Elite Fitness Bodybuilding, Anabolics, Diet, Life Extension, Wellness, Supplements, and Training Boards
Chat & Conversation A word about the US surplus and Bushy's tax cut...
|
Author | Topic: A word about the US surplus and Bushy's tax cut... | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
A surplus means that the taxpayers paid too much, now the Demo's want to spend that money to pay down our national debt. Can you imagine giving a store $10 for something that costs $5 and them telling you that you can't have your money back because their company made some bad decisions back in the 80's and they really need it. Now, I think paying down the debt is a good thing. But that is something that needs to be voted on in Congress. Instead the Demo's are saying: "Well they paid too much, let's spend it anyway". No dice. They should do what Ventura did when there was a surplus in Minnesota. He sent everyone a check who paid too much. That's how it should work, you pay too much and you get your $ back. Where I'm from, taking money is called stealing... [This message has been edited by Mr. T (edited March 08, 2001).] | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 454 |
The problem with your analogy is the we/them(store) part. It's all OUR debt. We are the store. If WE don't pay if off, congress can't pay it for us. The Dems are saying We spent too much in the past, and collected too little in the past, so now that we're collecting too much now, let's pay it off now while we can. While Bush says let's give it back to my rich friends that got me elected and maybe we'll have enough to pay down the debt too, hope hope hope... The reason Ventura can send a check back is the states are not allowed to do deficit financing. His state doesn't have a debt to pay, so his surplus is a REAL surplus, and he's free to refund it. And of course I could go into the whole Regan fucked up and cut taxes, and everybody (dems & reps) raised spending creating massive inflation but that's another thread. But the thing that really scares me is we appear to be headed for doing the same thing all over again. [This message has been edited by john937 (edited March 08, 2001).] | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: I see by your post that you watch a lot of CNN. I guess propaganda does work! | ||
Freak Posts: 2306 |
2thick should change his name here to "propoganda". What people seem to forget is that it was the dems that approved the tax cuts in the 80's that resulted in the debt. Now they want to penalize us today to pay it off instead of changing their huge spending on social programs. ------------------ | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: LOL that sounds pretty funny... But seriously, when you hear something on TV for the 1st time (the night before) and then every sheep repeats it without being able to explain what it really means, that is called propaganda. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1292 |
2thick = poo-poo head | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 995 |
quote: I don't know about you, but I don't remember borrowing money from anybody. -Warik ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
2Thick- When did opinions of one US citizen become propoganda? Don't you think it's kind of sad that you have nothing to offer but insults? You actually cut and paste articles instead of forming your own opinion, did somebody say sheep? And actually, I watch MSNBC. My analogy is fine. The US taxpayer is the customer. It is up to Congress to manage the store that we elected them to manage. When they fuck up it's their job to bail themselves out, not the taxpayers. Cutting the budget comes to mind. | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote:
| ||
Freak Posts: 2306 |
Hey 2thick, how is your new lame-ass board "anabolicfitness.net" coming along. That place is a joke when you got guys like decaman running things. Whys are all the normal bros like E2, Ulter etc hanging with that zero? ------------------ | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: Why do you say that it is my board? | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
2Thick- If you have read any of my posts in the past you would know that I have always thought that we are overtaxed in the US. I am actually an independant. An ideology is a set of beliefs. This is only one about taxes. Not my fault other people think we are overtaxed. Our founding fathers thought we were overtaxed too. It's kind of in our blood. Next time don't jump the gun and make assumptions about my beliefs. If I am a republican than I am the only one that thinks it's OK for gays to marry and all drugs should be legalized. When you assume 2Thick you only make an ASS out of U and ME. | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: LOL! An ideology is not a stance on issues. It is an all encompassing set of beliefs. The belief in individualism, freedom, etc is an ideology. Politics are not important in an ideology since politics assume that you have a shared set of norms and values that keeps the nation stable enough to argue over the details. If you didn't share the US ideology then you would be in a cabin in the middle of the woods stockpiling weapons... You have much to learn. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
I'm not sure how stupid you are but it says right in the post of mine that you quoted that an ideology is a set of beliefs. Are you getting tired or something? You misused ideology in saying that my post was one. In fact, my post is a stance on one issue. Come on Professor, teach me more. | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: Okay I will try to type slower for you. If you didn't buy into the ideology of the USA, you would not be buying a computer, using the Internet, going to work, watching CNBC, ect, etc, etc. Due to the overwhelming power of the ruling classes, about 80% of the population are sheep, 19.9% are educated sheep and .01% see the light and are either crazy or rich enough to live outside the boundries ouf the dominant ideology. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 995 |
quote: I have always thought of tax dollars as my money. My father has always thought of tax dollars as his money. My friends and their families (some of whom are NOT a part of the "ruling class") have always thought of tax dollars as their money. Taxing the population to pay for necessary government expenses such as upkeep of the military is understandable and completely un-opposed by me. Doing what the government is doing is bullshit. 2Thick's friend: "Hey 2Thick, can I have $1,000?" 2Thick: "Uhh... why?" 2Thick's friend: "Don't worry about it. I'll tell you later." 2Thick: "Uhh... sorry, no." Now pretend that you can't say no. The only difference between the above conversation and real life is that the government is not your friend. -Warik ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
Warik, Nobody ever used the phrase "The tax cut is money I overspent, I want my money back" until it was said on TV. You know that is what I meant. | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 454 |
quote: Then you don't remember the 80's. [This message has been edited by john937 (edited March 08, 2001).] | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 995 |
quote: This is true. Do you deny the fact that most people felt that way, however? Do you deny the fact that most Americans feel that they are over-taxed, be they the poorest of the poor (wait.. they don't pay taxes. no wonder they aren't upset) to the richest of the rich? Who would hear their voices? No one. No one would care. People care now. I honestly can't think of a reason why ANYONE would argue against a tax cut unless he (you) were playing the fun "I'm arguing against what I'm really for" game. You don't play this one too well. Maybe you should stick to guns instead. I had more fun in that thread. -Warik ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
2Thick- So by owning a computer and owning a TV I am a sheep? Wouldn't that make you a sheep also? After all, what are you typing on right now? I watch TV because I like it, I own a computer for the free porn. PS I like how you think Americans go to work as part of some ideology and not because of survival. Are you on medication today or are you just one of those people that gets off on annoying people? [This message has been edited by Mr. T (edited March 08, 2001).] | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: Yes, I am one also. I never said that I wasn't. The difference is that I know I am one. It would be impractical to totally go against the grain. I am not a Bill Gates so I cannot do what I want without serious repercussions. I lived in the states for 12 years. If you are familiar with consumerism, you will know it has noting to do with survival and everything to do with owing "stuff". Only 10% of the population are part of the underclass that cannot afford food and shelter. That means 90% buy stuff with their extra money. [This message has been edited by 2Thick (edited March 08, 2001).] | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 995 |
john, Do you have any idea how fast the national debt is growing every day? Are you aware of the fact that Bill Gates could dump his entire fortune into the "pay off the national debt fund" and it wouldn't even make a dent? It's not going to be paid off in your lifetime. Speaking of paying for my elder's Social Security payments, that's another good reason why the debt is so high. If the government weren't wasting tax money by putting into the illegal Social Security program, it could be putting that money into paying off the national debt. I am more in favor of paying off the national debt than I am paying for the retirement of millions of irresponsible individuals who didn't take care of their own finances throughout the first 65 (or is it 67 now? I see the government is trying to increase the age hoping that you all die before you get a chance to claim your "benefits") years of life. I think one matter that hasn't been addressed in the entire discussion of the national debt is: "Who really cares?" You don't see anybody asking us for the money back. You don't see anyone threatening us saying: "give me my money or I'll beat you up during recess." What's the big deal? (BTW: That is a question, not a "we shouldn't pay off the national debt because it's not a big deal." WHY is it a big deal? If someone owed me over a trillion dollars, I don't think I'd wait a couple of generations before asking for it back.) -Warik ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
2 Thick- Than how do you not know that being anti-tax is very American, not something that CNN invented? Most Americans live paycheck to paycheck. We don't choose to work in the US to by a TV. We do it to keep a fuckin roof over our heads. Warick- Well said, that's what I always say. No one is ever going to make us pay them back anyway. [This message has been edited by Mr. T (edited March 08, 2001).] | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: You yourself said that the founding fathers (and the creators of the US ideology) started a revolution because of unfair taxation. Being antitax is part of American heritage. I was talking about the phrasing of the words. Taxes were thought to be the price of freedom. It is not money that you can get back. Okay, any more questions. [This message has been edited by 2Thick (edited March 08, 2001).] | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: Wrong, big guy. Most Americans are working class and middle class. They are only living a harder life because of consumerism. If they stopped buying stuff they don't need then they would be fine. Food is dirt cheap in the US and so is property. You must really try see (and learn) about the rest of the world. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
Yes, you said that I got that idea from CNN. (the people keeping their $) Now you say that it is a basic American belief. Pick an argument and try to stay with it. You wandering... | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: Have you ever heard anyone say "I want the money that I overpaid the government back"? No you haven't because it was started by the pro-tax-cut people to sell their plan and everyone just parrots it like they thought of it. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
Yes, people in the US live beyond their means because they can, big guy. But going to work is not part of their ideology. They have to!!!!!!!!!!!!! | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: Do you read your posts before pushing "submit"? | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
Why would I, you quote them all anyway. They must be important to you. Didn't you just say that insults show frustration, oh wise one? | ||
Moderator Posts: 7145 |
quote: It was a question, not an insult. I only asked because you seem to avoid answering my questions. You seem to give very theological answers to any question I pose. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 995 |
Wow, 2Thick! Thanks! You've just made a good point in favor of my views.
quote: THAT'S RIGHT! Food and property are dirt cheap in the United States! There is no valid excuse for poverty! IT IS YOUR FAULT THAT YOU ARE POOR (not you, talking to the poor), NOT MINE! LEAVE MY FUCKING MONEY ALONE!! I EARNED IT!!! WHY DON'T YOU TRY TO DO THE SAME?!?!?!?! That is all. Thanks a lot. Glad to see you have changed sides. Your pal, ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1193 |
HAHAHA, your to funny 2Thick. I give "theological" responses to your questions. Where do I mention God or religeon? Your answer was a question, a sarcastic one. (therfore an insult) It's been nice chatting with you, but I'm getting hungry now. Maybe you can teach me more things tomorrow O Wise One. It's been a liberating experience talking with you. (Example of sarcasm) Hugs and Kissies- Mr. T | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 454 |
quote: Those irresponsible people you're talking about won World War II and paid Social Security payments into a system for their whole lives, and now want their benefits. They earned it, they were in no way irresponsible. The national debt is finanaced thru US Treasury debt. The Fed creates money in the form of Treasury Bonds which are purchased in the form of US Bonds and by banks and Savings and loans. That's what you hear refered to by the prime rate. We definitly are paying the interest on the national debt whether anyone calls up Warik to tell him about it. The debt "churns". Todays debt gets financed and paid off with today's reciepts which creates more debt which gets financed and gets paid off with tomorrows reciepts. Todays US Bonds get paid, but new bonds are issued. Noone is waiting generations to get their money. The interest on the debt is a constant daily drag on our economy. If you want to see real wealth in this country, just pay off the debt and we could afford a 20% tax break. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 273 |
quote: Bro, I think he meant you trying to answer somthing by saying that it exists and things are the way they are for a reason. That is how people explain religion. There ain't no proof. Just the way things are. I think that was what he meant by "theological". Dude you can't see the forrest for the trees. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 159 |
Guys why do you even get all sweated over internet arguements? face it, no matter how much you MAY actually be right, you will not make the person ont he other side of the screen here see that you are right, they are set in their beliefs and that's that. It's not worth it, who cares, you're just all posting now in hopes of one -upping some anonymous net dude, which is going to continue back and forth and back and forth for the rest of eternity, and at the end of eternity, you still wouldn't get a prize and no one would change opinions to see it your way. Just please, think about this, realize it's pointless to argue this hard over something. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 995 |
quote: Precisely. THEY paid for the system all THEIR lives and should receive THEIR benefits. Why do I have to do with their benefits? Those who put money into the system should get it back. Those who want nothing to do with the system should not have to pay for it. Do you disagree? -Warik ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! |
All times are ET (US) | |
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.45c