Number one has to be a willingness to let me look at, lick, kiss, rub, pound and spill my babies into it. if those things aren't happening, the prettier they are the more I hate them. Second is the beauty of the puss, is it trimmed/shaved? the pretty ones just look......well, pretty. Third is smell, a pussy should smell like something I can't wait to lick - like a cherry flavored sucker, Fourth is snugness and having the necessary depth without being too deep. Fifth is a lack of scabs or other wounds but this can be overlooked if the above mentioned criteria is met. Now some would say that a scabbed up puss can't possible be pretty but if you get back to the willingness part maybe............fuck that, no scabs. So a willing puss that is pretty, smells great and is tight with no scabs or other wounds is the best puss. IMO