madcow2, this is just out of pure curiosity. Suppose someone never consulted any sort of professional or any other weightlifter and simply bought a weight set and made up some horrible program with horrible volume, workload, intensity, and frequency and went on overtraining themselves for years showing little to no gains and, naturally, losses over time. Say someone introduced this person to proper training philosophy having to do with periodization, volume, compound lifts, etc. and they realized they've been doing everything wrong. If this person took 2 weeks off to get their body to recover from their horrible program and started up on an actually beneficial training program, would they show the same gains as they would have had they never had started their own horrible routine?
Basically, I'm just curious if someone could ever screw their body up so much through improper training that they become an ultra hard-gainer for their entire life or something.