Elite Fitness Bodybuilding, Anabolics, Diet, Life Extension, Wellness, Supplements, and Training Boards
Anabolic Discussion Board !!!!!___Cutting Before Bulking___!!!!!
|
Author | Topic: !!!!!___Cutting Before Bulking___!!!!! | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
Hey bros. Let me start with a friendly shout out from Michigan! (Yeah, Wolverines are gonna tear Auburn apart New Year's Day). Everyone here can agree that being huge and lean is a superior state of being. Some brothers place emphasis on the hugeness, while others (like myself) consider leanness closer to godliness. Which is better? Trick question, obviously, the answer is being both huge AND lean. Many brothers discuss their cycles and stats on the boards, and many cite their bodyfat % being around 20. They then ask for suggestions for these elaborate (and impressive) bulking cycles, and then mention they will do a cutting cycle later. As I prepare to embark upon a physiological journey, I asked myself "why bulk, then cut, if bodyfat % is high to start with". I could find no good answer to that, and here are some of my reasons. 1) Bodyfat is a location for the aromitization of certain AS into estrogens. More bodyfat, more aromitization, more estrogen. Estrogen promotes fat gains. 2) When you lose fat (naturally, or with only mild "supplementation") muscle loss is inevitable. As you start to carry more and more muscle on your body, the easier it becomes to lose it. Conversely, the further away from your body's muscle limit you are, the easier it is to gain muscle. If you diet and lose the fat before bulking, you will lose less muscle than if you bulk then cut. Lose a little muscle up front getting lean, make it up quicker as you bulk, and lose less muscle as you take off the few pounds of fat you might have added bulking. 3) Everything we do places stress on our body's structures. Some of this stress is good and will promote hugeness (like lifting). Some of it is bad (like slouching, using bad form, laying around like a lazy shit) and promotes osteoarthritis and other musculoskeletal problems. In either case our body is doing work. Work is described as force times distance. Using heavy weight while lifting increases work, and helps us get huge. Carrying around 20 or more unnecessary pounds of fat every second while you do the mundane activities of your life accelerates the development of musculoskeletal problems. Lose the fat before you bulk, so that after you gain 20 pounds of muscle and 3 pounds of fat, you aren't placing so much damn negative stress on your body. 4) Elevated bodyfat levels is a metabolic disorder in itself, and is a major risk factor for other metabolic and cardiovascular disorders. Take Joe Smith, a hard lifting (but natural) brother who has decided that the time has come to cross to the other side. Joe weighs 190 at 12% bodyfat (22.8 pounds fat, 167.2 pounds lean body mass). He wants to weigh 205 at 8% before too long. In scenario 1, Joe makes breaks the cherry with a fine bulking cycle, gaining 30lbs muscle and 4 lbs of fat in 10 weeks. Joe now has 14.6% bodyfatat 224 pounds and has to lose a lot of fat before he's satisfied. He'll lose a lot of muscle with that too, even with the ECA or clen. In scenario 2, Joe keeps his protein intake high but his calorie intake slightly limited, and while he gains less muscle (18 pounds) on his cycle, he takes off a pound of fat. At 207 pounds, Joe has 10.5% bodyfat, and can see a bit of abs. In scenario 3, Joe uses some supplements to lose fat before he gains muscle. He uses clen, or ECA, and some primo or other gear, whatever. In one 2on-3off cycle he loses 8 pounds of fat and 1 pound of muscle (being a pessimist, chances are "Joe" will gain some muscle and lose the fat). After 5 weeks he is 181 lbs at 8.2% bodyfat. He is aso ready for another cycle. If Joe does his bulking cycle in scenario 1 (with the same results, gaining 30 pounds of muscle and 4 pounds fat), Joe is 215 pounds at 8.7% bodyfat. Joe hasn't got to do much to get down to below 8%. Other things can enter into these equations (DNP, for example, which I'm not willing to use, for health reasons). I know that getting from 10% to 8% is a bitch. But even accounting for these "other factors", if you have a moderately high bodyfat %, cutting before you bulk makes sense for your looks and your health. Best wishes bros. Peace! ------------------ | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 93 |
Excellent post! I learned this the hard way. I was so eager to get "big", I didn't think about the fact that what I really wanted was to get "big and lean". One other advantage of dieting first: I've discovered that I don't need to eat as many total calories to gain while bulking, so I can focus on getting quality calories from whole foods with high protien, instead of just downing everything in sight. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 139 |
Great points, bump from a fellow G.R. bro. | ||
Elite Bodybuilder Posts: 1316 |
very well done post. ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
Good thing about this board is that it moves so fast, the bad thing (besides the scammers, dumbf*<ks, and occasional self-righteous moron parroting shit that was wrong the first time) is that a decent post can slip off the front page in an hour and a half. Guess I'll add another story about Joe while I'm bumping this. A friend, let's call him Joe Smith, is planning to put his 190 animal on a cycle come the new year. The cycle looks like this: Day__Fina__Dbol__T-prop_Arimidex_Finasteride_Clomid_ _____(mg)__(mg)___(mg)____(mg)______(mg)______(mg) 1___________________________________5__________50 2__________________________________2.5__________ 3__________________________________2.5_________50 4_____50____50_____50_____.5_______1.25__________ 5_____50____50____________.25______1.25________50 6_____50____50_____50_____.25______1.25__________ 7_____50____50____________.25______1.25________50 8_____50____50_____50_____.25______1.25__________ 9_____50____50____________.25______1.25________50 10____50____50_____50_____.25______1.25__________ 11____50____45____________.25______1.25________50 12____50____40_____50_____.25______1.25__________ 13____50____35____________.25______1.25________50 14____50____30_____50_____.25______1.25__________ 15____50____25____________.25______1.25_______150 16____50____20____________.25______1.25_______150 17_________________________________1.25_______100 18_________________________________1.25________50 19_________________________________1.25________50 20_________________________________1.25________50 21_________________________________1.25________50 22_________________________________1.25________50 23_________________________________1.25________50 24_________________________________1.25________50 25_________________________________1.25________50 26_________________________________1.25________50 Joe lives in a blessed land where it is completely legal to give his animal such supplements. He is giving it arimidex to prevent the poor thing from growing multiple breasts, clomid to make sure it restarts natural hormone production, and finasteride because it would be a shame if the animal's nice shiny coat of hair got patchy (oh yeah, he is also going to bathe it daily with a spironolactone shampoo, and nizoral) ------------------ | ||
Moderator Posts: 1281 |
Great post ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 440 |
Wow!!! I saved your last post to my HD when you posted cycles and info. Man, where do you get this stuff??? I am going to save this thread too. Great post. B True | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 201 |
You are right. I think everyone would cut first except they lack the will power to diet. I'm always trying to discourage fat asses not to take fina thinking that they can burn fat and grow at the same time. The real answer for fat dudes in mediocre condition is to lift naturally while calorie restricting down to sub 10%. Yet the myth of magic fina goes on. Excellent post. Sorry I know nothing about hair loss stuff. | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 11 |
Let me hear an Amen! | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
Mr.Lean my friend glad to see you. To the other bros who don't know Mr.Lean here he is a stand-up guy. Sure, he's a newbie here at Elite, but for what it is worth I'll vouch for him (no he's not a source damnnit!). Bro I'll fill you in on the do's and don'ts, in the meantime kick back and watch why Elite is the fastest paced and one of the most knowledgeable boards around. Peace! ------------------ | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 297 |
"Bodyfat is a location for the aromitization of certain AS into estrogens. More bodyfat, more aromitization, more estrogen." Does aromitization actually occur in the fat? I think it aromitizes the same in a fat dude as it would in a lean guy?? Am I wrong? Jay | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 410 |
That was good, so good that my fat ass will go on a cutting cycle before my bulk cycle! | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 98 |
From by Biochem expirence (6 years formal education) I do not believe any of the listed AS have that notoious =C bond. So the finasteride I believe will not effect this cycle. I do not have the chemical structures on had, so I would double check this. ------------------ | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 202 |
interesting, something to think about ------------------ "Don't Hate the GAME Hate the FAME" -me | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
JayIsCrazy, I'm going by memory but I recall that aromitase is active in, and is stored in, fat cells. I have read studies indicating healthy men with higher bodyfat levels experience more aromitization of natural testosterone than men with lower bodyfat, from the mechanisms noted above. The same mechanisms will affect injected test the same. Madhacker, the only one I know will have the =C bond will be the test in the test prop. Thanks for the input my brothers, keep it coming. Peace! ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 323 |
Dr Atlas, I agree with your post, however do you think a persons metabolism would be a good deal faster if they were carrying 25-35 additional LBM? I can gain muscle by looking at a weight, however I have to work my ass off to see my abbs. I can not get in enough protein and carbs to fuel my workouts and drop fat at the same time. Since I have started juicing about a year ago (doing second cycle now) I am finding it easier to keep my body fat down to a reasonable level and still eat enough to feel strong. I agree a lean body is much better than a fat bloated body, I just feel it may be easier with a faster metabolism. ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
Howdy Neighbor. Yes, an increase in LBM will increase your metabolism, increasing the tendency of your body to burn calories (and muscle, metabolism= anabolism +catabolism). Truth be told, being truly lean is an abnormal state for the body; your body wants to keep some fat reserves, typically no lower than 10%. Point 2 above applies: 2) When you lose fat (naturally, or with only mild "supplementation") muscle loss is inevitable. As you start to carry more and more muscle on your body, the easier it becomes to lose it. Conversely, the further away from your body's muscle limit you are, the easier it is to gain muscle. If you diet and lose the fat before bulking, you will lose less muscle than if you bulk then cut. Lose a little muscle up front getting lean, make it up quicker as you bulk, and lose less muscle as you take off the few pounds of fat you might have added bulking. If you are below 13% (give or take), this thread doesn't apply to you as much. The higher metabolism is a mixed blessing when your body is perfectly willing to burn "extra" muscle for the sake of its fat reserves. Dieting can suck bro. Doing keto cycles I needed the ECA for the intensity it lent me. I think 5 weeks is not too long to devote to fat loss though, not when you will be ready to bulk at the end. I firmly believe that the bulking/cutting guidelines in point 2 are true. Peace! ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 323 |
Thanks for your input Doc, I pretty much have to get on a keto diet to loose fat and still get enough protein in my diet. I have found it very hard to keep the intensity up in the gym. Squating intensely while in ketosis is almost impossible for me I get very faint and have actually lost my hearing for a minute or two. Ahh, I wish there was an easier answer but I know there is not. I am not a fat pig by any means but I have some work to do to get into those single digits by spring. Can't wait to get the boat out and cruise the channel in Grand Haven!!!!! This weather sucks the big one I can not wait until the summer!!!! Gotta be sportin the six pack for the girls on the pier!! ------------------ | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 171 |
Excellent post!I was one of those guys who carried an excess of 15lbs or more around my waist.Went straight into a bulk diet & cycle & yes i got bigger & stronger,but that damned fat started to feel like i was carrying house bricks around 24/7.In hindsight i now know not to waste time & money on juice when fat.Quality rather than quantity for me. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 151 |
bump | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
One last bump! ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 562 |
Why would you use that much arimidex on your animal. Studies have shown that there is only a small difference between using 1mg ed and using 10mg ed. Studies have also shown that estrogen suppression in and of itself does not contribute to the retention of lean bodymass or the loss of adipose tissue. For the increadibly tiny amount of testosterone that your animal is using, it shouldn't have significant edema or risk of gynocomastia. At those doses 1/4mg ed would be more than enough. By the way, I think it is a good idea to get rid of the fat first so you will look better while bulking and retain less water. giantset ------------------ | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
Yeah, Joe is considering doing .25mg EOD. It depends upon the bloat from the dbol and test. The dbol concerns me more than that little t-prop. If he doesn't note any sides on .25mg eod I'm sure he'll keep it that way, but he's stocking up enough to allow .25mg ED. Thanks for the input Giantset. Peace! ------------------ | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 52 |
My biggest concern about your other-wise great post: If I go on a keto diet for 4 weeks, and then come off and go right into a 10 weeks bulking cycle, won't I gain fat even faster than a normal bulking cycle where I did not diet? My metabolism is going to be slowed down from the diet, and I'm thinking I'm going to blow up if I suddenly reverse from eating 1,400 calories straight into 4,500 calories per day. I'm assuming that until my metabolism kick-starts itself again, I'm going to be running a massive calorie surplus there... | ||
Novice Posts: 4 |
Hello Dr. Atlas, I enjoy reading your posts, I believe you have a vast knowledge of nutrition, physiology, and bio-chemistry and certainly do not mind sharing it with the board. I believe you do have one major drawback though: MICHIGAN SUCKS...GO BUCKEYES! Well, now that I have that off my chest, could you plese read my "NEWBIE" post and comment? I am carrying quite a higher percentage of bodyfat than I am comfortable with, which is why I have selected the "gear" listed. I would appreciate any input and suggestions you might have. Please keep the OSU vs. MICHIGAN flames to a minimum. PEACE | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
Stalker, the only way I'd ever suggest doing keto diets is to cycle keto phases of 5-7 days with carb-up phases of 2 days, a la Lyle McDonald, BodyOpus etc. That should not shut down your metabolism too bad. I wouldn't drop quite as low as 1400 kcal (well it depends on your bodyweight) and 4500 might be a little much. I am on the short-cycle bandwagon right now, but have considered many long cycles in the past. Get a set of cheap plastic bodyfat calipers and take abdominal skinfolds when you start bulking. If the folds increase too quickly, back off on the calories. Hope it helps. KIDD, look on the bright side, OSU is getting a new quarterback this year yeah? PS I was rooting for OSU to beat Purdue. Peace!
[This message has been edited by Dr.Atlas (edited December 07, 2000).] | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 58 |
hey bro..i like the real stuff the NFL not the kid stuff.
| ||
Cool Novice Posts: 11 |
hey stalker, If your metabolism is lower, you can gain the same muscle with less calories. We don't just eat for the sake of eating. Your goal shouldn't be to eat 5,000 C. It should be to eat just enough to support optimal muscle gain with minimal fat accumulation. I think a lower metabolism is as big a plus for people on a bulking cycle as a fast one is for people on a cutting cycle. I doubt your metabolism would go down much in 4 weeks anyway. Most people get at least 5 weeks before the slowdown sets in. Four weeks of strait keto gives my the geebees. Do cyclic keto for six weeks instead. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 139 |
good post doc...btw, can anyone confirm what the ratio of fat:muscle is when you lose weight. I read in Arnold's encyclopedia that for every pound you lose 60% of it is muscle, and 40%fat. Anyone have any papers or evidence of this? | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 27 |
Awesome post bro!!! Mass Monster -------------- | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 11 |
60% of weight lost is muscle? That is absolute bullshit. In a fasting state, and how could it get worse than that? You'd lose 50% muscle and 50% fat. This is well documented. A general population on a high carb, low fat, low (50g/day) protein diet lose about one lb of muscle for every 3 lbs of fat. Now throw in some weight training, and those same folks would have gained muscle and lost fat. If you're natural you should be able to diet down to 10% with almost no muscle loss. Eat a bodybuilder diet and lift. Now two conditions seriously threaten muscle. Going from 10% to 5% often burns some muscle. Also dieting burns muscle when you have more muscle mass than your body can maintain naturally. In the former case prudent assistance from a meticulous diet, ephedrine, clenbuterol, t3, whatever can combat this. In the later, you would need to use anabolics during your diet to prevent serious loss. This is one of the reasons the doc is right on when he says diet before thy cycle. | ||
Cool Novice Posts: 37 |
wow... great post Dr.Atlas. Answered my question... will lose some weight before I start my first cycle. This board is great. ------------------ You can run but you'll just be tired when I catch you. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 139 |
Lean, "if you're natural you can get bodyfat down to about 10%"- I'm having a tough time with this. It seems when I do cut back on the calories, the weight will go down, although my waist size remains the same. Any ideas? | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 366 |
Excellent post Mr Atlas. Just curious, what would be your perfect cutting cycle (in the 8 week range)???? | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 562 |
Dr. Atlas, I feel like a moron. I was looking at the numbers for finasteride and somehow thought those were the numbers for arimidex. I was like, 2.5mg ed then 1.25mg, that is way too much. 0.25mg ed is fine, but using that much eod might work just as well. I am not sure how well arimidex works on edema related to dbol. Is the dbol bloat due entirely from aromitization or is it due to its non AR mediated results? giantset ------------------ | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 52 |
Dr. Atlas & Mr. Lean -- thanks for the advice. I'm going to give cyclic keto a try for a 4 to 6 weeks period, until I feel lean enough to switch over to a bulk cycle. | ||
Amateur Bodybuilder Posts: 225 |
bump! | ||
Pro Bodybuilder Posts: 519 |
Giantset, I think the aromitization is a big player in the bloat. Do I have hard evidence for that? No. But after talking with some brothers with dbol and arimidex experience, they reported staying cut throughout their cycle. Always02, in my opinion the perfect cutting cycle is shorter than 8 weeks, but if I were to do one it might be Fina 75eod, t-prop 100eod, winny (inject, though I prefer drinking or tabs 50ed) 100eod. One inject every other day. A little arimidex will prevent any bloat from that mild t-prop usage and the fina and winny promote that hard dry look. Peace! ------------------ |
All times are ET (US) | |