I could never again be with a guy that didn't make noise. My exhusband NEVER made a sound.
I LOVE to talk when I am making love, that is as long as I can form words intelligently. Then it is moaning and screaming. I will talk dirty when the mood strikes me.
I do NOT like it however if my lover talks dirty to me. It would be a definite turnoff one that would ruin it for good.