"So if one were eating in this fashion...only carbs for your PW shake, and your second PW meal, you'd day skip the r-ALA for the shake and get that insulin spke, then take the r-ALA with the second PW meal which is solid food?
I'm all confused now. Before, you and macro were saying to take the r-ALA with your PW shake, now the insulin spike is beneficial PW."
I would not, and do not, use carbs for an insulin spike post workout. Many do, but I don't. My PW shake has no carbs.
So to answer your question again, Yes the PW shake with carbs should be allowed to spike your insulin if that's what you're looking to do.
It's like this. I can't tell you what's best for you and your growth and be exact on every detail. There are completely seperate theories at work when it comes to PW shakes, PW insulin spikes, PREWO drinks, taking carb when you train or not, etc. You have to find the one that you think works for you the best.
Mr Nobody is over 250 when ripped for a contest. Now he's 303. If you saw him training in a gym he'd would be the first guy you'd ask advice from, likes the insulin spike post work out.
I personally don't think the rewards of the spike are worth shutting down your fat burning post work out. Your body stops burning fat in the presence of insulin. By training you've created this nice increase in your MR and you will burn fat for hours at an increased rate PW and instead you're going to spike your insulin and shut it all down.
So the compromise would be to spike your insulin and then take the Glucorell R to shut it down so it's not spiked so long. Hence, the suggestion to use it for your PW shake.
Singleton, drinking gatorade while training has so many benefits that the small amount of blood required to digest it is a small price to pay.