Who is the victor? Satch or Carth?

[paridhm]

Pics are in bros. Time for your opinions.

 

[satchboogie]

The Winner Will Be Determined In One Week After Most Elite Members Get A Chance To Vote!

 

[reigninghard]

Gotta be satch, Carth was a no show for the 2pm...either way both bros are friggin ripped, great job guys!

 

[clublavela]

After consulting with my friend here, he clearly opened my eyes:::

I voted for SATCH as he was the only competitor.....

THE WINNER IS ALWAYS CHOSEN DURING PRE-JUDGING NOT THE EVENING SHOW!!!!!!

AT 2pm, I SAT HERE AND SAT HERE AND SAT HERE---SATCH WAS THE ONLY ONE TO SHOW UP---------

There are NO EXCUSES for being late to a CONTEST.....SAME AS BEING LATE FOR A WEDDING---BUT A CONTEST REQUIRES MORE PREP WORK!!!!!!!


Totally agree with this point. Hell we waited until over an hour longer. I mean i understand Carth has a job and shit but he is the one who made the time and agreed on it.


PERIOD!!!! JOB WELL DONE!!!

Totally agree with this point. Hell we waited until over an hour longer. I mean i understand Carth has a job and shit but he is the one who made the time and agreed on it. i mean if this was a real contest would the judges allow him to perform after everyone else has gone and are ready to be judged?

 

[paridhm]

The Winner Will Be Determined In One Week After Most Elite Members Get A Chance To Vote!

Ok. Who is going to make the official thread about the vote when the week has elapsed?

 

[Quadsweep]

Well, Satch is my bro, I will say that first. But I am also an NPC judge that has to judge friends all the time and I am a no bullshit judge. I placed my sister out of the trophies so I am honest always.

I would have to put Carth over Satch do to his more mature muscle mass. He has a harder physique that is more balanced. Satch is stronger in the chest but Carth is strong from the back and legs...bet he deads and rows heavy and squats deep. Really nice calves. Needs upper pec development and traps and arms a bit bigger.

Satch needs to bring his legs up...common for people training a short time. Satch has a very nice waist and ab structure. Needs to bring up middle back thickness. Squeeeeze and feel it and row, row, row. Biceps are a little ahead of tris. Legs need to come up but that is with time. This is the best I have seen you. You will continue to get leaner each diet too.

This is a sport of paying your dues...a marathon not a sprint. Carth looks to me to have more time in the trenches but both have done a great job. Kudos to both of you.

Quadsweep

 

[slat1]

After consulting with my friend here, he clearly opened my eyes:::

I voted for SATCH as he was the only competitor.....

THE WINNER IS ALWAYS CHOSEN DURING PRE-JUDGING NOT THE EVENING SHOW!!!!!!

AT 2pm, I SAT HERE AND SAT HERE AND SAT HERE---SATCH WAS THE ONLY ONE TO SHOW UP---------

There are NO EXCUSES for being late to a CONTEST.....SAME AS BEING LATE FOR A WEDDING---BUT A CONTEST REQUIRES MORE PREP WORK!!!!!!!



PERIOD!!!! JOB WELL DONE!!!

The only problem with that theory is that the pictures were taken days apart. If time was an issue they should have been taken at the exact same moment. Not Thursday and Sunday. Its a complete non issue!

 

[ed2005]

Well, Satch is my bro, I will say that first. But I am also an NPC judge that has to judge friends all the time and I am a no bullshit judge. I placed my sister out of the trophies so I am honest always.

I would have to put Carth over Satch do to his more mature muscle mass. He has a harder physique that is more balanced. Satch is stronger in the chest but Carth is strong from the back and legs...bet he deads and rows heavy and squats deep. Really nice calves. Needs upper pec development and traps and arms a bit bigger.

Satch needs to bring his legs up...common for people training a short time. Satch has a very nice waist and ab structure. Needs to bring up middle back thickness. Squeeeeze and feel it and row, row, row. Biceps are a little ahead of tris. Legs need to come up but that is with time. This is the best I have seen you. You will continue to get leaner each diet too.

This is a sport of paying your dues...a marathon not a sprint. Carth looks to me to have more time in the trenches but both have done a great job. Kudos to both of you.

Quadsweep

Dito...Nice post bor.....

 

[nipples]

both are great bros with great potential.

 

[DieselGunz]

Voted Carth here

he is harder and has better balance between upper and lower body


Great job!