I have to agree that it's not quite what I hoped it would be. For me, one of the most overpowering sensations is that feeling of warmth when I slide into her. For whatever reason, I just don't get that feeling in the water. And if it's a hot tub or jacuzzi, then it's even less of that feeling. Now don't get me wrong, a lot of the women seem to LOVE the water-sex, so for that reason alone it's worth doing. Why would you not want to do what your partner finds pleasurable? But as for me, I feel that the way the water alters the way she lubricates, and the loss of that contrast in how warm it feels being inside her, I'll vote that sex is better on dry land. Just my 2¢.