Ahhhh... well... i start forest fires with my thoughts on PWO nutrition...
DISCLAIMER: do what works for YOU. try different angles, keep a detailed log, ala
Bunnylicious, and reference it to plan the next experiment.
That having been said, I dont do PWO shakes. Ever. I eat whole food. My deal is that i am an insanely easy gainer as far as LBM and my whole life has been about LOSING my fuckups. I have lost between 106-111lbs of fat and added about 14lbs of LBM, and for me the answer is to eat SLOW digesting proteins, not 'high quality proteins' I dont want whey, i want chicken or turkey with some good MCT/EFAs and some good deep complex/fibrous carbs.
The last thing on the planet I need is 'easy to assimilate' proteins. I want those babies to go low and slow, so my body can use them sloooooowwwwly, not jam all that protein into my system as fast as possible to risk storing the spill over as fat...
The majority of the myth of 'QUICK! EAT SOME WHEY AND SIMPLE SUGARS' mantra was based upon studies for Enduance athletes and their needs in regards to glycogen replenishment window after bouts of Extraodinary Depletion involving exercise that lasted for more than 1.5-2 hours or better.
I get flamed for saying it all the time, but i have no need to push PWO shakes of Whey/Dextrose/Maltodextrin on anyone, pretty much ever. For me its about liking to eat my food, not chug it down in 10 seconds in a locker room for fear of not making my mythical protein window time frame. (which is more like 4-24 hours, btw, not 20 minutes.) So, all you 'HURRY UP AND DRINK YOUR PROTEIN' types, flame away, i am used to it...
What it boils down to is: do what works for you, Different strokes for different folks and all that... funny part is, most of the PWO Shakers i know have never tried it any other whey (sorry for the pun, i had too
)