![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
Author | Topic: The Difference Between Republicans and Democrats | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 105 |
A Republican and a Democrat were walking down the street when they came to a homeless person. The Republican gave the homeless person his business card and told him to come to his business for a job. He then took twenty dollars out of his pocket and gave it to the homeless person. The Democrat was very impressed, and when they came to another homeless person, he decided to help. He walked over to the homeless person and gave him directions to the welfare office. He then reached into the Republican's pocket and gave the homeless person fifty dollars. It took me years to figure out the real difference between Democrats and Republicans and this little story tells it all. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 840 |
only 50 billion dollars a year goes to all forms of social welfare. 170 goes to corporate welfare. the republican (who owns a business) takes 3 1/2 times in governmental financial assistance than the homeless person. social welfare is just a trick to piss people off. the saving & loan scandal cost 1.4 trillion dollars. thats enough money for 28 years of social welfare. no one gets pissed off about that. they all went to level 1 prisons for a few years. like i said, its just a trick to piss people off. businessmen take 3 1/2 times in social welfare & stole 1.4 trillion. [This message has been edited by Joseph_stalin (edited February 23, 2001).] ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
Stalin, The Republican business owners are an important part of society, depending on their type of business, of course. They pay more tax money as well; therefore, they should get more government benefits. Homeless people are useless to society and pay no taxes. That's 50 billion dollars too many. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 840 |
come on. someone reply to this. i want to get an argument going. why is it that if a poor guy takes $3000 a year from the government he is a monster, but if a businessman takes $10000 he is tolerated. the snl scandal cost more than 28 times the annual social welfare budget. if that was invested in a moderate investment, the interest could pay for all social welfare programs combined. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 958 |
well a business man might take that money and use it to give the poor man a job or to make safety improvements for his workers. Something to increase the quality of his business for it's customers and workers. The poor man who gets a little money might go into that same business owner and spend that money, which he might have gone in and spent money had uncle sam not given it to him I think it has to do with how positive will the money being given out effect the economy, not just a moral ground for taking care of the poor. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
If a poor guy takes $3000 a year from the government he is a monster because, comparatively speaking, his contribution to the social program is no where near enough to warrant such a return. A guy making 20k a year pays around $3000 to the government - how much of that do you think goes to the social program that is giving him free money? A successful business man pays out the ass in taxes every year. He deserves as much money as he wants because it's his own money that he is putting in. Thank God that this $10,000 of which you were speaking was not split up and given to some more freeloaders. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Pro Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 364 |
those figures (and i'm skeptical of their validity...can you quote me a source, stalin?) of the cost of the s&l scandal versus the spending on social welfare are eye-opening. i don't think a comparison JUSTIFIES social welfare just because we may spend more elsewhere...all it tells me is that there are many places where spending can be further cut. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
I am against all of the government programs of which we have been speaking. Most (actually, I think all) are unconstitutional and illegal. If you opened up a business today doing exactly what Social Security , Medicare or Welfare were doing, you would be immediately jailed, sued, beaten, and God knows what else because that is illegal in all of our 50 states. Why should the government be above the law? -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 2747 |
Stalin, Social Security accounts for over $406 billion dolars per year. Medicare and Medicaid combine for roughly $316billion per year. Right there is $720BILLION in Social Welfare. That alone is slightly less than half the annual budget. Defense is $290 billion. Interest on the debt is $224 bilion. That's another $514 billion. Pensions for retired federal workers and veterans is $79billion. The total for these programs is $1.31 TRILLION. That's almost 90% of the annual budget. So what are you talking about? ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 840 |
downsize this by michael moore had the quotes on social welfare VS corporate welfare. the snl scandal quote was technically, poor people do contribute to society. the money they get they put back in the economy by buying food & clothes. my main gripe is that in america we create fake problems to distract ourselves. like baby boomers & social security. while bush & gore were arguing about how to protect the baby boomers, supposedly there was never a crisis to begin with. there was always enough money for social security for them (ralph nader made a remark about this subject on charlie rose once). or the drug war. we create a problem to busy our minds. people worry about 2 billion a year going to homeless people because it interests them for some reason. so tax cuts & "welfare to work" programs are enacted. all this does is distract people from how things (like the economy) really work & make a certain group of outcasts subject to humiliation & intimidation. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 840 |
where are you getting your information. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 198 |
Hey Stalin, I can tell the topic of social stratification and class issues interest you. That is very good in my opinion because I think it makes you more aware than most. If you want to read another good book on this topic, I highly suggest you read Robert Perrucci's: THE NEW CLASS SOCIETY. It's a very interesting read and it would provide you with more than enough statistics and trend analysis to back up all of your arguments. Peace. ------------------ - Kwai-Chang Caine ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Freak ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 2104 |
Stalin, if your heart bleeds you can always select the box on your W4 for "additional with-holding" so you can help out the poor, poor people in this country that cannot get out of bed in the morning to go to work like the rest of us. Maybe they could get up if they were not up all night smoking crack and drinking 40's. ------------------ ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Pro Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 382 |
Warik, your hard philosophy bespeaks your young age (not a flame). Live long enough and everyone will eventually get the wind kicked out of them and need a hand up. The problem I have with the original question is, I've never seen the Republican offer the $20 nor the job. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
john, I don't take it as a flame. I also feel that my age is irrelevant in this argument, but if you wish to bring it in, then so be it. I have to disagree. Not everyone will have the wind kicked out of them. That, however, depends on your definition of "having the wind kicked out of them." If your definition of "having the wind kicked out of them" is "this person lost his job... oh no boohoo." May1010 lost his job, and I don't think he started whining to the government. There is always, ALWAYS, a way out besides crying to the government. Do you mean to tell me that cab drivers up in the big cities who barely speak English can get jobs, immature just-turned-teen brats can get jobs at supermarkets, and adults with no education can get jobs at fast food joints, but the poor can't get a job anywhere? Pardon my language, but BULLSHIT. In a nation such as this one where the government caters to the "less fortunate" (aka lazy), there is NO EXCUSE for STILL being poor despite government help. If anything, government aid should be limited to enough money to get a temporary address to keep you sheltered while you start your new job. But no, you have people living off of that shit. Who is more worthy of my money? Myself, who has been working hard and trying to make something of myself, or some lazy bastard who does nothing but waste perfectly good oxygen and take himself into a drunken stupor nightly? I won't answer that question. I'm sure you are intelligent enough to do so. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Pro Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 382 |
We have a wino here in town (well, lots more than one). I used to pass him and think "He should take a bath and get a job". The local paper did a story on him that changed my attitudes. I don't know, let's call him "bob". Seems Bob was perfectly healthy and educated and found his true love, lets call her Betty. Bob and Betty got married, and Bob got drafted into World War 2. Went to Europe and got his leg shot off. Came back to America, got a wooden leg, and tried to make the best of it. He's not complaining, a lot worse happened to others. Had 2 kids. One later died experimenting with drugs. The other turned out fine. One day the remaining son was driving Betty to the mall and both were killed in an car accident. Bob went into deep depression, escaping into alcohol (And I can't say I wouldn't do the same). When he came out of year long drunk his house was reposessed and he was homeless, and no family. Now he todders on his game leg, dirty and grizzled on a highway corner with a "homeless vet" sign. There's no way you can see these things coming and plan for them. Shit happens. It's only the grace of God or good luck that that's not my story. Or yours. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 198 |
To believe SOCIAL problems are wholly based on the short-comings of individuals is rediculous. So many of you have the poor in your crosshairs as your main target, but you never question the influence and the overwhelming power that the super-elite have on you in this country. You are conditioned by an elitist controlled media to believe that hard work and perserverance will help you achieve the "American Dream"; all while rich elitists keep getting richer and you keep losing more and more of your income and wealth percentage to them. The fact of the matter is simply this. You believe the poor are the problem in this country because the media wants you to. The rich won't allow any other message to exist, because they obviously don't want the current American class structure to be examined. They like where they are and they will do anything and everything in their enormous power to stay there. They have even the most talented of us believing in this "American Dream" because they know if they get the best of "us" on their side, then they can legitimize their position and privilege to the masses. No matter what you think you have accomplished in your life, no matter how much money you make, no matter what position you hold, all you will ever be is their help. Unless you are born into great wealth you have about just as much a chance as becoming a member of the elite as you do in winning the lottery. Sorry for the poor writing, It's been a long week. ------------------ - Kwai-Chang Caine ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Freak ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 2104 |
There are thousands of people out there that heve been delt a low blow, but not all of them resort to drugs and alcohol. Even if they do, how is this the worlds problem, and why should I have to take money from my check, against my will and have it handed to them? That is stealing. We need people to take responsibility for their OWN actions. ------------------ ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Pro Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 382 |
You call it stealing, I call it compasionate. I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
john, Compassion comes voluntarily - theft does not. If someone chooses to help someone "less fortunate" than he, then good for him and the man deserves respect. If someone chooses to spend his money on himself because HE EARNED IT HIMSELF, then good for him and the man STILL deserves respect because he went out and earned his own money instead of having someone else's forcibly removed and given to him. By the way, what's your response in regard to the unconstitutionality of these government social programs? -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Freak ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 2104 |
good points Warik. Pretty sad that you work from January through April for free because all that money goes to the government in taxes. Isn't that why we left England? Isn't that why the south tried to secede? ------------------ ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 234 |
Warik i hope you don�t need help from other peeps in the future... ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 958 |
well the poor can keep getting poor or step their foot down and do something about it. It's absolutely BULLSHIT!!!For anyone to say they can't overcome being poor in this country. It's a Simple question that each person needs to answer. Am I going to do WHATEVER it takes to get on top, or am I going to just try and get by? If someone answers Yes they will do whatever it takes to get on top, then all they need to do is find a way. Legal, Illegal, doesn't really matter cause there is always a way. Morals and the law don't come into the picture if your desperate and have had enough of being on the bottom It can be done. People can overcome adversity if they truly want to... Ok this in no way refers to those that are mentaly unfit and are homeless...I am refering to the ones that have the ability to work and do not [This message has been edited by TxCollegeguy (edited February 23, 2001).] ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
quote: I won't. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 4601 |
I was poor, I was homeless. I did what I had to do to survive, I didn't go on welfare or foodstamps. I educated myself. I now make more than most. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 105 |
Damn, didn't think this little thread would create such kaos. Warik, I have to agree, and same with TxGuy. Anyone in this country can make it, if they try. And it is the rich and the republicans that help create the jobs, not giving free rides. You want it, work for it. This is true for us on this board. We all strive to reach a certain goal, and we will do what is necessary to reach that goal. Sure say I'm being hipocritical regarding the use of a crutch, IE AS, but hey, I'm doing what it takes to reach my goals, and I'm not expecting a hand out. A hand out equivilant may be implants, but that is in situations that know efforts, experience, and environment have not resulted in deisred effects. The use of imnplants also can be used where there are short comings, same as business loans. You do need the support at times when all other measures have failed, but don't get complaicent and expect a hand out at every turn. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 198 |
I can't believe you guys are falling for that "American Dream" bait that the media is feeding you. How can you channel all of your anger at the poor, when in reality it's the RICH (Yes, the rich) who have more to do with why you don't have more for yourselves. They are the ones who continually chip away at your wages, your benefits, and your job security each year. You worry about the poor and how much of a strain welfare is on you, yet you neglect to mention anything about how RICH corporations downsize you, take away your pensions, your health care, and replace you with cheap, benefit free, contingency workers. You also bitch and moan about taxes, but statistically it's the rich who are continually accumulating a higher percentage of the overall income and wealth each year. There is no longer a middle class folks. There is the elite 20% and the other 80%. Most of you on this board belong to that other 80% percent, but you still fall for the rich mans creedo and that is "blame the poor." Congrats, you are working for them and you aren't even getting paid for it. How does it feel to be a pawn? ------------------ - Kwai-Chang Caine ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
Is anyone listening to Joseph_stalin or Kwai-Chang Caine? It is ignorant to believe that institutional discrimination does not exist in America. A simple question. Why do women make less than men do for the same job? Is it because men are superior? I think not! It is called institutional discrimination. The same goes for the impoverished. Taxes are not monies being stolen from you! They are contributions to a society. It is called being civilized. I don't hear you complain about taxes on gas. For every dollar you spend on gas, 60%-70% is tax!! That screws you more than welfare. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
2Thick, The amount of taxation on gas is ridiculous as well. Taxes on cellular phones are awful, too. I had to pay over $10 worth of tax for my cellphone bill this month. My bill went up 25% just because of "taxes!" Just because we don't complain about it doesn't mean that it doesn't bother us. And yes, taxes are being stolen. They are NOT contributions because they are not being given voluntarily. I don't see how anyone could see it any other way. I work for say, 40 hours a week, but I only end up getting paid for 34, and that's if I'm lucky. How can you possibly think that something like that is civilized or even LEGAL? -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
Okay then if there were no public schools, no police officers, no infrastructure (i.e. roads, bridges, railways, side walks) no sewage system, no fire department, no paramedics, and so on...then you would be happier with keeping all of your tax money? Is that stealing or taking your money IN YOUR BEST INTEREST!!! If you think more than 3% of your tax dollars are being used for welfare then you have been tricked my brother...fooled very badly!! ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Pro Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 543 |
In defense of Warik <not that ya need it>. Those things you listed contribute greatly to society. ------------------ ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
2Thick, I am not against taxation itself - I am against needless taxation. I am in favor of a flat tax as Matt stated in his campaigning thread for 2004. (heh) The government does not NEED to steal 39.6% of the wealthiest's income and trickle its way down to 15% of the poor's income to provide the country with public schools, police officers, etc. I would gladly give 10%-15% of my annual income until the day I stop working so that my country could benefit from such things... such things that *I* would benefit from as well. You think I'm going to benefit from Social Security? Lol... I'll give it to my wife for spending money or use it to wipe my ass if I run out of toilet paper. Why? Because I'm going to PLAN for my future just like any other American should. The government is supposed to take care of the concerns of the country, not of the individuals of said country. (By the way, my children will not be going to public schools, so, in the case of public schools, I think I would be happier keeping my tax money.) -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
quote: The government -by definition- has three major functions. 1). Protect society from exterior harm 2). To protect society from interior threats (including property and personal rights) 3). To protect the weak from the powerful. These are all in reference to individual protection. If you had not had the government to protect you from the interests of the powerful, you may not have such a bright future. To deny the government any of those rights is to deny you your freedom. What you do not want for yourself shouldn�t be inflicted upon others because you feel that you are better than they are. That is not democracy, that is an aristocracy (and what America is totally opposed to). ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
How can you compare protecting someone who is too lazy to work to protecting a country from foreign military invasion? True, they are both protection of individuals, but the latter is protection of a collective of individuals who all need the same protection. I don't need to be spoonfed other people's money because I will be responsible enough to maintain myself. There is no reason for our government to punish success. No one is stopping you from giving your money to the homeless or to whomever else you wish to give your money. I'm not asking people to stop helping other people, I'm asking people to stop reaching into my pockets. If more concern were put into fixing the system than fixing the individuals, a lot more progress would be made. And I'm curious as to why no anti-Warik's-point-of-view'ers have yet to comment on the illegality of such social programs as Social Security. It doesn't have to be lengthy. You can just say: "you're right," and I'll discontinue discussion of that particular point. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
Once again, only 3% of your tax dollars go to social welfare. More than 3x that goes to corporations. What is the big deal about 3% of tax dollars? ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
2Thick, The big deal is that those 3% of my tax dollars are MY dollars and if I do not want them to go towards encouraging people to be lazy, then nobody should have the right to take them from me. In regards to that "more than 3x that goes to corporations" - I said I was against needless taxation. It's my money - not the corporations'. They get enough of my money when I buy their products. True, corporate welfare goes to better use than social welfare, but it's still a needless tax in my view. And with that, I'm off to bed. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 231 |
Why does everyone always imply its the "rich republicans" that have all the money, big business, etc. Do you really think there are no rich democrats?? BTW, i'm neither democrat or republican, just curious why the assumption is made so often. ------------------ ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
mrbill, That assumption is typically made because rich folks typically vote Republican and poor folks typically vote Democrat. There are, of course, many exceptions. I'm sure there are many rich Democrats, but I can't see why they'd vote Democrat if they are rich. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
The United States is the most powerful nation in the world because of its capitalistic ideals. Communism and socalism do not work. What would motivate someone to create a revolutionary idea or product if he or she knew that it would not significantly increase their personal standard of living vs. say, a waitress? A friend of mine once said (a smart guy too but he must have had a brain fart),"Wouldn't it be nice if everyone could have a Ferrari? Even someone like a waitress should be able to get something like that." My jaw was on the floor with after he said that. It was the most rediculous thing that he had ever said. If I was a young student, why would I want to become a doctor, a researcher, an engineer, etc? Why would I want to bust my ass if I knew that someone with barely a high school education could have all the things that I work a thousand fold harder for? I wouldn't. If there was a system like that, I would be a personal trainer...and probably a shitty one at that. At the end of the day, I would jump into my Ferrari and drive away...because hey, "I EARNED IT". I would never go to school and there would be no reason to expand my mind. I would just live out my days waiting for the free money to roll in. HMO's and managed care are destroying the medical community. Good job democrats, nice thinking once again. Doctors these days struggle to make a decent living. Many turn to selling supplements like Metabolife to supplement their income. It's not that they want to push supplements, but they have no choice. Capitalism drives creativity, creates competition to produce a superior product, and gives the majority a higher standard of living. Communism and socialism create cynicism and contempt, laziness, and apathy in society. So all of you spouting off this commie bullshit in this thread, wake up and accept capitalism or move to North Korea where you belong. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
quote: You are wrong. You have been brainwashed perfectly by the ruling classes. First of all Communism is an economic system and socialism and a type of government. You cannot use them interchangeably. For example, France/Japan/ Sweden/Denmark/Switzerland/etc are socialist countries with capitalist economies. Second, real communism has never come to pass. Real communism is advanced communism that is installed after capitalism. That means that it happens in advanced countries with advanced telecommunications and not backward countries like Russia of 1917 and China of the 1950s. Finally if you do not buy into the propaganda of consumerism and do not use greed as the driving force of your culture then being equal is very logical. Of course when you come from a stratified culture, it seems odd for a "waitress" to make the same as a "doctor". But when there were no preconceived biases forced into your mind by the powers that be then you would have a more open mind. It all comes down to vested interest. It is in the vested interest of the powerful to keeps things the way they are and to make communism look like a failure. If you just did some thinking for yourself, you would see the truth. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
Nice try. But the fact remains that if there is not a motivation factor to push people, then there will be no forward progress. In an ideal fantasy world, maybe communism would work. But human nature is to be lazy. You can try to rationalize against it all you want, but in this case it is YOU who is wrong. There is no brainwashing by the elite class going on here. The elite know exactly why their system works. Have you ever run a business whose workers were 95% incompetent? Well I have. They were the only ones I could afford to hire at the time. While they meant well, if I was not there to hold their hand every step of the way, the business would have collapsed in less than a month. The job requires intelligence, dedication, pressure, and hard work. Why would a talented person subject themselves to something like that if they could find a job elsewhere that pays the same without the pressure? They want money for their services and should be paid for them. So those people just served as basic grunts to do rudimentry customer service and data entry. I could not trust them to do much else. So I suppose these people should be entitled to the same material wealth as an intelligent productive person. LOL. Maybe in fantasy land, but the harsh reality is that people are too quick to reproduce and leave more offspring than there are resources or funding to support them. So there is a sense of Darwinism....either be productive, or be selected against. I'm sorry if this does not agree with your humanitarian side, but it is the fact of the matter. I wish things could realistically be different also, but it's just not possible. Back to the HMO thing. People pondering medical school are beginning to question the value of 4 years plus residency for potentially little reward, reduced patient care, and long hours. Can you blame them? Why should they stress themselves if they know that they could finish high school, get one computer certification, and run a network making the same amount of money? Well, that is what is happening these days where the most talented in our society choose the smarter path, leaving the quality of other fields such as medicine to suffer as they must lower their entrance standards. I'm sorry if the truth hurts. But next time before you take a condescending tone with me, learn who you are talking to. I've paid my dues to the business world. I know what works and what does not. Eventually when you play Robin Hood long enough and if too much is taken away from the wrong people, that is when laziness, apathy, and cynicism sets in resulting in pain and lack of progress for all. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
You argument fails because of the "fruit of a poisonous tree" parable. You are using the ideals of capitalism to explain why it works well. That is not logical thought. That is cyclical and used in propaganda. If there were no emphasis on wealth and no emphasis on accumulation (as capitalism espouses) then there would not be a lack of motivation. The lack of motivation would only come from people who believe in the capitalist ideals, not people who do not accept them. The only reason why individualism and self-achievement is so ideal in capitalism is because it conveniently explains why 85% of all wealth in the US is owned by 0.01% of the population. That sounds more like what you are against than your precious idealistic capitalism. If you believe that everyone has an equal chance to make it in this world then you are sadly mistaken. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
For your argument to hold any water, you need to explain why the U.S. and similiar countries like Germany pioneer the way in computers, medicine, research, and engineering. Why do these capitalist nations make progress at a rate of 1000 fold greater than the old U.S.S.R, North Korea, and China? Because there is motivation for a reward. Why is it that the average Chinese citizen makes $1 per day in "credits", has very little, if any access to immediate medical care, and works 15 hours per day? If communism and equality are so great, then why is Hong Kong so prosperous while the rest of China struggles to survive? Even the poor people in Hong Kong have life a lot better than those in the country-side IMO. I realize that material wealth is a felt need that is created by society. But once ingrained, it is almost impossible to remove. And even if you were to take away all the money from the wealthy and give it to the poor, within 5 years the rich would be rich once again, with the poor right back to where they started. To accumulate and maintain wealth takes discipline and intelligence. Go out with a bunch of blue-collar workers on payday and you will see why this is so. When I first started, I had nothing. But now I am very comfortable. But then again, I am still single and at least will be childless for another 10 years. That is the key here. I deprived myself of alot so that I had the resources to start various projects. I just had the self control not to drink, smoke, eat Ramen noodles, and stay single and childless. You take the average citizen from just about anywhere and chances are that they will not have the same discipline. They fail because they make too many misc. expenses for themselves thus creating debt that limits their horizons. Take Ross Perot. He was penniless when he first started out. Tommy Hilfiger sold jeans out of the trunk of his car, going bankrupt at least once before he got his system working. Even Warren Buffet started out working odd jobs scraping to get by while he bought his first stocks. Most musicians and artists start out as teenagers hanging out doing something they love. This is just a small sample of poor people who have bettered themselves. You have to have the stomach for business and the willingness to sacrifice comfort until conditions change for the better. In keeping with the theme of laziness and instant gratification that is the basis of human nature, that alone disqualifies over 95% of the population for a chance at true self-reliance and success. Everyone has a chance at even minor success in a capitalistic system. They are only limited by their own human nature....not outside factors. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 1270 |
2thick, youre gonna have to accept that fact that life is not fair. You cant punish those who have an obvious talent for working hard in order to 'even the playing field' for those who are prefectly content doin little or nothing at all.... I am well aware of the fact that some are born with very few options but I also know that there are those who give up, and those who decided they want something and go out and get it. I dont think anyone born in the US has the right to bitch about not being able to find work and slack off. I have a friend who was born in Azerbaijan to a woman with no limbs (thats right, samsonite; Ranger's old gf ![]() [This message has been edited by coolhandluke (edited February 24, 2001).] ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
quote: I disagree. You are assuming that because one person can make it, that anyone who tries can make it. You are committing an individualistic fallacy and assuming that one person could be representative of millions even though the occurrence of a Perot or Hilfiger is One Million to One. So with your line of reasoning, any black man has the potential to become Secretary of State because Powell has made it...I think not! For every Perot that makes it, there are hundreds of thousands of men just like him that fail. The same goes for the other men you have mentioned. Social factors such as class, status, income, race, and religion do have a strong impact on your future. There will always be exceptions but MOST people are going to follow the overwhelming trend. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
quote: I always though you were a little crazy but this post is what has convinced me...LOL J/K, you make a lot of sense. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
This is pointless. You are making predictions that are far-fetched to say the least. Just because a country jumps out fast at the starting gate, doesn't mean that it can be sustained. And read "minor success". Success is success. I'll take minor success any day over working a farmers field. You have convinced me of nothing, and it is late here. So I guess we will just have to agree to disagree. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
P.S. The rich countries are rich because their systems work. The masses can moan and groan all they want in those areas of the world in which you speak. But it won't change the fact that the formula works. It's pretty easy to have that rate of growth when you have nothing established in which to measure its relative rate of growth. And I believe in nature rather than nuture. So don't even try to argue about that, because I concede that neither can prove our case there. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 198 |
Capital is far more responsible for who becomes successful in this country than hard work. Most of the wealthy born in this country are no more talented or gifted than you or I, but when they have the financial backing of daddy's or grandpa's old money they are able to go to Ivy league schools, network with other aristocrats, and put themselves in just about any position they desire. For instance, my background is from that of a rural working class family. My roommate on the other hand is from one of the wealthiest families in all of Jacksonville. I surpass him in virtually every possible skill and knowledge area you can think of; especially in terms of writing, communication skills, and computer literacy. Can you guess who already has a job after college? Not me. ------------------ - Kwai-Chang Caine ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Pro Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 436 |
This country is not a republic or democratic, it is socialism at it worst. Socialism is a view that society has the rights and individual rights don't really count. Look at the Clinton administration, social programs this and that. It takes a village to raise a child, on and on. I personally view this country on a ledge, sooner or later it is bound to fall off it principles of the Constitution, and what is worse is that congress and the courts and cops are just trying to do away with the bill of rights. I can only hope a military coup with some real level headed people spearheading it may work to straighten it out, but unfortunalely it will not happen that way. We could just end up with more control freaks than we have now in office. The 2 party system sucks. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
"Woe is me" I think that should be tatooed on every left wing residents forehead. Let me tell you all a little story of a friend of mine. His name is Jeremy. Jeremy grew up with 5 brothers and sisters in a tough neighborhood on the South Side of Chicago. His parents were African American who made enough just to get by. Basically Jeremy grew up with nothing. But Jeremy was a smart guy. While his siblings and their friends did poorly in school, Jeremy diligently attended class and always concentrated on his homework. He always said how he wanted to get out of his neighborhood and live in one of the lofts downtown that he drove by when riding on the bus. His dream was to go to college. He was not quite an athlete, but he thought that he might be able to get a scholarship in academics. Sure enough, he was able to get some help, but he didn't quite get enough to pay for all of the expenses he would need. So as you can see, the American dream is very much alive. I'm sorry for those who try to place blame on society for their lack of accomplisments. But if this kid can do it, anyone can. Jeremy was not the smartest guy...not even close. But he always kept himself busy and tried to better himself at every chance he got. Maybe the rest of the naysayers to capitalism might learn something from my old friend. I don't even want to hear bullshit like "Oh but he is a special case". That is the worlds biggest cop-out. This guy came from nothing, and just applied himself to something, like the Navy, that is available to anyone. There is still plenty of opportunity out there. You just have to know where to look. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
quote: It IS a special case. When most (98%) of all people in the lowest classes stay there then there is no American dream for them. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
What does "2Thick" mean anyways? Your skull? This kid comes from the bottom of the barrell. What is the point of even arguing with you? I've proven my point, and yet you continue with your paper-thin excuses. Why can't you just admit that the only thing limiting in the United States is ones motivation? Sure maybe it takes alot longer in some cases, like with my friend (4 years of living at the poverty line from 18-22) while he was building experience in the Navy. But he made it. You can't deny that there are programs out there like the military that give opportunities to disadvantaged youth. It is up to them to go get it. If they don't want to go through the trouble of boot camp, work to get that scholarship in highschool, or what have you, it's not my problem. I'm not responsible for your laziness. So quit wasting my time with your nonsense. This is the last time I'm going to say this: those 2% who make it are willing to do whatever it takes. The other 98% are just content to survive with their hand out and whine, bitch, and cry when they don't get their way. Some children never grow up. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 198 |
Myo-genetic, You are seriously out of touch with society my friend. Your "nature" argument is flawed in so many ways that it's ridiculous. To say that those who don't make it to the top are lazy is basically the same thing as saying BLACKS, HISPANICS, AMERICAN INDIANS, WOMEN, AND ALL OTHER MINORITIES ARE LAZY. These are the people who statistically don't make it to the top. It has nothing to do with them as individuals and everything to do with institutional discrimination. ------------------ - Kwai-Chang Caine ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
Kwai-Chang, So what you're saying is that we have a system which benefits the evil white man and holds back the blacks, the hispanics, the indians, the asian, the women, the insert-anything-other-than-white-here's? Then, can you please explain why this evil system spoonfeeds the evil white man's money against his will to the blacks, the hispanics, the indians, the asians, the women, and the insert-anything-other-than-white-here's? I know the answer, but I'll be flamed if I provide it. Maybe you could phrase it better than I would. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
So that is the best you can do? That's your strategy? Put words into my mouth? What a fucking joke you are! Maybe if you even bothered to read my posts you would see that nowhere in there do I say the white man is superior or a minority is inferior. I even told the story of how my poor black friend made something out of himself. It comes to no suprise to me that you can't get a job after college because likely you don't even bother to read the correct way to fill out the basic application. Go be a good little sheep and FUCKING READ WHAT I SAID!!! I'm not at all suprised by the way you talk out of your ass however. You have a history on this board of putting words into peoples mouths and mis-interpretation...that is, since it is obvious that you only skim the posts. You have managed to completely discredit yourself infront of everyone by that last post. And of course you are probably one of those who disregard the simple fact that it is WHITE PEOPLE IN THE UNITED STATES WHO COMPOSE THE LARGEST PORTION OF THOSE ON WELFARE OR OTHER FORMS OF GOV ASSISTANCE. [This message has been edited by Myo-genetic (edited February 25, 2001).] ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 198 |
Warik, Our system is owned and operated by rich white men who have and will continue to pass their wealth down from generation to generation without giving a damn for you and I. Now does this mean that all whites are sitting pretty in the lap of luxury; hell no. And if there is one thing I truly believe in it's free speech. Speak your mind Warik. Don't hold back. Myo-genetic, How can you not expect someone to take what you said the way I did? You made it very clear that you believe in nature over nuture And as for your personal attack on me. Well, that was completely juvenile. I am a junior in college and my previous post was simply there as an example of the benefits the rich have regardless of their talent or intellect. I will most likely have a very good job lined up for myself after college and I'm just as sure that it will pay just as well if not better than the job my roommate is getting. All I'm saying is that I had to earn it myself, it wasn't given to me by my father. I really have no need to defend myself against a post as ignorant as the last one you directed towards me, but I'll respond by saying FUCK YOU anyway. That kind of shit only makes you look like a dick. ------------------ - Kwai-Chang Caine ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
and you call me ignorant.... Stop dodging the fact that there are hundreds of thousands of successful minorities out there who made themselves. You know why I have the views I have? They come from talking with many of these people. Maybe if you didn't hang out with cynical losers all the time you might see the light. [This message has been edited by Myo-genetic (edited February 25, 2001).] ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
quote: You and I? Speak for yourself. I'm going to be one of those evil "rich white men who pass their wealth down from generation to generation" because I WANT to and I will dedicate my energy to accomplishing that as opposed to dedicating my energy to complaining about how everyone else has it better than I do. Besides, why SHOULD the evil rich white men give a damn for you or I? I'm not complaining that Bill Gates's children are going to be set for life after he passes without me getting a penny. WTF have I ever done for Bill Gates? He owes me nothing.
quote: My only problem is the knowledge that, several years into the future, I will be giving over a third of my income to the government for no good reason. Who is to blame for that? The evil rich white men? The evil rich white men don't put the tax-happy Democrats into office. That job is left to the "good poor non-white men and women" (as you describe them). And, in reality, they aren't really "pulling" me down at all - nor will they ever. The 33% of my income that I will be surrendering is more than 100% of theirs, and my remaining 67% is enough to keep myself and my family happy for the rest of our lives. Again, I don't mind giving up the money, but I *DO* mind giving it to those who are not deserving of it.
quote: I will agree 100% with you on this point. Moving up is NOT as easy as many of you think it is. You need motivation, ambition, intelligence, perseverance, and a willingness to work harder instead of complaining about how unfortunate you are. Wealth doesn't come by luck - it comes by work. Sure, many children today will be well provided for by their rich parents, but when you backtrack throughout the family line, eventually you will find a generation that was just as poor as the poor folks you are speaking in favor of. How do you think they got wealthy? Did their parents help them out? Nope, they were poor too. It's called WORK!
quote:
Thank you, that is all. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
Warik, I like you ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 86 |
Kwai-Chang Caine here is my only question. just answer this. dont go into some detailed explanation of this and that. i just want a straight answer. why should I (a 20 year old) work over 70 hours a week in 2 different jobs so that i can pay my way through college and the other bills that i have. and why do i have to give my hard earned money to someone who is doing nothing to better their own life i know why i do this NOW! so please just answer the question. im with Warik, i will be proud to be one of those evil white men (as you call it) so that my family and future generations can live happily. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
It's also quite funny how you DON'T EVEN HAVE TO BE A WHITE MAN to be evil and rich! I like the stereotype, though. It's supposed to insulting, but it's really quite the ego boost. -Warik ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Pro Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 370 |
The only differance between republicans and democrates is the size of their dick and everyone knows it. The only reason Bill's girls squeeled on him was cause he had a tiny pecker. You never here of a republican president getting busted by women. WE know what keeps them satisfied. ------------------ ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
The more I read Kwai-Chang Caines posts, the more I realize how quick he is to generalize everyone and his subtle (and some not so subtle) racists undertones. He was the first one to draw the race card, blaming the "evil white man" for all of his shortcomings. I don't know what his background is, nor do I care. All I know is that his posts exhibit a deep hatred for "the man" who he automatically correlates with the entire caucasian race. What a classical example of reverse racism. I knew a guy back in my high school who stated that it is impossible for a black person to be racist. I asked him if that this entitled him to say racist remarks about others. He said that nothing he could say is racist because he is the one oppressed. Funny how this guy never went to class, did his homework, or much else for that matter except complain about how he was oppressed. I asked one of my black friends about this attitude. He shook his head and looked at the floor. My friend then said that there are more like that other guy than he cared to think about. He also said that his race embarrassed him much of the time. He asked me what I thought about the Klan. And upon seeing the look of disgust on my face, he immediately broke in and said, "That's exactly how I feel when I have to listen to guys like that. I'm proud to be a black man, but embarrassed that someone might generalize me with him just because I'm black." But I refuse to be embarrassed that I work hard and am successful just because Mr. Kwai-Chang Caine states that it automatically makes me an "evil white man". I was cynical back in high school when I tried to get scholarships and was denied for 100% of them. I watched as my middle class minority friends all got free rides while I, living in a single parent household, got the door slammed in my face even though my grades were much better and my family had less. My mother told me that I shouldn't be suprised since I am white and male. She told me that nothing will ever be handed to me, and I had to out and work for it (and she is a hard-core Democrat). Did I get mad at this? No. A little frustrated, maybe. But it taught me discipline. I watched as 50% of my friends squandered away their scholarships due to poor academic performance. Right now I am not even using my college degree. I worked for a year in a related field and saved enough money to start my own company. During that year, I just worked. I went out maybe 4 times that year. I ate $2-3 worth of food per day, bought almost no new clothes, and had 2 beers all year. I watched my friends buy expensive cars and eat out every day. They were satisfied to be middle class. But I was not. I took my money after that year and started my company. If society is to blame, then blame the fact that we make it too easy to spend and very difficult to save. How is a blue-collar worker ever going to save a dime if he goes to tittie bars every payday? But then again, this is where the nature part comes in. Some people just cannot control their primal urges to chase girls and drink no matter what their upbringing. They are also too in love with TV, sports, and all the other distractions out there. Those who are successful like all of those things too. But they are intelligent enough to know their limits. They realize that instead of that new Mustang, maybe they should put that money in a mutual fund and drive a Neon. Instead of renting an apartment, they buy a house. Instead of going to the strip clubs, they go to the gym and stare at the thong-butt goddesses. I could go on and on. But the people who start with nothing learn the lesson of sacrifice early on and then use those principles to the fullest extent possible. And the best part of all this is that my business holds its money in overseas accounts. And since I spend less than 30 days per year in the U.S., all of these people who spend their lives with their hands out will never see a dime from me...unless I give to charity. Maybe a worthy cause...like the rainforests. At least the rainforests deserve to be preserved. So I have no personal vested interest in this argument. I state my opinion as an outsider looking in who has been there and done that and I speak from my experiences and that of others. A final thing to ponder....isn't it funny how most democrats, once they start to make real money, suddenly turn into Republicans? I tease my friend Jeremy (the IT admin) about this all the time..... ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 198 |
To those it may concern, I am not the one who started coining the term "evil rich white man" around here. I only bring race up as an issue to state demographics and social truths. If there were true equality I wouldn't have to link economic success and wealth to race, simply because in reality there would be an equal percentage of it for all races. This too goes for sex or any other type of classification. Now about the personal remarks. There is no call for personal attacks around here. If you disagree, then do so civilly. It is tasteless to attack, discredit, and marginalize me as a person, just because you disagree with what I say. The topic here is not whether or not you like Kwai-Chang Caine, so let's keep it from degenerating to that. Respect me as I have respected you. ------------------ - Kwai-Chang Caine ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Moderator ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 6822 |
quote: Yes, my skull is too thick. It is so thick that I have two graduate degrees and I am working on my PhD. I assume you are in the military (or have that line of thought) so I wouldn't expect you to understand what I am saying. BTW- Do not bother responding because I will be too thick to reply to your "enlightened" words of wisdom. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
So you're giving up then?!? Is your inflated ego so out of proportion with respect to reality that you can't take it when some "newbie" gets into your head? Some us do not around needlessly kissing ass to the mods. I'm sorry if you are used to getting this kind of treatment by the majority, but you won't get it from me unless you deserve it. And I can't believe that you resort to listing your "credentials" as if that increases your credibility in this topic!!! I envision some little 4 year old stomping his foot on the floor saying, "I AM SMART!! LOOK AT ME!! I GOT AN OUTSTANDING ON MY SCIENCE FAIR PROJECT!!" And you are no better than those writers in the various bodybuilding rags who, while writing about physiology, list their extensive list of credentials. Then you later come to find out that these writers have a Ph.D. in english or zoology. This hardly qualifies them as an authority in such a different field. I have an very extensive education as well. But I don't go around waving it in the faces of those who I disagree with. They say that the best teacher is experience. Any employer will tell you that experience is far greater than any college education. You obviously missed that little tid-bit about life. My knowledge in this field comes from experience with friends, family, and others who I talk to on the street. I've probably met over 200 self-made people in my life. They all came from nothing. And they echo my sentiment. So by all means don't answer. I wouldn't want the "mighty" 2Thick to have to waste his precious time. I'm sure you need this time to give out your pathetic low dose cycle advice over at the anabolic board. That is all. ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 90 |
This thread is getting out of control and I hope 2Thick deletes it... ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
It's a shame that a good thread has to die because some people start acting like kids. Don't delete it - at least ask a mod to lock it if it gets ugly. Good stuff in here. -Warik ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() Posts: 222 |
Myo-Genetic and Warik for Pres and Vice in 2004! ------------------ ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||
Elite Bodybuilder ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 848 |
quote: Change the order of the names and we might have a good idea on our hands. =) -Warik ------------------ BY THE POWER OF GRAYSKULL!!! ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
All times are ET (US) | |
![]() |
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.45c