Oh, and if you break up with g/f #1 and go with #2, I can guarantee that she will be screwing a new guy every other day with you not knowing. That girl looks like she is attention starved (the bathroom scene of her taking a pic of herself gave it away...) so just being w/ you (since you are calling them "girlfriends," which I assume means something more than a fling...) is probably not how it's going to go. Those girls need CONSTANT attention. She'll screw you and then move on, I'm sure.
In one year she will look like my leather purse... used, abused, drugged out, fried out (tanning/hair dye), etc. But she is quite a cutey... for now.
So have some fun and go with her now... but don't cheat on the first g/f....