Maybe it was the girl who said, "I've never done that for anybody before."
I find girls to be sparing with their compliments. Yea they will say how good it feels and how good you are at something blah, blah, blah. But I give MUCH more flattering compliments to them.
I appreciate comments on my personality/intelligence over my physical appearance...it's nice to hear that someone thinks you're attractive but the same compliments from guys get boring over time...