Is this self defense or murder?

[Beachboy6294]

If he had drugs in the house they may get him but not for 1st Degree murder!

 

[Scotsman]

If the police didn't clearly identify themselves then it is definitely self defense. Now it's their word against his as to whether or not they actually did yell anything or if they just came storming in.

Anyone who comes barging into my place without notifying me of who they are is getting shot no questions asked.

Cheers,
Scotsman

 

[mountain muscle]

Sounds like a good shoot to me.

Doesn't sound like they had justification for a no-knock warrant and unfortunately, a cop lost his life.

No-knock warrants are a slippery slope. I don't think just hearing someone say police is enough to warrant giving up without visual id.

I could start doing home invasions and yell police as I kicked in the door.

 

[gjohnson5]

I had no idea Canada was that liberal...
Here in GA , ther would have been several police raiding his home and he would have been shot and killed.

Then the drugs would have been seized and used as evidence.

I may have to move to Canada

 

[MorganKane]

I say murder.
1. They had a warrant and went in legally.
2. They followed procedure and yelled out Police.
3. I assume they all wore "entry" clothing and equipment -not mentioned in the article.
So the word POLICE would be very visible.
4. The suspect fired on the officers, he totally ignored both the verbal notification and the written notification.

Does not sound like self defense to me..

 

[Beachboy6294]

I had no idea Canada was that liberal...
Here in GA , ther would have been several police raiding his home and he would have been shot and killed.

Then the drugs would have been seized and used as evidence.

I may have to move to Canada

The same thing would have happened in NOLA too except they would have killed the family too

 

[gjohnson5]

Well since they cant catch and convict anyone over there in New Orleans , might as well kill em'

I wonder if they still go over to Covington and Jefferson to do all of their background check , Fingerprint stuff and Forensics?

The same thing would have happened in NOLA too except they would have killed the family too

 

[blueta2]

The same thing would have happened in NOLA too except they would have killed the family too

really?!

 

[Beachboy6294]

Well since they cant catch and convict anyone over there in New Orleans , might as well kill em'

I wonder if they still go over to Covington and Jefferson to do all of their background check , Fingerprint stuff and Forensics?

Yes you are right but this new DA is suppose to be getting some convictions finally. NOPD is finally starting to build their own forensics place that is suppose to be state of the art but we'll see. It's crazy that I still love this place so much!!

 

[dabuffguy]

A montreal man is on trial for murdering a Montreal police officer.
Last March, 2007, Montreal police made a middle of the night suprise attack on a suspected drug dealers house. The cops rushed into this guys house where this man, his wife and 2 kids slept.

The man who thought he was being robbed got his gun and shot at the cop who came busting into the room shooting. Suspected drug dealer kills cop.

He's on trial and the jury is out as of last weekend. They can either convict of 1st degree murder, 2nd degree or aquit under the self defense law.

If this guy is convicted of murder, I know the justice system is seriously faulty!


Discuss...........

http://www.nationalpost.com/scripts/story.html?id=562799


http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNe...10/parasiris_trial_080610/20080610?hub=Canada

If he's white, self-defense. If he's black, 1st degree murder.



























Kidding!