I'm pretty big (proportionate I guess since I'm 6'5" 255#) and I have had a chick who felt pretty loose to me say it was too big, and I had a chich who I swear was less than 2 inches from her clit to her asshole and she took it like a champ! It was so tight that I would back off and she would get on top and say "Tell me if it hurts" and FORCE it in! Once she was really worked up it was easy but still very tight.....tighter than most women's ass. She was also a squirter.