You're wrong on their weight and what you think 140 is. Trust me.
Seriously. Unless he's standing over them as they weigh in and has calibrated the scale lol. I have a hard time believing a former soccer player (muscular legs) only weighs 135 at 5'9".
I think women lying about weight (pretty fucking common) has skewed what men think certain weight looks like. Plus, one number isn't going to look the same on every body. Bone structure as well as body composition play a huge role.