 UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! |
 George Spellwin's ELITE FITNESS Discussion Boards
 Anabolic Discussion Board
 Ethnicity And Muscle Size
|
| Author | Topic: Ethnicity And Muscle Size |
|
Pops Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 172) |
posted June 20, 2000 04:51 AM
  
hello guys, ive often wondered about different races and their ability to gain muscle. as we all know, africans rule when it comes to genetics, it gets no better, either in bodybuilding or sports. then you got the germans and eastern europeans who also generally have very good genetics for muscle size. of course you have other races who are not so blessed for muscle size: asians, hispanics, etc. being of mexican indian and spanish decent, my genetics are nasty for bodybulding. i suppose that each race has its attributes depending on the sport. my question is: what is the ethnic profile of elite fitness members and how would you rate your success in weight training (strength, size and training history)? HONESTLY. race: hispanic(mexican indian x spanish) weight:210 lbs strength: below average, bench press: 225 for 1 rep size: slightly above average, 16 1/4 inch arms training history: ive been training WITH CARBS since january. i know the size and strength category is pretty vague, but its the best i could think of, any suggestions? -Pops IP: Logged |
|
scott825 Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 353) |
posted June 20, 2000 05:06 AM
Im full german & have always thought that it may play a role in the good genetics i have ,but who knows.. this topic might go better in the C&C IP: Logged |
|
Ph4t Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 153) |
posted June 20, 2000 05:07 AM
wow... 225 is pretty light when compared to your weight. ..train hard for strength, you'll see big results. IP: Logged |
|
Natymike Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 179) |
posted June 20, 2000 05:52 AM
I learned in plenty of History classes that when slave selection took place, they selected only the biggest and strongest of all the Africans, this explains why Africans in the US have such unbelievable genetics, its because they inherited them from their ancestors. IP: Logged |
|
dahmer Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 279) |
posted June 20, 2000 08:47 AM
Asian-Ectomorph I am a really hard gainer. Just started my first and I think I have found what it takes to get large!!! All those years of lifting and all the supps never gave me what this little mini cycle has done so far!!! I am a true believer in the power of GEAR!!! Already planning next cycle and I am not even half way through with this one!!! IP: Logged |
|
mightydog Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 197) |
posted June 20, 2000 09:16 AM
Its a fact that different races have a different proportion of fast twich muscle fibers. But look at the bright side, in these countries where genetics are so so, they can get roids much easier! IP: Logged |
|
Irish Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 20) |
posted June 20, 2000 09:17 AM
Irish, best damn genetics out there!!!!!!!! 6'0 220# Above average strength. I don't push a max because i was a pitcher in college and ended up having surgery on elbow. IP: Logged |
|
Iron God Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 93) |
posted June 20, 2000 02:06 PM
Generalizations about race like that are hard to back up with hard evidence I say Americans are by far the physically largest and strongest race of people on Earth and it has much to do with our economic environment,society and our diverse gene pool. Plus food here is dirt cheap!! ------------------ IP: Logged |
|
SCHNiKEN Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 397) |
posted June 20, 2000 02:32 PM
How would you guys rate italions? IP: Logged |
|
mightydog Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 197) |
posted June 20, 2000 02:41 PM
Thats right Irish! You got to have the liver of an Irishman to handle lots of orals too. Problem with us Limmys and Irish is fighting all this friggin hair! IP: Logged |
|
lorenzo Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 165) |
posted June 20, 2000 02:58 PM
Irish mostly with American Indian. Stronger than average I suppose.... 365 x 6 on bench, squat 585 x 8 .....have never done a single rep max. 5'8" 205 IP: Logged |
|
mightydog Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 197) |
posted June 20, 2000 03:04 PM
Want to see strong. Check out pacific islanders, esp. the well fed ones! IP: Logged |
|
ItalianSweetness Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 291) |
posted June 20, 2000 03:06 PM
Irish People: --- I am not flaming you. If u guys get great results, more power to you. I am italian and i have lots of irish friends although we don't get along,hehehha. Anyway.....i have to say Irish people have the worst genetics i have seen of any persons around. They just can't get big that easy. I guess the irish curse comes in two forms now huh? heeheheh Us italians don't have probs gettin big. I grow almost as good without roids, seriously. How many big italians did u see compared to irish.........maybe 100 to 1! IP: Logged |
|
ItalianSweetness Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 291) |
posted June 20, 2000 03:08 PM
Bump so all the irish can get mad! (kiddin  )IP: Logged |
|
morereps Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 188) |
posted June 20, 2000 03:09 PM
German myself. Live in US now. 5'8" 220 good genetics chest 48" before bodybuilding after 2 years 50" waist 32"
IP: Logged |
|
PeteyPete Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 74) |
posted June 20, 2000 03:22 PM
i'm not sure if i believe theories on ethnicity and muscle growth completely, i'm half irish and half italian and i have no prob gaining weight. Before i ever lifted a weight i had that naturally thin and lean build i got from my irish side, but i eat and lift and have been able to overcome my ectomorph genetics without any probs. I know people of every race whom have great genetics and shitty genetics. For example, Most asians are small, but there is this one vietnamese kid in my gym whom is huge. I do believe that mabye african americans may be able to put muscle on faster then white's or asians, but from my experience they're usually never as strong, At my gym there is one black guy who looks bigger everytime i see him, nevertheless he's not strong at all. There are always exceptions, there are easy and hard gainers in every race IP: Logged |
|
lorenzo Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 165) |
posted June 20, 2000 07:43 PM
most of us Irish in America are of the diluted form. In other words I am a mutt...a good portion Irish then American Indian, English and who knows what the hell else. IP: Logged |
|
AY Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 211) |
posted June 20, 2000 08:49 PM
I have to disagree with you there, Pete. I've seen several black guys and I personally believe they are blessed with the best genetics and strength. It may be because they possess more fast-twitch muscles. I've not yet come across a muscular black guy who was weak. Being born of Asian stock myself, I honestly think that my generation still lacks in terms of size and strength. The younger generation, though, is relatively bigger. I think that the food they eat and the abundance of food plays a part in determining the size. I will not call myself a hardgainer, though, and while I started out small, I have totally changed my physique. AY IP: Logged |
|
glenbenton Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 436) |
posted June 20, 2000 09:09 PM
its true bro the blacks and itialians have the full genitic muscle advantage. i know this shit for a fact. irish germans like myself have a shitload of a hard time gaining the kind of muscle that blacks and itialians can gain easy. all my itialian friends could gain the kind of muscle in a couple monthes naturally that would take me a year or two to gain. its just the facts look at how much more ripped black dudes are with out having to even work out that often. look at every one of these black guys on mtv in the videos they are all ripped to the max. i doubt these guys dedicate their lives to weightlifting they just good black genes IP: Logged |
|
flossin1 Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 115) |
posted June 20, 2000 09:23 PM
German and not disapointed. IP: Logged |
|
Spunky Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 79) |
posted June 20, 2000 09:32 PM
I was not fortunate enough to have good genetics. But i've found w/ ppl like me who have to work hard to gain muscle tend to have a more of a drive. Sometimes thosed blessed w/ good genetics get lazy, they aren't forced to work as hard. I on the other hand try to work twice as hard as my genetically blessed friends so I can keep up w/ them. And eat twice as hard! IP: Logged |
|
Marauder Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 486) |
posted June 20, 2000 09:44 PM
I'm scot-irish with a little American indian. I come from a long line of hellraising athletes like amateur boxers and track and football players...a few of my clan is in the special forces as well...although I hope to be the first navy SEAL. I have no problems getting in shape, for some reason my brother and I were always stronger and faster than any of the other kids in the neighborhood we lived in...we would always run around starting ;ittle "wars" ha ha damn i miss that shit! Marauder out. (sorry to rant) ------------------ IP: Logged |
|
Zeke_B Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 24) |
posted June 20, 2000 10:38 PM
Watch those Worlds Strongest Man Competitions The winners are usually Scandinavian. (Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Finland). Those dudes aren't built like bodybuilders though. I am pretty much American mutt. I'm about IP: Logged |
|
biggmack Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 188) |
posted June 20, 2000 10:53 PM
I've always had the assumption that African Americans have the best muscle building ability, and cutting ability! IP: Logged |
|
Spunky Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 79) |
posted June 20, 2000 10:59 PM
I agree w/ the african american theory. There are several black guys that workout at my gym, they all seem to gain muscle quite easily, and are very very strong. IP: Logged |
|
gearface Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 194) |
posted June 20, 2000 11:10 PM
I'm caucasion and I think I have pretty good genetics. ------------------ IP: Logged |
|
TwinGATs Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 196) |
posted June 20, 2000 11:16 PM
I don't believe blacks get bigger easier, but they tend to stay leaner easier.... IP: Logged |
|
Latimer Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 248) |
posted June 20, 2000 11:30 PM
I see a lot of good points some of you have made. Here's my opinion on the matter... FUCK GENETICS. Go bust your ass in the gym. Too many people use genetics as an excuse. You got good genetics, great more power to you. You don't got good genetics, then accept the fact and bust your ass even harder. Again that's just my opinion. I'm not flaming anyone who posted or anything. This thread is quite interesting actually. I heard people of African descent have more red muscle fibers which makes them faster and have more endurance. For instance a cheetah is loaded with red muscle fibers. People of European descent have more white mucle fibers so this would in turn make them stronger and geared toward power. All this shit is cool and we're gonna find out way more as science progresses but ultimately I don't think anyone should use their race for an excuse. Peace IP: Logged |
|
Recoome Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 14) |
posted June 20, 2000 11:37 PM
The most genetically gifted people are Northern Europeans/Scandinavians. I believe it has to do something with descending from Vikings. Samoans bulk up pretty easily too, though they have probelms with water retention. IP: Logged |
|
lorenzo Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 165) |
posted June 20, 2000 11:37 PM
It's true... you never really know unless you really bust your ass and find out. When you say "I have bad genetics" you are telling yourself that being second best is ok because there is nothing you can do about it. You will not know until you train your ass off. Be the best YOU can be.... don't worry about anyone else. IP: Logged |
|
Spunky Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 79) |
posted June 20, 2000 11:44 PM
thats my philosophy.. AMEN to that!!!!! IP: Logged |
|
Curious Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 191) |
posted June 20, 2000 11:51 PM
German...sheist! ------------------ IP: Logged |
|
TheBear Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 136) |
posted June 21, 2000 12:02 AM
ummm Nate I heard that theory too.(only the strongest blacks were picked, hence they are the strongest today) Not only is that a fallacy of arguement, it is quite racist. There were Millions of slaves in North America. While some were picked based on physiques, that was not a requisite; the color of their skin put them in slavery. Millions of African Americans were of average to very below average genetics. Your theory is just antiquated ideology my man. please research before you blaze a comment like that cuz that is so untrue. Most of these posts are pretty racist to. It is quite comparable to commenting that blacks have smaller brains, and asians are all intelligent. Old myths people! IP: Logged |
|
lorenzo Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 165) |
posted June 21, 2000 12:13 AM
Why are these observations racist? Why when we discuss our observations there is a lable of racism attached? I'm white and people are generalizing here about white, blacks, asians,etc. I'm not offended. They may be generalizations and are not always true (thus the term generalization) but these are just things that we see and are discussing them here. IP: Logged |
|
lorenzo Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 165) |
posted June 21, 2000 12:17 AM
One more thing. You said that Nates statement was fallacy of arguement...then you proceed to say that infact there is some truth to his statement:
IP: Logged |
|
TheBear Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 136) |
posted June 21, 2000 12:19 AM
I call it like i see it Lorenzo. If you cannot see that the comment that Blacks are bigger because of slavery, then you are quite ignorant. It is an antiquated theory that has been proven wrong, and it is only ignorant people that speak of it these days. I have many black friends that get VERY offended when it is brought up. Im not going into the reasons it has been disproved because you can do that on your own. This is an anabolic chat. You said it yourself, that you are talking about generalizations and how it doesnt offend YOU. Well dude, many people will disagree with you. Its easy not to let generalizations get to you when you are part of the white majority bro. IP: Logged |
|
TheBear Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 136) |
posted June 21, 2000 12:30 AM
Lorenzo that is not a fallacy! While some were picked on their physiques...it had nothing to do with modern genetics! That was my point, hence not a fallacy..You were reading too much into my statement IP: Logged |
|
TheBear Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 136) |
posted June 21, 2000 12:41 AM
Lorenzo that is not a fallacy! While some were picked on their physiques...it had nothing to do with modern genetics! That was my point, hence not a fallacy..You were reading too much into my statement IP: Logged |
|
lorenzo Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 165) |
posted June 21, 2000 12:41 AM
Well, it's true that I cannot empathise because I will never be able to veiw this from any other perspective than my own. They may be offended but it doesn't mean that we are not entitled to discuss here what we are discussing. When a (balck)person says that white people can't jump or dance, etc. I may be offended too, but I have to deal with that on my own. I do know however that there may be in a general veiw, truth to that statement. To this point the people on the thread have tried to avoid stereotypes and ingnorance. Maybe someone had false information that they posted here and you made the correction, now they know.very good. If not for this discussion that person would have continued to believe that his information was correct. So, we have made progress in race relations. Incredible how talking about things helps everyone. IP: Logged |
|
costanza Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 51) |
posted June 21, 2000 01:54 AM
Regarding the strongest man competitions - in addition to the German and Nordic peoples you see the big Scots. I have a lot of that Scottish in me from Mom's side (and unfortunately some bad genes from Dad, who is not only small but skinny - but wiry and strong). All in all it isn't a bad combo as I am both coordinated and strong - but all in all I'd rather be black. Then I'd have these strong shoulders without this gut. IP: Logged |
|
THE STEEL BEAST Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 468) |
posted June 21, 2000 02:51 AM
GERMAN HERE............MOM MADE IT TO THE OLYMPICS AS AN ALTERNATE FOR THE GERMAN NATIONAL TEAM.MAN WAS SHE DIESEL.....I THANK HER FOR WHAT IVE GOT ------------------ One more road to cross The only difference between me and a madman is that I am not mad. BLOOD LIKE VENOM, IP: Logged |
|
Recoome Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 14) |
posted June 21, 2000 02:56 AM
Well I'm black, and I sure as hell don't gain easily... IP: Logged |
|
glenbenton Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 436) |
posted June 21, 2000 03:51 AM
my dad is responsible for my bad genes the fucking bastard. all skinny fucks on his side with no ability to gain quality muscle at all. so i think im gonna turn to growth hormones in a few years IP: Logged |
|
scott825 Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 353) |
posted June 21, 2000 08:22 AM
bump for us Germans!! genetic freaks! IP: Logged |
|
mightydog Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 197) |
posted June 21, 2000 08:40 AM
Wasn't there a movie called "White men can't jump?" My point is that race and sport is pretty much main stream when compairing values. Whether its a healthy subject to indulge is up for debate as I have noticed in some threads above. I was not affended by that title, and even if i was, who would give a shit. IP: Logged |
|
DoctorSavage Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 167) |
posted June 21, 2000 02:28 PM
Lads; Trying to censor yourself for any racist implications with a topic like this is fairly ridiculous. Take it with a grain of salt and try not to get your panties in a bunch. As to the question of African genetics, it has been my observation during several hundred autopsies I had to help with while serving with the JAG that People of African descent are more likely to store body fat within the body cavity underneath the abdominal wall, where as most europeans store it over the muscle and on the side (oblique) area. As to distribution of strength, statistically I would say that Africans have a smaller spread than Europeans, but that spread has a higher average than their pasty faced cousins. On the other hand there are more Europeans at both ends of the spectrum. This means that in strength sports you will see a sligtly higher number of Europeans, but on average, the African guy you meet at the gym will probably be stronger than you. ------------------ IP: Logged |
|
BigWh1tey Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 82) |
posted June 21, 2000 03:28 PM
IM A FUCKING BIG WHITE GUY 1/2 IRISH , 1/2 GERMAN. ------------------ IP: Logged |
|
BigT Pro Bodybuilder (Total posts: 218) |
posted June 21, 2000 03:49 PM
I don't like to generalize...I've seen guys who look like little asswipes bench twice their bodyweight, and I've seen guys with such incredible muscle size and cuts that you do a double-take who can't even bench their own weight....certainly all races have characteristics they are known for, but I think it is unfair to generalize. btw in response to a post before...I have seen black bros who look like a million dollars but are weak as hell, I think it is because they are naturally muscular without training so they look good, but without much training in the gym, they are not as strong as they look. IP: Logged |
|
wannagrow Amateur Bodybuilder (Total posts: 12) |
posted June 21, 2000 05:25 PM
5'10, 170lb, 9% bf...asian.. As an asian i feel like i am screwed..but it's not true for all asian. A lot of Koreans are very big (husky built) while the chinese are usually small frame, lengthy built. And that is why i am on this site...researching i can break the genetic barrier and stereotype. what do u all think? IP: Logged |
All times are ET (US) | |
 |
Contact Us | Back to Elite Fitness
Elite Fitness Discussion Board