Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below 
In the past I've made the mistake of totally fogetting the legpress is favor of the squat. I'm not argueing, the squat is a superior movement, but the legpress does have things to offer.
Mainly the fact that it is very difficult (and dangerous) to goto failure on squats. With the leg press you can load up and squeeze out reps untill you bottom the thing out and can't get it back up.
I use to take squats to failure, squatting ATF and being my squat weights were quite light at the time, (under 200). It was not much of a problem for my spotter to help me out when I tripped with fatigue or failed.
As the weight increased it got increasingly dangerous, I first realized I couldn't really give 100% safty when my friend was warming up doing 315 (working set was 405). All of a sudden his left leg gave out, caught me off guard since he was just warming up. I grabbed the weights as they fell and it nearly ripped my arms out since it was dropping. No one was hurt, he wasn't sure why his leg just gave out but it made it clear to us at that point that while we could spot we couldn't really do too much if failure is 100%.
Now, because of schedules I don't even have a spot. The catch bars while better than nothing. Don't give me full confidence to really push myself to my limits.
In comes the leg press.
I can push myself untill I really do fail. So long as you have enough flexibility that if the weight bottoms out you don't crush yourself. You can give it you all and no need for a spot.
I still squat, its the base of my leg day.
but, I actually think more growth is coming from the legpress at the moment. (in quads only, since my leg placement on the press takes my glutes largely out of the movement)
Eventually I wish to rig chains to the squat bar and hook them to the top of the rack (theres a chin bar uptop) that way we can once again squat to failure untill then my leg day won't be complete without the legpress.
In short, don't forget about the legpress because of all the tadoo surrounding the squat. The squat is a great movement but most of us probably can't safely push our selfs to the limit on it.
PS. I have set up benches on either side of the rack and then put some wooden bocks on each side effectively making a cage. I've failed a few times like that and watched splinters of wood go flying off. It worked and occasionally I do it, but a few times I've failled so that I would have broken my neck if the benches were not in place and it eventually started sinking in that banking safety on this half-assed cage wasn't worth the risk.
Mainly the fact that it is very difficult (and dangerous) to goto failure on squats. With the leg press you can load up and squeeze out reps untill you bottom the thing out and can't get it back up.
I use to take squats to failure, squatting ATF and being my squat weights were quite light at the time, (under 200). It was not much of a problem for my spotter to help me out when I tripped with fatigue or failed.
As the weight increased it got increasingly dangerous, I first realized I couldn't really give 100% safty when my friend was warming up doing 315 (working set was 405). All of a sudden his left leg gave out, caught me off guard since he was just warming up. I grabbed the weights as they fell and it nearly ripped my arms out since it was dropping. No one was hurt, he wasn't sure why his leg just gave out but it made it clear to us at that point that while we could spot we couldn't really do too much if failure is 100%.
Now, because of schedules I don't even have a spot. The catch bars while better than nothing. Don't give me full confidence to really push myself to my limits.
In comes the leg press.
I can push myself untill I really do fail. So long as you have enough flexibility that if the weight bottoms out you don't crush yourself. You can give it you all and no need for a spot.
I still squat, its the base of my leg day.
but, I actually think more growth is coming from the legpress at the moment. (in quads only, since my leg placement on the press takes my glutes largely out of the movement)
Eventually I wish to rig chains to the squat bar and hook them to the top of the rack (theres a chin bar uptop) that way we can once again squat to failure untill then my leg day won't be complete without the legpress.
In short, don't forget about the legpress because of all the tadoo surrounding the squat. The squat is a great movement but most of us probably can't safely push our selfs to the limit on it.
PS. I have set up benches on either side of the rack and then put some wooden bocks on each side effectively making a cage. I've failed a few times like that and watched splinters of wood go flying off. It worked and occasionally I do it, but a few times I've failled so that I would have broken my neck if the benches were not in place and it eventually started sinking in that banking safety on this half-assed cage wasn't worth the risk.
