Who is the victor? Satch or Carth?

[maldorf]

Both of you guys look amazing for only training the short time that you have. You both have less than 4 years of training? Wish I had looked that good after only training that long!
I would have to give the egde to Carth because of his more balanced development and hardness/vascularity. Carth had a better back and legs. Only thing that I felt was undersized on Carth, as far as symetry goes, was calves. Calves were cut up great and had good shaped, but a bit undersized compared to those nice quads.

 

[reigninghard]

im fairly new and getting to know some of you guys..thanks for the entertainment of the competition..it was nice to see how you guys have come along..keep up the good work..both you guys seem pretty damn cool to me.

 

[gjohnson5]

Satch has no legs. Carth is more vascular and looks bigger despite being about 40lb lighter. Not sure if Satch's scale need calibrating but looks like Carth has bigger arms and wider lat spead.
Carth looked more lean and that may be due to Satch holding water. Every way I look at this , Carth is the winner and it's not even close

 

[Beachboy6294]

And that is why LOVE conquers all!!! K to you for coming back to the Light.

Cool I am glad you both settled this like men and not lil nerd bitches hiding behind their computer's!! Man we all have our bad days and say shit that we wish we could take back but you can't. Well not really....I swear this board has so many Bro's that will lose their temper quick but it seems like after all is said and done it doesn't go one forever and they act like men! Peace....

 

[Lestat]

both look impressive

 

[Makavelli]

Sorry for chiming in so late guys, but I had some things I had to do yesterday. I think that both guys look good. They both made great progress and that's what they should be most concerned with. I didn't see any front relaxed poses, unless I missed them, so it's hard to judge symmetry. From what I saw Carth wins due to 2 things: #1) conditioning. He was harder all around. Satch was too soft. #2) Proportion. His body is in better proportion than Satch's. Satch needs lots of work on his legs which held him back here. Even if his legs were bigger and match his upper body I would still give Carth the nod for conditioning. Great job to both!

 

[Slydog]

Both are winners and both should hold their heads high. I went with Carth also, its clear that carth has been training longer than satch due to the musle maturity and proportion.
Satch, for next year I would suggest sticking to the basic lifts (deads, squats, presses, bent over rows, etc...) We need to get your legs and back up... COnditioning is not your problem. We have to work on mass especially in the two areas I mentioned before. Either way great work bro and yeah you def have a great color which means a lot in a real competition.
Carth, if we can keep you injury free and perhaps a lil more focused I'm sure the sky's the limit. Look good bro just stay away from the tren, don't want you to catch a case homie. Congrats....

 

[Smokescreen]

This is fucking great! The links to both Satch pics and mine are dead! WTF?

 

[will b huge]

Wow, I got a lot of respect for you now. That took a lot to do. I think you're the first to really be a man about it. Thank you. I mean it, thank you.

It's not that hard to tell the truth, and even I could see that I was being a retard yesterday..... Sorry again, and I tried to leave you some positive karma for ya, but they said that I had to spread it around first....I can probably get it to go through to ya tomorrow....


Have a good one.....(looks like Carth is quite ahead of Satch in the POLL...)

 

[jokerswild]

Carth hands down