Elite Fitness Bodybuilding, Anabolics, Diet, Life Extension, Wellness, Supplements, and Training Boards
Diet Discussion Board Does the Adkins Diet work?
|
Author | Topic: Does the Adkins Diet work? | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 337 |
IS A ALL PROTIEN DIET, AND NO CARBS THE BEST WAY TO LOOSE SOME FAT. WILL THIS TAKE AWAY FROM MY MUSCLE GROWTH AT ALL. IVE BEEN TRYIN MY HADEST TO LOOSE WEIGHT, NOTHIN WORKS. I DO CARDIO, ALTHOUGH I HATE IT, 25MINUTES TO AN HOUR 3-4 DAYS A WEEK AND LIFT HEAVY 4 DAYS A WEEK. I EAT CLEAN, AND JUST TRIED A CYCLE OF CLEN, AND GAINED WEIGHT ON ALL THAT. SO NOW IM CONSIDERING TRYIN AN ALL PROTIEN DIET. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 57 |
I was on the adkins diet for about a year or so. It was a good way to lose fat at first but the more I lost the harder it was to get off. I think the main thing on that diet is no sugar. At all. Zero. No ketchup no bbq sauce nothing that has sugar in it. It is the enemy. I talked to other people who were on it and they had no trouble at all. There are alot of thinks that has sugar in it. Hope this helps. | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 337 |
NO SUGAR AT ALL, WELL WHAT ARE YOU SUPOSED TO EAT. JESUS, I MEAN WHO CAN LIVE ON MEAT ALONE. AND IM STARTING TO HATE TUNA. | ||
Novice Posts: 7 |
The Atkins diet works very well for some people like my girlfriend and doesn�t work at all for others like me. I�ve tried it 3 times and I always end up getting the flu while not losing a pound. I think I tried every stupid diet in existence before I found something that worked. When cutting, I try to stick to a 40-30-30 type diet that has only 80%-85% of the total calories I usually consume. Morning meals are a little heavier on the carbs and the later meals are heavier on the protein. My last meal ( I eat 5 meals ) has no carbs at all. You have to find foods you like and be patient. The next trick is to get you metabolism up. I do cardio in the morning so as to take maximum advantage of the natural metabolic acceleration it provides. To keep the metabolism up through the rest of the day I supplement cardio work with E/C/A stack or Lipokinetix. Clen has never worked for me. Or maybe you�re one of the people Atkins will work for. -Preechr | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 57 |
I know man it really stinks. And its hard not to eat that stuff. The diet works for some and not others. Hope youre the one it works for.......r | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 374 |
If you are lifting weights a straight ketogenic diet is the fast way to lose lean muscle mass. Either a timed ketogenic diet, or cyclical ketogenic diet should be used to provide the glucose necessary for anaerobic activity, lest it be synthisized from amino acids, some of which will inevitably come from your own lean tissue. Also, the Atkins diet and all other ketogenic diets including the ones designed for weight training that involve strategically-timed consumption of carbs(Body Opus etc.) are NOT HIGH PROTEIN DIETS!!!!!! They are HIGH FAT, MODERATE protein, near-zero carb diets!! 60-70% fat, 30-35% protein, 5% carbs - not high protein. Too much protein = gluconeogenesis which= no ketosis which means the diet won't work unless you keep track of calories like any other diet. | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 429 |
If you follow it, you will lose some weight. | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 460 |
I tried this diet a few weeks a ago and I think i I ate tooooo much protien therefor I didn't lose a pond. I do not know how to get all the fat that is required without all that protein. Can someone list some keto diet foods that are high in dietary fat and moderatee in protein. I haven't been able to find shit!!!
------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 374 |
cheese, eggs, flax oil+whey, bacon, | ||
Novice Posts: 7 |
You may lose weight on the Atkins diet, but some of the foods such as bacon and eggs are still artery hardeners and not good for the heart. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 82 |
ok, it's time somebody debunked this Atkins stuff once and for all. 95% of the people who use this board are not competitive bodybuilders and their bodies aren't ready for/don't need a ketogenic diet. A ketogenic diet is used short term to trick your body. AND it has to be carefully planned and monitored. It's an advanced (and not healthy) diet strategy for competition-level athletes. Most people who try it use it wrong. That said, Atkins is even worse. Just eliminating carbs in the hopes that your body will use its fat stores simply doesn't work. The body needs carbs for fuel. When it doesn't get fuel it starts cannibalizing muscle long before it turns to the fat stores for fuel. Yes, cutting out simple carbs (sugars like fructose) is a good idea unless you need to quickly replenish glycogen stores. Cutting out complex carbs is the surest way to SLOW your metabolism and sacrifice muscle. Cut down on fat. Cut down on sugars. Eat RIGHT. ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 562 |
"ok, it's time somebody debunked this Atkins stuff once and for all. 95% of the people who use this board are not competitive bodybuilders and their bodies aren't ready for/don't need a ketogenic diet." Most competitive bodybuilders DO NOT use ketogenic diets for the simple reason that they are genetically gifted in the ability to lose bodyfat with little effort. If you look at where most competitive BB'rs start, they tend to be ectomorphs with a few mesomorphs...these are the people who have little problems with fat accrual. Duchaine stated that a keto diet is the best in terms of getting to low bodyfat % for the average person. "A ketogenic diet is used short term to trick your body. AND it has to be carefully planned and monitored." Short term?? You may want to tell this to all the epileptic children who are using Johns Hopkins' keto diet to control their seizures. Many of them are on a keto diet for over a year. "It's an advanced (and not healthy) diet strategy for competition-level athletes. Most people who try it use it wrong." How hard is simply eating meat and fat and checking foods for carb content?? The hardest part is not the food choice, but the will to stay on such a redundant choice of foods and suppression of carb cravings. "That said, Atkins is even worse. Just eliminating carbs in the hopes that your body will use its fat stores simply doesn't work. The body needs carbs for fuel. When it doesn't get fuel it starts cannibalizing muscle long before it turns to the fat stores for fuel." Eliminating carbs is the most efficient way at tapping into your fat stores. The body always uses some protein for fuel in the first days of any diet (that is sub-maintanance calories), this is due to the fact that enzymatic pathways necessary for fat utilization have to be up-regulated. The benefit of a keto diet is that amino acid oxidation reduces after initiation of ketosis, whereas on a low fat, high protein diet, amino acid oxidation remains high. Also, the body does not need carbs for fuel, this is simply not true. The body PREFERS carbs. "Yes, cutting out simple carbs (sugars like fructose) is a good idea unless you need to quickly replenish glycogen stores. Cutting out complex carbs is the surest way to SLOW your metabolism and sacrifice muscle. Cut down on fat. Cut down on sugars. Eat RIGHT." Low fat diets show greater loss of lean body mass than higher fat diets. Simple reason: with no fat for fuel, the body resorts to oxidation of aminos for fuel. Also, even though T3 is suppressed faster on a low carb diet, this does not seem to deter the effects of a keto diet. | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 39 |
Go to NewYorkMuscle.com for a sample menu (bodyopus). Or The PowerStore.com has a good article on ketogenic diet with a list of foods. Personally, I've used this type diet the last two contest seasons. Last year I didn't get in good enough shape to compete and this year I placed 3rd in my class. The diet is very easy for me and works so well the first month (even though my workouts suck) that I stick with it for two or three more months, and it just doesn't seem to get me "ripped" past a certain level. Don't get me wrong it will suck the water out of you during the no-carb period giving you a lean but flat appearence. I guess the best diet is the one you can stick with. Lyle McDonald wrote a good book "The Ketogenic Diet" on the subject. I'll help you with any questions if I can, but I'm still looking for the right diet for me to get that dry vascular look. ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 374 |
Unfortunately, the dry and vascular look often depends more on genetics and drugs than diet - it's a hard thing to achieve. | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 47 |
Atkin's diet is definitely a fad diet. I suppose it's all a matter of opinion but high carb diets have always worked best for me and others I know. Carbohydrates aren't fashionable but they are what nature designed the human body to run on. I have just lost 15 kilos of fat on a high carb diet with protein intake at 1 gram per pound of bodyweight. My advice: keep fat right down, only eat as much protein as you have to and give priority to carbs. Avoid refined foods, especially sugar. The stuff is POISON! Red meat will just make your body acid, but atkin's diet causes acidosis anyway. Its not a good strategy for long-term health. Ketogenic diets will always catch up with you in the end. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 78 |
Lizzy, can you please post a sample of your diet? | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 39 |
Vlaovic, You seem knowledgeable. What's your opinion of the best way to diet??? I read your current diet on the "post your diet thread". It appears like you do somewhat a "Zone" type diet? [This message has been edited by baldbeefman (edited November 14, 2000).] | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1098 |
Wellllll.......since Cockdez1 has joined these boards I have tended to agree with him/her. Until now. I am not in dis-agreement, I just think that on some aspects of diet (like sooo much else in life) men are different from women. I think I may have asked this question before (on this board or this women's board) but I am still looking for competitive bodybuilding FEMALES that have done well on high fat/near zero carb diets. My experience is similar to Lizzy's in that I take in the minimum amount of protein to do the job. All else is carb, and the fat is incidental, but adequate. I've tried CKD and lost water weight (went flat) and muscle. So yes the scales went down. I am not taking any androgens, and I'm sure that AAS supplementation can shift a female's metabolism towards what you guys are describing. But I am still waiting for legitimate success stories from women that have done well on any type of ketogenic diet. Lizzy, it sounds like you've got your dieting act together (is it fair to assume you're female???). I hope you will contribute to the women's board sometime because I feel there is much you could share that would be of interest. This topic will probably die in it's tracks, but I hope that we will get some enlightening input from the likes of Cockdez1, MR. BMJ, Valdez or anyone else that has experiences to share. P.S. High fat diets equal increased Test in men, inceased Estrogen in women (although most hormones increase in both sexes on a high fat diet). Food for thought?? | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 349 |
I keeped going pass this thread for quite some time, and I have to say, it is a rather interesting one. Has not been too many lately for some reason. As of right now, it is 1:48 am in the morning and I am tired as hell, so I will probably not be too helpful right now. BUT, let me get a few words in here. I think cockdezl hit it pretty much on the dot with his dissection of the previous guy/gal's post (cant remember the name/handle). Most pro's are well gifted individuals that have never really had a problem of being the usual fatties (no offense here), and even if they did, they are using every drug imaginable to keep in shape even when bulking. I mean look at Ronnie Coleman at 300 pounds. He is not even fat, just water retented. The combination of DNP, Growth Hormone, Thyroid meds, and everything else keeps these guys lean even when they are not competing. Therefore, if you can get down to contest shape on a non-keto diet, then why bother with the hassle of eliminating the carbs. Personally, I am not that gifted, and I gain more than my fair share of "stubborn" body fat, and it can only be lost through a CKD. If I could do it without a CKD, I would, but I can't. And yes, I do not have the money for growth hormone and every other drug that would come in handy. MS brought up an interesting point that women may not benefit from a keto type diet. This may or may not be true. I have neither the experience working with competitive women bodybuilders nor the knowledge in body physiology/biochemistry to figure this out. I have put many women/girls I know on a CKD with exceptional results, but never any that planned on competing with competition bodyfat levels. This is interesting though. I think I remember your previous post about this topic MS, and if I remember right, the topic of Elzi Volk came up, am I right? Maybe cockdezl can help us out with this. I have put women on a CKD with the supplementation of juice, DNP, T3, etc. but again, they never had the intent of competing. Most women I have worked with only want that "tone" look, and once they get to that level, they usually quit with the dieting. I did notice that Elzi's lower body did not match the leanness of her upper body. I figure that Lyle McDonald would have been able to help this if he could of, but then again, he has also complained that he cannot get rid of that extra bit of fat on his lower abdomen too. Normally, I would just tell someone to experiment with Yohimbine for that stubborn fat, but I am sure Elzi used this, especially after writing her GREAT article on the Meso board. A keto and E/C/yohimbine usually do a number on the stubborn fat, but if MS is right, then there has to be something else which is factoring in here. A lot of people figure this has to do something with androgen receptors, but I have not heard anything other than educated guesses. Actually, I am gonna stop here and think about this some more before I start giving out wrong answers and STUFF (mainly ramblings of uneducated crap due to being tired. Also, I am pretty brain dead from reading 3 chapters of my microbiology book). Hopefully others can give some input on this too. I'll be back tomorrow sometime. Later. MR. BMJ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 562 |
MS/MR. BMJ, do not get me wrong, I am not a keto/low carb fanatic, what got me about the above poster was his/her assesment that these diets are fads and dangerous/or detrimental to health. I beleive that YOU must find out what is best for you, since diet is very individual. Like I stated before, people like the pro's have amazing genetics and can get ripped on Twinkies and flipping through the channels on TV, while some people must literally put a gun to their head to drop a few pounds (I seem to be in the latter...where's my damn gun?). Realistically, everyone would love to be like the pro's, in the fact that they can eat high carb diets and lose fat, but that just ain't the case. MR. BMJ stated above that Elzi Volk used a keto diet to get in competition level, and although her lower body was not as good as the upper, she was still very impressive. We know that women have stubborn fat depots in the lower body due to hormones and alpha-2 receptors, and this is a fact no matter what the diet. We know that keto diets do not show significant differences in weight loss compared to that of high carb diets, but new research is showing that the choice of carbs (or restriction of) does make a difference in LBM retention. A recent study showed that low GI carbs caused less LBM loss, as compared to high GI. This seems to smack us in the face, since we assume that the insulin spikes should be anabolic, but from research we know that the more insulin present, the more gluconeogenic activity (muscle breakdown, or protein utilization). With lower carbs or lower GI carbs, there is a reduction in insulin plus an increase in fatty acid levels, which suppresses gluconeogenesis, thus preserving muscle. P.S. MR. BMJ, did you get my e-mail on your unknown? Did you get the results yet? | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 349 |
cockdezl, yeah thanks for the e-mail, my unknowns are due tomorrow, well actually, as of two minutes ago, they are due later on today. I am pretty sure I have Pseudomonas aeruginosa because she only used the organisms that we experimented with in class. Therefore, this leaves out all other Pseudomonads because aeruginosa is the only one we used. She gave us 2 organisms, one being a positive and one being a negative. My other organism is definately a nonenterococcus. I think the thing that threw me off was that I used a flow chart for the nonenterococcus, which made it plain and simple. For the P. aeruginosa, I did not have one, I just had a gram (-) rods enterics flow chart, and with it having no change in my TSI slant, the only thing else I could really do was check for it being oxidase positive, which it was, and also the rest of the enterics tests, which matched in results. There was more too, but nothing I didn't mention in my post that you answered in your e-mail. Bottom-line, I'll find out later today, hehehe. Now, back to this post. I lied last night. I said I would do more on it today, but since school has been a little hectic lately, and my micro lab book and unknowns are due tomorrow (I mean today), I will have to come back here tomorrow (later today). Until uhh later...MR. BMJ | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1098 |
Hi guys. I guess we're way off topic by now! I think the bottom line is the same for everyone. Dieting is not a hard-core science so we do have to find out what works for each individual. But where to start and what to try next should be based on education, not on fads. Whether or not Atkins or any of the other ultra low carb diets are a fad will require the test of time. For now, I can feel smug since I'm obviously one of those folks that can diet well on a medium-high carb, ultra low fat diet. And I don't want to see Elzi Vokyl crucified because of a little lingering lower body fat (or any other woman for that matter). I think she was both a novice (first competition) and older than your average novice. Kudos to her. But I'm still waiting to hear from women who are NOT taking gear/hGH, etc... (in other words Non-pros?) who think this diet is the bee's knees and have got truly shredded on it. And that's not a 'challenge', just a legitimate desire to know if they exist and talk to them about how they find high fat diets. | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 436 |
I've done it, you loose fat, but your energy levels in the gym suffer greatly!! Doing a hard set of squats is almost impossible on a zero carb diet. ------------------ | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 217 |
"Red meat will just make your body acid, but atkin's diet causes acidosis anyway. Its not a good strategy for long-term health. Ketogenic diets will always catch up with you in the end." This statement stinks of ignorance. I can't stand people making naive, wide and sweeping generalizations. How could you possibly know that a ketogenic diet will "always catch up with you"??? What the hell does that even MEAN??? The bottom line is it works for some people, and not necessarily for others. If you feel good on the diet, then go for it. IF you feel like shit, eat carbs. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 152 |
Sounds like this adkins diet is nothing but "keitosis" It is a way to do it, however keitosis is dangerous. The body needs about the amount of carbs in 3-4 apples a day. If it's working though, have at it. Good luck. 4rt ------------------ | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 47 |
It does work if done properly. The trick is you can't cheat AT ALL during the week. If you do, you're right out of ketosis. I went from 224 to 198 in less than 2 months. It was a relatively painless diet once you get used to it. For a simple overview, check out the following site : | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 34 |
Thanks for the info. Would the diet work as effectively WITHOUT the huge fat intake? I just don't feel right eating such fatty foods. If I can endure the lethargy and low energy levels, would it work if I cut out the fats as well? Or would that mean my calories are so low that my metabolism would slow to a stop? What do you think about replacing the fatty foods with lean, protein foods? So I'm eating almost 100% protein? Would that work? Ooooh boy! Better get the old constipation relief and haemorrhoid cream out. ------------------ | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 799 |
The less carbs I eat, the worse my lifts get at the gym. I'm slowly going downhill at the gym. But, I seem to be obsessed with eating low carbs....I still eat alot of fat and protein, but, carbs are low....too low for me it seems anyhow.... | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1098 |
Lisa and Lizzy (and anyone else who fits the bill) If low carbs are not for you then don't beat you head against the proverbial stone wall. I still think you and I have a similar metabolism, and I know for certain that I have NO ENERGY for anything on an ultra low carb diet. I also can tell you that for the last 12 weeks I have been eating what my body tells me I need, and doing NO WEIGHT training and NO CARDIO I have lost 6 kilos (around 11 lbs) and look and feel great!! My strength is through the roof this week having just started weight training again, and I've been eating 2-3 meals per day (max) with my biggest meal in the evening JUST before I go to bed for a long, deep, carb-induced sleep. In other words, for this so-called bulking cycle I am truly listening to my body and it works great. Don't be afraid to eat carbs if that's what your body really needs to be happy and healthy. Maybe I should start a support group called "carb-a-holics-anonymous". Save the low carb tricks for the next time you want to cut. BUT BUT BUT, If low carb/high fat works for you as a fatloss or bulking diet then GO FOR IT. You will never know until you try. | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 349 |
MS, I have been thinking about this for a long time, and it is driving me nuts. Obviously you have found what works for you, but I have no idea why a keto/CKD does not help with your dieting for them hard stubborn fat areas. It is such an effective diet at working on those A-2-adrenoceptors, which as you probably know, is what makes up the majority of fat cells in the lower body, etc in women. After looking at the pics, I have to say you definately know your body (trust me on this folks). I have a stack of journals on the distribution of the different fat cells (both men and women), receptors, etc. which I have read and not read (YET), and after my finals this week, I am gonna have to do some more research. One thing I do agree on here is that in most cases, if not all, people should get down to as low body fat as possible before taking on a keto type diet. Why eat fat, grease, and protein, when you can do it with carbs. It just makes sense to me. I generally try and get down to around 9% bodyfat before doing a keto diet. At least that's what I have done before. Now, I have no problem jumping into a keto/CKD because my body adjust to it quickly. Also, I have done my fair share of dieting, and I know what to do and what not to do in order for it to work wonders for me. Because I have been in such A Micro-studying phase lately (hair is turning gray), I have not had much time to do anything. Actually, the classes I have the hardest time with are my non-major classes like business/management and non science classes. They drive me insane!!! | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1098 |
Maybe differing goals is what's confusing you MR BMJ. This discussion is probably better on Lizzy's thread about bulking without adding fat. I am not "dieting" to lose or gain anything right now. I mostly think that carbs have been over villianized lately to the point where people are afraid to eat them at any stage of their training. There is nothing revolutionary about high-carb bulking diets for bodybuilders. It's still the most tried and true formula. And after too many years of pre-contest dieting I see no need to feel miserable when I'm not dieting. As I said above, it makes sense to leave the low carb diets for when you really need them for fat-loss. That way you also have a trick up your sleeve to shock and confuse your body once the fatloss has slowed. Or, as you said, wait until you're already pretty lean and use high fat diets to get that last bit of stubborn fat off (if that works for you). | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 349 |
Sorry MS, I had it confused. Now i'm on the same page as you . I thought you meant that ya didn't use them anymore on a dieting phase. I definately agree to use them when bulking. By the way, have you read the articles on musclemonthly.com by Elzi Volk? They are very good and it might be beneficial to have them posted on the women's board (guys too you should read them too). She has definately became one of my favorite contributors to this industry. One smart gal!!! MR. BMJ | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 34 |
Can anyone tell me why a ketonic diet requires the high fat intake? Call me naive (which I am) but I don't see why a high fat and protein diet would be any better than a simply high protein diet. Unless it's got something to do with the alpha whatevers on your fat cells.... those receptor things. If that IS the answer, would someone mind explaining that in detail? If you're okay with the low energy levels and lethary, what advantage does increased fat have? Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I can't get over the idea of eating a lot of fat while trying to lose it. ------------------ | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 13 |
The ketogenic diet requires a high fat intake because if you were to eat 100% protein, you wouldn't be able to achieve ketosis, even. And that's because protein gets converted into glucose in order to be utilized by the body. It is only fat that goes through a totally different channel and in the process, induces ketosis. Plus, personally, I only ever feel full for longer than 5 minutes when my meals contain a higher percentage of fat. | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 39 |
Works great from what I hear. --------- " I got news for you pal, your only leding to things right now, Jack and Shit and Jack's left town " | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 137 |
ive seen it work with myself and my friends...I gain and lose weight really fast and have lost about 7 pounds using this diet for one week very strictly and working out hard, after a while, you dont hjave any energy though and needto get off of it to lift heavily...I like to use this diet to lose weight fast, then eat very healthy afterwards including carbs so that it doesnt all come back...because if you arent careful, it will come back real fast |