Ive read over 1500 articles on carb loading written by professional and amature bodybuilders. Instead of just asking a few peoples opinions I suggest you do the same and actually research the topic. Then make your own decitions from there. Look at there on satge photos and judge it for youself. I dont really have the time to waste explaining all the chemical properties and why its nessisary to do this and not do that. There is a very well known site out there with plenty of info.