Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
UGL OZ
UGFREAK
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsUGL OZUGFREAK

insatiable appetite. is something wrong or do I just lack willpower?

I have been so hungry and I can't seem to feel full. I ate 2375 cals today, 207 grams of protein, 54g of fat and *274* grams of carbs!! It has been pretty much all clean food, though. I know I should just ignore my hunger and stick to the plans, I'm just concerned that this could be symptomatic of a health problem. For instance, both grandmothers have diabetes, and my dad was recently diagnosed with hypothyroidism. I also wonder if I might have an eating disorder (compulsive overeating?). Does it sound like the chemicals in my brain aren't working correctly? Maybe I don't have enough of something (what tells you you have eaten enough?).

Background info: I have only been on the precontest diet for a month - and I went on vacation for 11 days when that was on hold - so I really doubt that its a reaction to deprivation. My cals have been around 1800. I have also been feeling really tired and unmotivated in the gym, but my mood has been good otherwise. Also, for those who recall my sugar junkie thread, this is not a problem with sugar. I successfully kicked that habit. Just hunger in general.
 
Last edited:
Every 3 hours.

Today, for instance:

Awoke @ noon

banana
.5 cup oatmeal
1 cup nonfat cottage cheese

banana
2 soy burgers (18g protein/ 5 g cho each) with soy cheese
instant coffee with soy milk

nonfat yogurt
.5 cup black beans
.3 cup soy crumbles
.25 cup salsa
2.5 cups of salad with 1 tbsp Udo's and balsamic

*Lifted back @ 10 pm*
Myoplex Light meal replacement shake immediately afterwards

----HUNGRY!!!!!!-----
Ate:
Pure Protein bar (280 cals: 30g protein, 28g carbs, 7g fat)
.5 cup nonfat cottage cheese
--and I admit it -- 2 slices of de-cheesed pizza that roommate ordered, couldnt resist it

Its now 3 am and I'm going to bed.

As I said before, the day totalled 2375 calories, 274g carbs, 207g protein, 54g fat.
 
VeggieLifterChick said:
I have been so hungry and I can't seem to feel full. I ate 2375 cals today, 207 grams of protein, 54g of fat and *274* grams of carbs!!

mmmmmmmmmm...breakfast....

:lmao:
 
I was wondering where you'd gone.

Dieting = hungry.

Increase your water intake. Chew sugar free gum. Eat sugar free Jello.
 
I'm pretty sure this has come up before, but I'll say once again that vego or not, you really need to eliminate all processed foods from your diet and if possible get them out of your sight. This particularly includes almost all high protein soy or veggie foods such as burgers, pizza, cheese, milk etc... If it's protein you need then get it from soy protein isolate, whey, egg whites or cottage cheese AND NOTHING ESLE. Do not eat protein bars or anything else designed to tempt your taste buds. Don't have them anywhere near home if you don't have an unbelievably strong willpower. Other than that, your cravings are pretty normal and your binge was not excessive. But PLEASE allow yourself regular high carb refeeds and follow SteelWeaver's advice between refeeds.
 
Spatts,
Just been eating bananas because I am allowed to have fruit and I happen to like bananas. Didn't realize they were high GI. I will go with apricots instead. Does the GI of a food have an effect on perceived fullness?
What is dextrose, exactly? Is that a sort of sugar? The post work out shake, Myoplex Light, has 2g sugar. The protein is whey, 25g.
I usually eat 35g of fat or so, but then my protein is around 145g at best.
I keep hearing that I need to drink a ton of water. What are the reasons for this and how much do I need?
Steel, the sugar free jello sounds good but doesnt sound filling. Also, since I'm sure you don't know this, DIETING SUCKS!!!
 
Ha ha - that's funny - I was coming back to say exactly the same thing. Touche, MS. Also, VLC - there are practically no veggies in your diet!! Aim for, like, 4 or 5 cups or broccoli or cabbage per day - this REALLY helps with hunger, and will provide your body with some good fibre, vitamins, you know - the good stuff in veggies. Salad has practically none of that in it, especially not if it's iceberg lettuce.

I'd agree on the refeeds, but what's your bf % at now? Don't do them too regularly til you're down in the mid to low teens.

Protein bars are some pretty dense calories. I find if I'm really losing it, a carrot hasn't ever ruined my diet - nice and crunchy, and sweet. Has more carbs than one would want, but at least it's not, like, 200- 300 cals like the bars.
 
Sorry MS I didn't see your post there when I replied to Steel and Spatts. Glad to hear that my cravings don't sound crazy.

My trainer said the veggie burgers were okay, perhaps she meant that to start out. She did say to stop eating processed foods. Do you think you could modify what I listed as what I ate today to reflect a better (nonprocessed) diet? I am a bit foggy on that concept. I do have Biotest Grow! protein powder which is 20g protein and 2g carbs per scoop and yummy. Should I be replacing the burgers with that? Like eating a whey shake and a cup of rice for a meal? Liquid diet?

Also, I am extremely unclear about this concept of a refeed. A refeed is a controlled carb binge, more or less, right? How often? Is it a day or a meal? What does it look like? Pasta? or just a lot of oats? How much? What amount of carbs should I be eating in grams the rest of the time? I know 275 is way high.
 
I'm glad I posted this because I've been learning quite a bit!

Okay, more for SteelWeaver.

1) 4 cups of cabbage...umm..sounds yummy...blech. Seriously though, what are good veggies to eat and how do you prepare them? I am not all that familiar with veggies that don't go into salads.

2) I know I wasn't supposed to have eaten the protein bar or the pizza. Binged.

3) Bf % was at 21.5% last time I got it checked, Aug 14. Its definitely not lower than that, due to the vacation. One good thing I have noticed about myself is that when I stick to the plans I see results pretty fast.

Should I use r-ala? With the refeeds?
 
MS said:
I'm pretty sure this has come up before, but I'll say once again that vego or not, you really need to eliminate all processed foods from your diet and if possible get them out of your sight. This particularly includes almost all high protein soy or veggie foods such as burgers, pizza, cheese, milk etc... If it's protein you need then get it from soy protein isolate, whey, egg whites or cottage cheese AND NOTHING ESLE.

I have a question - if it's been answered elsewhere, then someone kindly point me to the post! But protein powders are processed too. Why are they superior in this sense to veggie burgers?
 
VeggieLifterChick said:
Spatts,
Does the GI of a food have an effect on perceived fullness?
What is dextrose, exactly? Is that a sort of sugar? The post work out shake, Myoplex Light, has 2g sugar. The protein is whey, 25g.
I keep hearing that I need to drink a ton of water. What are the reasons for this and how much do I need?
 
MS/ STEEL

VeggieLifterChick said:

I do have Biotest Grow! protein powder which is 20g protein and 2g carbs per scoop and yummy. Should I be replacing the burgers with that? Like eating a whey shake and a cup of rice for a meal? Liquid diet?

Also, I am extremely unclear about this concept of a refeed. A refeed is a controlled carb binge, more or less, right? How often? Is it a day or a meal? What does it look like? Pasta? or just a lot of oats? How much? What amount of carbs should I be eating in grams the rest of the time? I know 275 is way high.
 
re: preparation for veggies - I go raw. Highest vitanmin content, more perceived fullness (for me). If you prefer them hot, steam them. I just keep a zillion of those plastic ziploc containers with blanched edamame, raw spinach, beans and broccoli in the fridge. If the flavor (or lack of it) is unbearable, try homemade italian with olive oil dressing or sprinkle Ranch mix on them. *just a little*
 
This is going to sound gross, but it works. Try a double-serving of fiber (Sugarfree Metamucil, Citrucel, etc.) in a large glass of water. It fills you up, trust me.
 
AAARRRRRRGGGHHHHH!!!!!!! #$%%&&%#$%

I just wrote the longest reply in the HISTORY of Elite, giving you every single possible link and bit of advice I could think of to help you, then when I hit submit reply, the %$%'&$%&E%$ machine had logged me out, and I lost everything!!!!!!


#$%#$%%T

I will try again later, I'm sorry - I'm too friggin' frustrated now - damn, that was the most fucking useful post I've ever made! DAMMIT!
 
Ahh SteelWeaver, it happens to me all the time too. But it's usually because my computer crashes instead of a server time-out. I've learned to keep my replies shorter (to the appreciation of most board members).

Makedah, as usual a keen question:
"I have a question - if it's been answered elsewhere, then someone kindly point me to the post! But protein powders are processed too. Why are they superior in this sense to veggie burgers?"

They are not superior for cutting, especially if they are intentionally designed to taste good. Whole foods are best IMHO, but if you restrict your diet to the extent that you don't allow yourself meat, ( in other words vego) then you are pretty much forced into using some protein powders while dieting. In this instance I would personally recommend you find the WORST tasting powders. We're only human (even worse, female) and if it tastes good it is very VERY easy to eat too much of it. This includes foods that are salty, sweetened (even if artificially), or drinkable. Anything sweet and chocolate flavored is particularily bad news for your average dieting female. Aside from that, protein powders do not seem to be as satiating as whole proteins from my observations. Foods designed to immitate meat products are even more irresistable to a lot of vegetarians in my experience. If you are craving meat-like foods then I personally think you're better off eating real meat.... Your body is trying to tell you something. Otherwise just add in a LOT more veggies, and cut as much processed food as you can. Avoid salty or sweet stuff.

Refeeds...........................................maybe I'll wait for Steel to repost her links etc... It is a complicated topic and may not apply to you if you have not yet lost much fat.
 
Aaah, heavy legs - DONE! :)

OK, I'm going to try this again. A tip, to anyone else who has this problem - oh, and MS, please don't shorten your posts just because of a silly MACHINE - remember - you're smarter than the machine (why am I not smart enough to religiously follow my own advice?): "select all" then ctrl + c BEFORE pressing "submit reply" - that way it's on your clip-pad if the machine has logged you out and sends you to platinum sign up (the secret black hole of Elite), and you emerge victorious: sign in, paste and post!!!! Whoo hay!!!

OR - work in wordpad or MS Word and press save every paragraph - I do this at work for just about everything - whole system crashes about noon every day ...

Now, VLC. I'm going to forgive you for not using the search button on this occasion, since these 2 links are not on Elite itself, but there is a WEALTH of information on refeeds on Elite if you use the search feature.

So, refeeds. First, go here:

http://www.mindandmuscle.net/magazine/pastissues.html

and read the articles called "Leptin: The next big thing" Parts I, II, III and IV, in issues #3, #4, #5 and #7. You might have to read them a few times, but they are WELL worth it.

Then, having grounded yourself in some theory, go here:

http://groups.google.com/groups?dq=...fitness.weights

(courtesy of MS on my thread about refeeds currently just a little way down the women's page) and read the entire thread, paying particular attention to anything Lyle McDonald, Elzi Volk or Par Deus say. While you're there, run a search on variations of the word "refeed" - ~s, ~ing, etc.

Then come back to Elite, and if you still don't feel satisfied, run a search here on refeeds under Par Deus or MS's user names. Also, PwB, Vageta and plornive had some very good posts/comments/q's on refeeds, so you might want to search those names too.

Your other questions: cabbage, broccoli, etc: lightly steamed. Or you could shred the cabbage raw and serve it with a *dash* of soy sauce. Don't BOIL your veggies

I don't know anything about biotest grow, but whey digests much faster than other proteins, so you may not want to be using too much whey except post-w/o. I use a 50% soy isolate, 30% casein 20% whey blend I got from www.proteinfactory.com - custom blend - tastes like shit, but like MS said, sure prevents one eating too much of the stuff, lol.

For more information on proteins, go here:

http://www.thinkmuscle.com/articles/mcdonald/protein-01.htm

and read all four parts of Lyle's article. The links to parts 2, 3, 4 are in each subsequent part.

Clean food is basically anything that you can pick off a tree, a bush, um, field crop, out of a nest, the ground, or with a shotgun :eek2: For you that means egg whites, yams, sweet potatoes, brown/wild rice, any kind of legume - chick peas, black beans, kidney beans etc., - broccoli, cabbage, brussels sprouts, cauliflower, etc. Avoid pumpkin, peas, carrots (in excess) - you know, northern winter soup type veggies. They're less fibrous, more starchy - you'll be doing yourself out of the nice REALLY glycogen stores filling carbs if you have too many of those. I THINK (???) Hmm, maybe someone can comment on that.

FF cottage cheese is OK, even if you can't pick it off the land - it's still pretty close. The protein in it is casein, slow-absorbing, and it doesn't have too many carbs, unlike milk and yoghurt. The lactose in those breaks down to glucose and galactose, the latter of which refills liver glycogen first, and when you don't have a lot of carbs to go around (which you DON'T, on a diet), you want to be sending what you can to your muscles for ATP/CP replenishment. Skipping the fruit is a good idea for the same reason - fructose refills liver glycogen stores first. Oh, I think, also, there's a connection between liver glycogen stores and fat-burning - your body thinks you're A-OK, ready to go, full of fuel and satiated when liver stores are full - I dunno - someone in the know can clarify here.

GI stuff:
"Does the GI of a food have an effect on perceived fullness? "

YES - high GI usually = sugar = huge blood sugar spike = insulin spike = fat storage and also = blood sugar crash = WANT MORE CARBS NOW!!!!

This is why most of America is obese, and why diabetes and insulin insensitivity are becoming such a problem. Thus, do not eat sugar or high GI foods ever if you can help it, except maybe on refeed days or post-w/o.

For more info on GI values and foods that are low - high GI, go here:

www.mendosa.com

Low GI carbs will promote sustained release of energy into the system, without dips and spikes = GREAT workouts and generally greater feeling of fullness/satiation (mostly because lower GI foods are also higher in fibre).

"What is dextrose, exactly? Is that a sort of sugar?"

Yes. It's up to you, but I'd skip all sugar on a diet (except on refeed days, if that).

OK, now, water: one, it makes you feel full (for about 5 minutes and then you down another glass :) )

two: all of this:

http://boards.elitefitness.com/forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=8357&highlight=water

I posted my diet for you before, VLC. I know you weren't too thrilled to see it, but it's the real deal. For now you can probably lose quite steadily just keeping your calories down, eating CLEANLY, drinking tons of water, training like a wild animal, and having a refeed every 2-3 weeks, if that. I'm not sure that you need them at 21%. From 15% down is when you'll really start needing them, but I can't see how a controlled carb-up along the lines of Beverly International (do a search for valerie's posts) would hurt in the meantime.

There will come a point where cottage cheese and carrots actually DO make a difference, but for now, happy reading!

Good luck!





(Oh, and I'm COMPLETELY open to corrections and additions here - there's only so much learning one can do with limited time)
 
Being a compulsive eater myself, I can tell you: Compulsive eaters eat when they are NOT hungry. That's the definition of compulsive eating. If you are feeling hungry, it isn't a question of being compulsive or lacking willpower.
 
The high GIs kill your diet. I'm refeeding today w/ instant cream of wheat, and not even enjoying the stuff after the first bowl (toooo sweet). Does that stop me from wanting to eat more and more and more? NOOOOO. I can hardly wait the 2-3 hours till the next meal. When I'm eating normally (low carb, high protein, moderate clean fat), I almost forget to eat. Almost. :-)
 
SteelWeaver said:
VLC? You OK? Busy reading, or just busy?

Hey Steel, I'm here. School started this week and I'm taking 17 credits plus I'm working 13 hours a week so I haven't had that much time to read the boards. I'm happy to say that all my classes are awesome.
Now, the sort of bad news:

I've gotten really frustrated with the dieting thing. Its extremely stressful on me because I'm not as adequately prepared as I thought. I haven't even gotten to the hardest parts of the diet and I'm already feeling like its a serious stuggle. I think a lot of the reason that its so difficult is the same reason I fall so far offtrack when I have any opportunity to cheat (like when I went away): I have this f*cked up mentality that I'm either on a strict diet in which every gram and calorie counts or I'm NOT, so I can eat everything and anything in sight. In other words, I don't really know how to have a healthy, clean diet as part of my lifestyle. Largely because I was unprepared mentally for the diet (extreme deprivation+vacation=major cheating) I now have only 8 weeks to lose just about as much bodyfat as when I started this thing. Not only that, but I spoke to my trainer yesterday and she said she went to a competition this past weekend and saw that the figure girls definitely had 5-10# more muscle than I've got right now, pre-hardcorecutting when I'll lose even more. So basically I would have to work my ass off and diet really hard to come in at a low enough bodyfat, and even after all that, I wouldn't come in as good as I could be.
It was hard to come to this decision, because I really wanted this, but I need to be honest and realistic. This isn't worth the all of the frustration, deprivation and stress (not to mention money) that I would have to deal with in order to prepare for the competition. Its not healthy, and its not making me happy, and on top of that I won't even come in the best condition I could for all of the hard work.
I decided that I'm going to work on laying the proper groundwork so that I can be prepared to go for a competition in the spring. I want to get the clean, balanced diet down. I would like to try to gain at least 5 pounds of muscle, which really shouldn't be too tough for me. And I especially want to get down to a reasonable bf%, which in my mind is 16%, and then maintain that. That way, come January or February, I can take 12 weeks to gradually get down to 12% (or whatever) for a competition. I think this would make things easier on my body and especially on my sanity.
I really appreciate all of the effort everyone has put into helping me out and informing me about this competition, especially the diet. I hope I haven't let anyone down with my decision to postpone the contest prep.
 
Last edited:
Aw shucks, VLC. I really hope my long-ass post didn't freak you out or anything. I was just trying to help :( I just get so excited by everything I've learnt ... I want everyone else to, too.

Well, it sounds like you're comfortable with your decision, and that's the important part. In many ways, I feel it's a good decision for you considering your circumstances. I was a little surprised when you decided to do this show with so little time to prep. I gave myself 20 weeks for my first show, and still didn't come in lean enough - a good part of the time was spent just coming to grips with what I was going through. An incredible experience altogether, but definitely something you need to be willing to sacrifice a lot of time and energy for.

And, yes, it really is a lot of hard work. And expensive.

Are you intending to keep dieting from now? Or lay off for a while? I strongly suggest that you don't just keep dieting all the way til Jan/Feb and then carry on dieting for your show. I may be off base here, but if it were me, I'd go hard and strict for a couple of months from now, try and stay there for another couple, then drop what you need for the show. That way your body won't be all dieted out by the time you REALLY need to kick it into shape. And you'll have a chance to figure out what works for you diet-wise. And you'll be able to have a fairly normal Christmas :)

PLEASE keep us up to date on how things go - I'd be VERY interested to hear how it feels to try and maintain 16% when "normal" is around 20-25% for you.

Good luck to you girl, and enjoy school. :)
 
Thanks for understanding, Steel. Don't worry, your post didn't cause me to quit the precomp stuff. I found it really helpful, honest, and full of info, as all of your replies are. The decision was based on a combination of factors.

SteelWeaver said:

Are you intending to keep dieting from now? Or lay off for a while? I strongly suggest that you don't just keep dieting all the way til Jan/Feb and then carry on dieting for your show. I may be off base here, but if it were me, I'd go hard and strict for a couple of months from now, try and stay there for another couple, then drop what you need for the show. That way your body won't be all dieted out by the time you REALLY need to kick it into shape. And you'll have a chance to figure out what works for you diet-wise. And you'll be able to have a fairly normal Christmas :)
:)

I'm not going to keep dieting, no. But I am going to try keep eating fairly cleanly. I'm going to eat pasta and have a protein bar on occasion and all the great stuff you can't have when you're precomp. I'm even going to eat the real cheat foods, like pizza and ice cream. The key to it for me is that I'm going to do it all in moderation - for instance, just one slice of pizza, and the small ice cream cones, and not both on the same day.
I actually joined up with a friend and we came up with some goals, both longterm and shortterm (a span of 2 weeks). She's somewhat new to lifting and eating healthfully. She weighs 220 and she's 5'6'' and wants to lose 60 pounds this year (4# a month). Her short term goal is drop atleast 5 pounds this month. My long term goal, as I've said, is to get to 16% bf and gain a little lean mass. I figure a loss of 3 pounds of fat per month should do it within a few months. My short term goal is to stick to what I said I would do and get back to 134, which is my "normal weight," 3 pounds from here. Somehow, when I'm over my normal weight, it comes off easily. Below that is more challenging. :D So, we're going to lift 4 days a week intensely and do cardio on our own 4-5 days a week for 45-60 mins a pop. (She's my twice a week lifting buddy for chest day and legs day).
We're going to drink 2 glasses of water with every meal and have no more than one non-water caloric drink a day. For instance, tea is okay but soda is not. Actually this is more her issue than mine. I'm pretty good about just drinking water. Anyways, also we're trying to eat 5 servings of veggies a day and 2 servings of fruit and take a multivitamin. I want to keep my protein over 100g a day, too. I think these are totally realistic and healthy guidelines that should aid my training and hopefully even let me lose some fat. I don't feel like its a diet - there's no deprivation. Its more a matter of making sure I get enough of things.
Oh, and the other part of our program is that every 2 weeks we're doing something to reward ourselves for meeting a goal and/or sticking to the program. We're thinking pedicures, going out to dinner at a nicer restaurant, etc.
 
Wait a moment, it just struck me that I didn't really understand what Steel wrote. Do you mean you think I should keep dieting for a few more months and then chill?

Either way, I'd love to hear your opinion/advice on my plans.

Also, I realized that 4-5 days of cardio when I'm not preparing for a show might sound like a lot, so I wanted to expand. I find that if I don't do cardio I get frustrated a lot easier and my temper is shorter because I have energy to burn. I can't stop lifting either. Lifting is meditation for me: I concentrate on the breathing and focus on contracting my muscles and executing the form correctly. It clears my mind and relieves my stress. when I exercise often I'm much more laid back, and a far happier person. Plus, I don't have to restrict my eating as much.

:)
 
Sorry VLC - I was getting to this, then realised I should try and give the impression of working for a little while ... :)

Look, to be completely honest - I don't know. I haven't been doing this long enough. But from everything I've read, and questions I've asked and so on, dieting for a long time is a bad idea:

a) because it fucks up your metabolism
b) because it drives you insane

and thus,

c) ultimately results in frustration, anger, depression, despair, etc. etc. because eerything stops working.

Thus it would seem to make more sense to me to do it in steps, i.e. diet now, then ease up a bit for a few months, maintainence calories or a bit more, gain a bit more muscle, then hit the pre-comp. diet hard from a lower bf and fresh metabolism perspective.

I will never ever do a 5-6 month pre-comp again. It drove me insane, and it was hell. And it helped to destroy a few relationships, too.

Your plan sounds OK to me, for now (for a few weeks or so), but might I recommend that you make your *own* pizza, if you HAVE to have it? Wholewheat crust, fat free cheese, reduced oil sauce etc. And eat fat free frozen yoghurt instead of ice-cream? I mean, these are not such difficult options, and better in the long run. If you MUST eat bad carbs and fats - at least separate them. If you read up a bit on insulin and sugar and fat and anabolism and fat storage, you'll see why, especially on a hypercaloric diet, you don't want to mix fat and carbs, ESPECIALLY not simple carbs (pizza crust, lactose in ice-cream) and saturated fats (cream in ice cream and cheese).

You could do sprints/intervals on a couple of your cardio days if you want to do that much cardio - but I would say that that much cardio will be counter to your hope to put on muscle, and will make it more difficult to ramp up to a high level of cardio when comp-prep sets in.

It's nice that you have a training partner. You can motivate each other. Just be aware that if one is losing more than the other, or getting stronger faster, or worse, LOSING motivation, eating a lot of crap, etc. it can be UNhealthy for your goals. This game is so mental it's not funny. A little friendly competition is fine, but I know *I* do much better just kicking my OWN butt.

So, to answer simply. Yes, I think you should keep dieting a few or even a couple more months, then take a break, then go again for the show. But that's just my opinion. Some of the vets on this board may have better ideas ...

Good luck :)
 
VeggieLifterChick said:
I find that if I don't do cardio I get frustrated a lot easier and my temper is shorter
yikes, tell me about it!!!! I'm the same way except instead of short tempered - I'm kinda just stressed-out & "wound up" without enough exercise. Since changing to strictly Olympic Lifting workouts, I've had some tough times unwinding without my former workouts.

Have you tried yoga? That could help. You could also lift 5X per week instead of 4 & cut down on the cardio. Unfortunately you can't just do more cardio to make up for eating more - doesn't quite work like that - especially since you need to add muscle. But once you pack on those extra LBS of muscle, then you CAN, you MUST eat more.
 
Was thinking about this some more... .how about doing more workouts that are not lifting, but not cardio -- still anaerobic?! I thought of some workouts that could help you keep working those fast twitch fibers, but get you the stress relief.

Sprints
Boxing!!!
--Gloves & bags - jab punch 6X, hold while your partner goes, etc. Awesome workout & hi-intensity, anaerobic.
Tennis is anaerobic too

I suppose my mindset is stuck that you need to keep cardio very minimal if your goal is gain LBM and/or get strong -> since my coach & team mates are telling me to cut cardio way down so my focus is exclusively the fast twitch work.
 
Sprinting sounds good, I'll definitely spend a day on that. Still, I have a hard time understanding why I can't do 5 hours of cardio a week and build muscle at the same time if I eat right and train right, because I've done it before. Maybe it only matters when you're at a low bf or when you're eating so minimally that you can't have enough energy??
 
Stimulation of different muscle fibre types, and the principle of SAID (Specific Adaptation to Imposed Demand - uh, or something). Which means that your body adapts to the demands you place on it. So if you eat too little, it slows everything down to compensate. If you lift heavy weights, it responds by laying down muscle, among other ways of improving anaerobic efficiency, so that it can cope better the next time you hit it heavy.

And if you make it perform long endurance activities, it will increase the efficiency of the aerobic/oxidative system, which is great for cardiovascular health, but also relies more on Type I muscle fibres, which don't grow as big as Type II muscle fibres. Instead, they are good for oxidative functions. Another adaptation is that the body will dump muscle, since muscle is heavy, and the body wants to be efficient - carrying a lot of extra dead-weight around simply uses up MORE energy than necessary for the activity that is being demanded of it. So, da DAH, bye bye muscle.

Have a look at any marathon runner - all skin and bones. Naoko Takahashi, the latest Japanese fave, can't weigh more than 40kg, if that. But boy can she run a long way pretty fast.

Cardio isn't bad - if you are interested in a healthy heart, and general overall fitness, you should definitely be doing it, but 5 hours a week is a lot. 3 x 30-45 or so should be enough. And like Gladi and I said, if one or 2 of those are sprints/intervals, you won't have to worry too much about breaking down your gym efforts, since sprints are anaerobic/glycolytic.

AND, your body won't be used to doing a ton of cardio before you even start comp prep. I taper my cardio almost all the way back before starting comp prep, so that I can slowly taper up all the way through the diet, without ever hitting a wall.

Um, does that help explain it?
 
I have a hard time understanding why I can't do 5 hours of cardio a week and build muscle at the same time if I eat right and train right,
I had felt the same way - why will working slow twitch fibers inhibit the growth of fast twitch - so long as I'm eating enough to fuel all the activity & growth??!!!

Below is an explanation from w6 - one of the best I've seen on the issue. Made sense to me too since I had learned about O2 utilization within the cells for my personal trainer exam (never learned that sorta thing in college - studied business).

http://boards.elitefitness.com/forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=166271&highlight=mito
 
Top Bottom