UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!
  George Spellwin's ELITE FITNESS Discussion Boards
  Chat & Conversation
  old school bodybuilders vs new school bodybuilders

Post New Topic  
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

Author Topic:   old school bodybuilders vs new school bodybuilders
thiassi
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 835)
posted July 07, 2000 07:15 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for thiassi   Click Here to Email thiassi     Edit/Delete Message
I think the old pics of Arnold in his prim are a thousand times better than todays pro's.
It seems they just go too far today, and just don't look as good.

L8R

------------------
Warning spell checker (not responding)
PRESS ENTER TO CONTINUE

IP: Logged

Slopain
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 789)
posted July 07, 2000 07:19 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Slopain   Click Here to Email Slopain     Edit/Delete Message
probably gonna get flamed for this one but I totally agree, for me I want to be big but not a freak. Respect those freaks cause they have made a total and very literal Lifetime commitment to look the way they do, but as far as aesthetically speaking - I love the old timers looks, no bloat, no oil in the shoulders, no balloon look, a nice tight clean and ripped look. I like that.

Slopain

IP: Logged

THE STEEL BEAST
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 587)
posted July 07, 2000 07:21 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for THE STEEL BEAST   Click Here to Email THE STEEL BEAST     Edit/Delete Message
USED TO BE ABLE TO COVER FACES AND STILL TELL WHO WAS WHO.NOW ITS IMPOSSIBLE.NEW SCHOOL IS NOT REALLY APPEALING ANYMORE

------------------
IS SUCCESS THE CONSTANT LACK OF FAILURE?OR IS SUCCESS CONSTANT FAILURE OVERCOME BY SINGLE SUCCESSES?

IP: Logged

BACKDRAFT
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 159)
posted July 07, 2000 08:24 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for BACKDRAFT   Click Here to Email BACKDRAFT     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 79358778
There's a saying that really holds true,THEY DON'T MAKEM LIKE THEY USED TO.

IP: Logged

Cleaner
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 448)
posted July 07, 2000 11:22 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Cleaner   Click Here to Email Cleaner     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 8790283
I aspire to look like Zane!

IP: Logged

Capt'n_Crunch
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 1027)
posted July 07, 2000 11:25 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Capt'n_Crunch   Click Here to Email Capt'n_Crunch     Edit/Delete Message
I vote for the old school, new school is just over bloated, over synthetic, and ridiculous.

IP: Logged

Recoome
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 72)
posted July 07, 2000 11:30 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Recoome   Click Here to Email Recoome     Edit/Delete Message
Has anyone seen pictures of Arnold while he was training, while pumped to the max?? Shit those muscles were pure quality, and his waist had to be fucking size 28!! That looks way the hell better than today's drug-filled dogs

IP: Logged

mrbill
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 75)
posted July 07, 2000 11:31 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for mrbill   Click Here to Email mrbill     Edit/Delete Message
well looks like a clean sweep so far for the old school...to me Arnold will always be "The Man"

IP: Logged

slabcat
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 190)
posted July 08, 2000 12:05 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for slabcat   Click Here to Email slabcat     Edit/Delete Message
Gotta jump on the bandwagon here. Old schoolers look much better. BB's now just try to get everything as big as possible no real sculpting anymore.

------------------
Someday we will meet in a place where there is no darkness, or S-police!

IP: Logged

Recoome
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 72)
posted July 08, 2000 12:15 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Recoome   Click Here to Email Recoome     Edit/Delete Message
LOOK AT THAT FUCKING WAIST

IP: Logged

superdave
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 376)
posted July 08, 2000 12:23 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for superdave   Click Here to Email superdave     Edit/Delete Message
Jesus, I forgot about his wasp-waist! He may have used roids, but with that waist it obviously doesnt even come close to what the pros shove into their bodies now. Arnold Rules, period

IP: Logged

mystic_hormones
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 93)
posted July 08, 2000 01:19 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for mystic_hormones   Click Here to Email mystic_hormones     Edit/Delete Message
flame me if you want but I am for new school because well I would rather look like Dorian or ronnie than ferrigno or arnold. though I do hold a high respect for old because they are responsible for what the sport has today.

------------------
if they don't lift...
-RIP 'EM A NEW ONE-

IP: Logged

TxCollegeguy
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 380)
posted July 08, 2000 01:22 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for TxCollegeguy   Click Here to Email TxCollegeguy     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 48636409
Here here...The Old timers are still where it should be....Props to the freaks, but the old timers just make it look better....

when I was Young and Arnold was speaking all the time on fitness in kids back in the Early Bush years thats what got me motivated to one day get into Bodybuilding...I really enjoyed how overall apealing the old school guys looked

IP: Logged

Tulk311
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 59)
posted July 08, 2000 01:36 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Tulk311     Edit/Delete Message
Hell yeah old school all the way!!!
What i want to know is how did all those old school bodybuilders keep there waist so tight! Even the amatuers in todays contest dont really have that same look,...cmon i know u guys know what im talkin about!!??
Tulk311

IP: Logged

MrMuscle
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 1144)
posted July 08, 2000 06:48 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for MrMuscle   Click Here to Email MrMuscle     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 70512967
old school, new school...the only really difference is tht they have newer and better drugs. i like a bit from both worlds...i mean..look at Lou Ferrignio when he was at his biggest he had MONSTER traps, i mean, they were so thick no current bb can measure up to it...and now we have guys like Milos, he has good symmetri, small waits and all that..but he aint winning anything. reason? cuz we want it BIGGER. Thats why we al are rooting for Lee Priest, hes the biggest freak out there.

but i agree, nobody looks like arnold and columbu did..but if they did..would the win anything??

------------------
"Pain, is only weakness leaving your body"

"...damn you for not giving my TEST" - Metallica

"After this show i'll be fat and happy again.....If i make it to the show...." - Lee Priest

IP: Logged

COnCReTE_MAsS
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 3)
posted July 08, 2000 07:02 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for COnCReTE_MAsS   Click Here to Email COnCReTE_MAsS     Edit/Delete Message
old school wins it all , lou,arnold are the best !!
i was always wondering what can u do if u want to have this symmetery ?

IP: Logged

bikinimom
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 156)
posted July 08, 2000 07:21 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for bikinimom   Click Here to Email bikinimom     Edit/Delete Message
arnold, Arnold, ARNOLD. nuff said.

IP: Logged

thiassi
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 835)
posted July 08, 2000 07:21 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for thiassi   Click Here to Email thiassi     Edit/Delete Message
MrMuscle, I don't think they could even get pro status today. They were big, but todays judges want to see almost 0% fat and almost 0% water in thier systems. I think todays pros are some of the most unhealthy people around. I think it is kind of a shame. Judges need to go back to the old standards of quality muscle and symetrey.

L8R

------------------
Warning spell checker (not responding)
PRESS ENTER TO CONTINUE

IP: Logged

The Ranger
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 1313)
posted July 08, 2000 10:47 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for The Ranger   Click Here to Email The Ranger     Edit/Delete Message UIN: 67366885
This isn't even close....OLD SCHOOL!!!

------------------
Ranger


IP: Logged

mightydog
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 329)
posted July 08, 2000 11:59 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for mightydog   Click Here to Email mightydog     Edit/Delete Message
If this freakish escapade continues, it might as well be called "The professional steroid users competition."

IP: Logged

t
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 29)
posted July 08, 2000 12:18 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for t     Edit/Delete Message
Actually I think arnold's waist was 34inches at 240 ilbs, but because of his v-taper it seemed so small-yep judges should not have rewarded bloated people like sonbaty/dorian and then maybe we would see more 'classic' looking bbs out there today, but hey- shawn ray still looks pretty sculpted, as does wheeler when he doesn't weight too much.
thankx

IP: Logged

The Whole F/N Show
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 108)
posted July 08, 2000 01:17 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for The Whole F/N Show   Click Here to Email The Whole F/N Show     Edit/Delete Message
There is a real difference in the DRUGS, nutrition, and even training methods used today vs. then. So Arnold probably would've been sucessful today. Would he have dominated? Who knows? I'm betting many of the pro's then could have been pros today. Look at Lou Ferrigno. He competed in the 70's and in the 90's and looked quite different during each era (not just the haircut either). 90's Lou would've kicked the 70's Arnold's ass, but who know what the 90's Arnold would've looked like.

70's Lou

90's Lou

[This message has been edited by The Whole F/N Show (edited July 09, 2000).]

IP: Logged

MaxMuscle
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 174)
posted July 08, 2000 03:41 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for MaxMuscle   Click Here to Email MaxMuscle     Edit/Delete Message
I personally like the bodybuilders today. I believe they're much more impressive, but I know that they use a lot roids. I like Dorian Yates. But if I could chose my physique, I would like to have a physique like Mike Mentzer and Casey Viator. They look more natural.

------------------
Go Huge Or Go Home

IP: Logged

t
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 29)
posted July 08, 2000 04:40 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for t     Edit/Delete Message
personally I think 70's lou looks better than 90's
thankx

IP: Logged

bigal
Amateur Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 82)
posted July 08, 2000 05:41 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for bigal   Click Here to Email bigal     Edit/Delete Message
I like old school better, but Arnold was a freak of nature himself. No one else had the shoulder to (wasp)waist dro like him. He would have won today because of his mentality. He was a winner and if he was competeing today he would have done whatever it took to win.

------------------
TRAIN AND GROW


IP: Logged

lexicon
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 303)
posted July 08, 2000 06:48 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for lexicon   Click Here to Email lexicon     Edit/Delete Message
The older guys look much better. Though I even think they are way to big to look good. Present day pro bodybuilders look horrible. The reason people look at them is because they are freaks, not because they look good.

IP: Logged

Jim Layhoe
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 510)
posted July 08, 2000 11:26 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Jim Layhoe   Click Here to Email Jim Layhoe     Edit/Delete Message
Old school

IP: Logged

The Whole F/N Show
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 108)
posted July 09, 2000 01:01 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for The Whole F/N Show   Click Here to Email The Whole F/N Show     Edit/Delete Message
Arnold's taper was damn good but so was Lee Haney's. Haney's kinda in between old school bodybuilder and modern day freak IMO. Ol' Skool guys definately look healthier becuase they were. MaxMuscle for those days Mentzer used a lot of roids.

[This message has been edited by The Whole F/N Show (edited July 09, 2000).]

IP: Logged

MaxMuscle
Pro Bodybuilder
(Total posts: 174)
posted July 09, 2000 03:38 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for MaxMuscle   Click Here to Email MaxMuscle     Edit/Delete Message
I'm very sure that Mentzer and Viator juiced. What I was commenting on, was that I would rather look like them, because they 'look' more natural. Every bodybuilder back then juiced.

------------------
Go Huge Or Go Home

IP: Logged

All times are ET (US)

Post New Topic  
Hop to:

Contact Us | Back to Elite Fitness

Elite Fitness Discussion Board

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board (UltimateBB), Version 5.42a
� Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998-1999.