My comments are in bold.
Something that strikes me as a bit odd. Did you try to increase your lifts week to week or did you start light and scale upward meeting previous records around the first record week i.e. 2nd to last week of volume phase, and then surpass that record in the next week? You should be scaling so records. I'm not sure whether you are doing this or not but the way you phrased I figured I'd bring it up.
The first time I ran the cycle I put my best record for all lifts in week 3. I ramped up to that record matching it in week 3 then trying to beat in week 4.
My best 5x5 on the BB Row was 200lbs I ramped like this,
week 1 - 170
week 2 - 185
week 3 - 200
week 4 - 210
Also, how did the training go? Did you feel overwhelmed by the end of loading, did you feel recouped by the beginning of week 7 (i.e. week 5 deload, week 6 first 3x3)? I need a bit more info here. If you have a log and want to post it on the 5x5 thread that would be better the PMing the whole thing to me.
At the end of the volume phase I didn't feel overwhelmed like some people say in the 5x5 thread. I wasn't thinking thank god its time to deload. What I noticed was as the weeks were going on I was feeling more fresh in the gym like I was recovering during the program. Weeks 1-2 were a bit hard and I was worrying that I wasn't going to beat my records in week 4. Once I got to week 5 and on every day in the gym was getting better, stronger more energy. Before I started the routine my appetite was down, trouble sleeping, tired during the day, moody now its the opposite I feel great. I started the program at 185lbs from weeks 1-6 I put on 1-2lbs, I weighed myself Saturday morning and I weigh 195lbs now. 8lbs in the last 3 weeks, my abs are still there no real change in bf% at all.
Another thing is your state of fatigue before beginning the program or whether you weren't able to get the rebound.
When I started the program I was using standard bbing splits for over 6 months with no breaks from training just heavy lifting all the time. I'm going to deload again I'm thinking I was overtrained before starting the routine and I didn't get as much as I could from it. I really screwed up this first cycle when I think about it now I should have ran a 6 week loading peroid instead of 4 weeks.
To be honest, it's hard to tell from the limited info and comparing yourself to others isn't always the best since some of them might be at different relative levels of their absolute max strength (ie. the most they are ever likely to lift at their weight). Gains come a lot slower with experience and the fact that most of these guys gain strength during the volume phase tells me right there that they could likely use a good single factor program (i.e. the novice version of this) and probably net out equal and maybe even better results in some cases.
I would plan on giving it another run through. I would absolutely deload again because we need to ensure that you are starting fresh this time. I'd advise 1-2 weeks of training 2x per week, just use medium weights (i.e. 55-65% 1RM), only the core lifts, no lift more than twice a week, and use a range of 3x3. I want you to be super fresh. We can also experiment with a longer loading period.