BigPapaTy said:
alright good deal so, do you guys think I should do Rippetoe instead of Bill Starr?
In order to make that decision, we need to know alot about you.
How old are ya, how long have you been lifting, how serious was your previous lifting, how legit is your technique, what is your body weight, how tall are you, what are your current maxes etc. Gimme a list =P
The difference between a 3x5 and a 5x5 is the time it gives to heal. In general and very inspecifically, a beginner can heal alot faster then an intermediate. A 3x5 takes advantage of that fact. As you grow, your body exerts more force which creates more fatigue which requires more time to heal. The 5x5 provides a more structured routine.
Just to make sure you buy it, order Practical Programming and Starting Strength. I can't stress this enough, best 60 dollar investment I have ever made.
And when you saying about my numbers are you going by those to suggest the Mark Rippetoe? I am all ears on starting that on friday, doing that for awhile then moving to Bill Starr? Good idea? And is Bill Starr 5x5 way over my head? Form I do not have a problem with, if that is it. But again I am all ears.
I gauged your numbers to think what your experience range. Assuming you arn't a giant of a man or a midget. If you are where I think you are, then you should last about 3 months on a 3x5. From there you will plateu and you will need to begin to periodize, aka something like the Bill Starr 5x5.
Forgive me for the structure, or lack there of, of my post, I have a tendency to just write what comes to my head. Anyways, incase I didn't explain it well enough earlier:
The 5x5 BS assumes that you can exert more force then a novice causing you to get more fatigued then a novice, and while you do regenerate at quicker rates then a novice, you still exert enough force that it requires you to take longer time to heal then a novice.
So, basically, the 5x5 isn't too advanced for you. In fact, if you were so willing, you could do the advanced and elite weight trainer workouts, but you wouldn't grow and there would be no results, because it doesn't play to your body.
And as far as form goes, there will still be ways to fix even the best form. Before I got starting strength I thought my technique was perfect. Since reading SS, my squat technique got better causing me to move heavier weight with less effort and less pain and aches afterwards. My shoulders hurt substantially less and I have been getting more gains in all. lol, I push Rippetoe/Kilgore's work so much that I should be getting like 25% from each sale.
Anyways, any more questions ask away.