Whats small dick below 6 inches? How many times have you had sex? A woman whose fucked as much as you sound like equals a 3 inch dick...... I don't want that shit either.
He seems to be a decent guy - and he's 2 years younger, which is not my typical - but he's good looking, educated, he works out regularly (if not too much), decent career (and packing more than 4 inches), that being said there's a lot to find out yet about him.