So, if being ripped meant you would weigh 150 pounds then you would be cool with it? It's a long running joke about Brad Pitt and his "Fight Club" physique on this forum because it's a juicer board and they wonder if he juiced to be 165 pounds.
I would rather be 12% bf @ 240 than 6% BF @ 175 but peoples goals do differ and to each his own.