The people who have the idea that Jay should have won are probably smoking crack.
I was at the olympia in person, and seeing the competetors in person gives you a much better idea of their shape than seeing pictures on the internet or PPV. When ronnie stepped on stage, most of the people around me started laughing and couldn't believe how big he was....they all KNEW he won.
Ronnie was far better from the front, the only thing Jay had close was his ab/thigh pose and his back had improved quite a bit. But he did not beat Ronnie, not even close.