherwise im that guy who perpetuates the "do it cause i said so" belief that is thought of for some trainers. im not taken seriously unless i can explain something thoroughly. if i take a little heat for asking questions oh well, it wont affect my paycheck. but if i misinform someone it will.
 
Top Bottom