Which physique is best...

[heatherrae]

Of course. Everyone knows the measure of a man is not his roll of duct tape.

It isn't?

 

[heatherrae]

Nice try HR.......height is just as important as mass/leaness, it's intrinsic to the physical build....Let's just assume that 2+2 =5

JG, you are babbling. I already said that I don't want to have more than one variable. If I did, then you would say that the poll was flawed because you wouldn't be able to tell which variable influenced the response.

Are you trying to tell me that men who are lean and ripped and men who are massive but not as ripped can't be of the same height? I've seen both types of men at all heights.

 

[javaguru]

JG, you are babbling. I already said that I don't want to have more than one variable. If I did, then you would say that the poll was flawed because you wouldn't be able to tell which variable influenced the response.

Are you trying to tell me that men who are lean and ripped and men who are massive but not as ripped can't be of the same height? I've seen both types of men at all heights.

Then you should have not posted pictures, that alone creates many variables, and asked the question...would you rather be 8%BF or 15% BF...

 

[heatherrae]

Then you should have not posted pictures, that alone creates many variables, and asked the question...would you rather be 8%BF or 15% BF...

See, now you are twisting that too. You are just trying to be argumentative.

It isn't just a matter of being 8% or 15% bf, it was a size thing.

Plus, if you are asking a question of aesthetics using a picture is better than have someone just answer a verbal inquiry.

However, I'm sure the answer would have been the same either way, Mr. McBitter Farts.

 

[jh1]

The following Men of EF are Fat:

crazyjoe, heavy_duty, hstern, Mr. dB, redsamurai, samoth, jon79, PuddleMonkey, tatyana_zadorozny, the_clockwork

That's all.

 

[Whiskey]

assuming both can lift the same ammount, i'm going to be geigh and vote. #2.

Whiskey

 

[javaguru]

See, now you are twisting that too. You are just trying to be argumentative.

It isn't just a matter of being 8% or 15% bf, it was a size thing.

Plus, if you are asking a question of aesthetics using a picture is better than have someone just answer a verbal inquiry.

However, I'm sure the answer would have been the same either way, Mr. McBitter Farts.

I was using an example....then just say would you rather be 170 and 8% or 250 and 15%...photos are filled with variables as I pointed out.

 

[heatherrae]

The following Men of EF are Fat:

crazyjoe, heavy_duty, hstern, Mr. dB, redsamurai, samoth, jon79, PuddleMonkey, tatyana_zadorozny, the_clockwork

That's all.

don't forget the ones who voted as females.

 

[Jon79]

The following Men of EF are Fat:

crazyjoe, heavy_duty, hstern, Mr. dB, redsamurai, samoth, jon79, PuddleMonkey, tatyana_zadorozny, the_clockwork

That's all.

yesss i was included in somethin

btw

i hate heatherrae

 

[bw1]

yesss i was included in somethin

btw

i hate heatherrae

Every one does